Longitudinal models for self-rated health in extant research
| Study . | Models Considered . | Final Model . | Comparison . | Correct for Measurement Error . |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bauldry et al. (2012) | Random effects (quadratic); fixed effects | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | No | No |
| Berdahl and McQuillan (2018) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Brown et al. (2016) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (linear) | Yes (likelihood ratio test) | No |
| Ferraro et al. (1997) | Autoregressive | Autoregressive | No | No |
| Foraker et al. (2011) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | No | No |
| Hargrove and Brown (2015) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Kosloski et al. (2005) | Autoregressive | Autoregressive | No | Yes |
| Lazar et al. (2007) | Autoregressive | Autoregressive | No | No |
| Leopold (2019) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Lersch et al. (2018) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Liang et al. (2010) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| McCullough and Laurenceau (2004) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (cubic) | Yes (Δ deviance) | No |
| McCullough and Laurenceau (2005) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (cubic) | No | No |
| McDonough and Berglund (2003) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (linear) | Yes; not shown | No |
| McDonough et al. (2005) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Meadows (2009) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Miller and Wolinsky (2007) | Linear regression | Linear regression | No | No |
| Mirowsky and Ross (2008) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Rohlfsen and Kronenfeld (2014) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Sargent-Cox et al. (2010) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | Yes (Δ chi-square) | No |
| Shuey and Willson (2008) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | No | No |
| Sokol et al. (2017) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | No | No |
| Takahashi et al. (2018) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Wilkinson et al. (2012) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | No | No |
| Willson et al. (2007) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | No | No |
| Wolinsky et al. (2008) | Mixed effects (fixed + random effects) | Mixed effects (square root of slope) | No | No |
| Yang and Lee (2009) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | Yes; not shown | No |
| Yao and Robert (2008) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | Yes (Δ AIC) | No |
| Zajacova and Burgard (2010) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | Yes; intercept and slope only |
| Study . | Models Considered . | Final Model . | Comparison . | Correct for Measurement Error . |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bauldry et al. (2012) | Random effects (quadratic); fixed effects | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | No | No |
| Berdahl and McQuillan (2018) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Brown et al. (2016) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (linear) | Yes (likelihood ratio test) | No |
| Ferraro et al. (1997) | Autoregressive | Autoregressive | No | No |
| Foraker et al. (2011) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | No | No |
| Hargrove and Brown (2015) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Kosloski et al. (2005) | Autoregressive | Autoregressive | No | Yes |
| Lazar et al. (2007) | Autoregressive | Autoregressive | No | No |
| Leopold (2019) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Lersch et al. (2018) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Liang et al. (2010) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| McCullough and Laurenceau (2004) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (cubic) | Yes (Δ deviance) | No |
| McCullough and Laurenceau (2005) | Random effects (linear, quadratic, cubic) | Random effects (cubic) | No | No |
| McDonough and Berglund (2003) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (linear) | Yes; not shown | No |
| McDonough et al. (2005) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Meadows (2009) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Miller and Wolinsky (2007) | Linear regression | Linear regression | No | No |
| Mirowsky and Ross (2008) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Rohlfsen and Kronenfeld (2014) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Sargent-Cox et al. (2010) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | Yes (Δ chi-square) | No |
| Shuey and Willson (2008) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | No | No |
| Sokol et al. (2017) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | No | No |
| Takahashi et al. (2018) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | No |
| Wilkinson et al. (2012) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | No | No |
| Willson et al. (2007) | Random effects (quadratic) | Random effects (little variation in slope; linear) | No | No |
| Wolinsky et al. (2008) | Mixed effects (fixed + random effects) | Mixed effects (square root of slope) | No | No |
| Yang and Lee (2009) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | Yes; not shown | No |
| Yao and Robert (2008) | Random effects (linear, quadratic) | Random effects (quadratic) | Yes (Δ AIC) | No |
| Zajacova and Burgard (2010) | Random effects (linear) | Random effects (linear) | No | Yes; intercept and slope only |