..., and are such that epistemic warrant is preserved across the episodes of fission and often involves quasimemories that are not memories. But what he says about memory does not support the denial that such creatures are possible. Where he thinks de se attitudes are necessary, de se * attitudes, indexed...

... position postulate conditions on objective empirical representation that are more intellectual than are warranted. Such views leave it doubtful that animals and human infants perceptually represent elements in the physical environment. By appeal to common sense and to empirical perceptual psychology, this...

... to this third condition as warrant.1 Thus, when p is true and S believes that p, S will know that p just in case p has warrant for S. But if p is false or S doesn’t believe that p, S will not know that p, even if p has warrant for S.2 We can now use the notion of warrant to introduce the other...

... Knowledge.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 70 : 417 –30. Davies, Martin. 1998 . “Externalism, Architecturalism, and Epistemic Warrant.” In Knowing Our Own Minds , ed. Crispin Wright, Barry C. Smith, and Cynthia Macdonald, 321 –61. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ———. 2000...

... use or use by others; moreover, it does so without adding to, or altering, the original epistemic status of the belief (see, for example, ibid., 466, 486–87 and 1997, 37). It just transfers the original warrant (if any) along with the belief, from one’s earlier self to one’s later self, or...

... warrant into an argument. When I recall a general fact, I use substantive content mem- ory. When I recall an event, I use experiential memory. When I use an earlier-instantiated step in an argument to combine with an inference rule, I rely on purely preservative memory. I introduced substantive...

... York: Cambridge University Press. Plantinga, Alvin. 1993 . Warrant: The Current Debate. New York: Oxford University Press. Quine, W.V. 1969 . “Epistemology Naturalized.” In Ontological Relativity and Other Essays, 69 -90. New York: Columbia University Press. Schmitt, Frederick. 1992...

... years. But there is further reason for surprise that more has not been done to bring them together. The chief bugaboo of contextualism has been the con- cern that the contextualist is mistaking variability in the conditions of warranted assertability of knowledge attributions for a variability in...

... with the justification of beliefs or the warrant of reason, but with explaining the presence of belief and how belief is retained in the face of skeptical arguments (177). Chapter 9. Owen’s final chapter moves into new territory and treats the con- ditions, if any, in Hume’s writings under which...

..., they diverge from it at a number ofjunctures- for example, Firth argues that what is crucial for foundational beliefs is not their certainty, but their self-warrant. In “Radical Empiricism and Perceptual Relativity,” Firth defends a ver- sion of radical empiricism against the “argument from...

... Quine, tells us there exist no num- bers at all, and so no prime numbers. Nominalists are aware that the assertion of the existence of prime numbers is warranted by the standards of mathe- matical science; they simply reject scientific standards of warrant. Nominalists insist on calling all...

... truth norm, the hearer may reasonably expect that the speaker has some warrant for what she says. The most plausible warrants for assertions that are not predictions or retrodic- tions will generally be, in conjunction with truth, sufficient for knowl- edge. Recall first DeRose’s distinction...

... Goodman and Quine, tells us there exist no num- bers at all, and so no prime numbers. Nominalists are aware that the assertion of the existence of prime numbers is warranted by the standards of mathe- matical science; they simply reject scientific standards of warrant. Nominalists insist on...

... be warranted in strengthening your belief that bananas are yellow. But, knowing the full story, doing so seems suspicious. Having an experience hijacked by what you believe undermines its capacity to support the belief that caused it. With full knowledge, this would not be rational. Against those...

... is rational for you to believe ϕ. And if ψ is a necessary condition for χ, then every ρ that is implied by ψ is a necessary condition for χ as well. So given that, as per (4), rational assertability is a necessary condition for warranted assertability and given that, by the belief-assertion...

... BOOK REVIEWS abstract, and its arguments insufficiently attentive to the evidence that arises within the narrative context of lived Christian experience. “Rationality” rather than justification or warrant is the key concept of epistemic appraisal by which faith commitments are judged...

... -20. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Goldman, A. 1967 . “A Causal Theory of Knowing.” Journal of Philosophy 64 : 357 -72. BOOK REVLEWS tal.” It offers an off-beat criticism of reliabilist accounts of warranted belief, and continues Firth’s cautious...

... every circumstance, and thus we must be able to tell, at least under conditions suitable for reflection, whether or not we ought to do so. Consequently, one of the most in-depth and interesting chapters in the book concerns warrant for both our nonnormative beliefs and our normative ones. The...

... predominant motivation is skeptical: theory systematically exceeds the reach of empirical warrant. Antirealists deny that explanatory power is evidential; realists deny that the reach of empirical warrant sum- marily terminates at the boundary of the observable. But these counter- arguments are mere...

... warrant investigation is the thought that transparency is merely the by-product of the redundancy associated with the truth predicate. Just as adding that p is true to one’s assertion of p is redundant, adding that one believes that p to be true adds noth- ing to one’s assertion that one believes that...