Search Results for response-dependence

...David Shoemaker This essay attempts to provide and defend what may be the first actual argument in support of P. F. Strawson's merely stated vision of a response-dependent theory of moral responsibility. It does so by way of an extended analogy with the funny. In part 1, it makes the easier...

... premise in the incompatibilist's argument and the Ockhamist response. It sketches some potential links between the issues here and recent work on ontological dependence, and it connects the issues raised by Merricks to important work that has appeared in (among other places) the Philosophical Review . ©...

... it. Recall this line from the Third Answer: You have a choice about whether God was in that mental state.… For, if God was in that mental state, God's having been in it depends on what you do at t . I think the proper response to any such suggestion mirrors what we said in the case of Jones's being...

...; the amusing; the shameful; and the pride-, guilt-, and anger-worthy 1 —are all “essentially emotion-dependent” (13). The second is its rationalist part: “the claim that to predicate one of these values is to hold that the relevant emotion F is a fitting response to its object x ”—in other words...

... of truth, reference, and realism should be utilized for this domain. The above gives readers a flavor for Gert's view. I end with a few observations. Although Gert maintains that his colors are objective, they seem response-dependent in the sense that we have no means of specifying or identifying...

... depending on the region of discourse to which it belongs” (6). The cruces discussed by Wright are Evidence Transcendence (familiar from Dummett and Putnam), the Euthyphro Contrast (response-dependence), Cognitive Command (Wright’s pro- posal on behalf of the relativist), and Width of Cosmological Role...

... moral values as revealed in their conduct, about which our judgments may be true or false. On this view, the fairness or propriety of blaming and holding responsible depends on facts about the agent being responsible, not the other way round. To put this point more sharply, we may say...

.... For example, in efforts by Mark Johnston and Crispin Wright to differenti- ate more and less objective accounts of various discourses (about, e.g., color, shape, value), in developing the infl uential idea that certain such discourses are “response- dependent.” See Mark Johnston, “Objectivity Refi gured...

... it as “a form of response-dependence view inspired by Heidegger, Hume, and McDowell” (8). It is committed to the following metaethical theses: ethical realism (factualism and objectivism), descriptivism, and reasons and/or fittingness fundamentalism. Although the material is clearly structured, part I...

...-world interactions . Other views (e.g., standard response-dependent realist views, irrealist views) accommodate the point equally well. It is also possible to ask whether interactionism fits with the metaphysical and phenomenological facts. Most hold that, necessarily, if something (whether...

.... Mohr, Richard D. 2005. God and Forms in Plato. Las Vegas, NV: Parmenides. xxv + 279 pp. Moran, Dermot. 2005. Edmund Husserl: Founder of Phenomenology. Cambridge, U.K.: Polity. xiii + 297 pp. Norris, Christopher. 2005 [2002]. Truth Matters: Realism, Anti-Realism, and Response-Dependence...

.... But this similarity is significant for JS. Constructivists have devel- oped sophisticated responses to the circularity worry, from which JS could borrow liberally.64 For instance, Street responds to the charge of circula- rity by marshaling a thought familiar from response-dependence theo- rists of color. Very...

... .” PhD thesis, University of Chicago . Gray Aidan 2014 . “ Name-Bearing, Reference, and Circularity .” Philosophical Studies 171 , no. 2 : 207 – 31 . Gray Aidan 2017 . “ Name-Bearing and Response-Dependence .” Unpublished ms . Groenendijk Jeroen , and Stokhof...

... Philosophical Quarterly 104 , no. 2 : 392 – 407 . Shelley James , and Watkins Michael . 2012 . “ Response-Dependence about Aesthetic Value .” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 93 , no. 3 : 338 – 52 . Stecker Robert , 2006 . “ Aesthetic Experience and Aesthetic Value...

... truths that are not response-dependent, mind-dependent, or constructivist; often assumed to make positive ontological claims; the word ‘realism’ not used by me for this reason” (2:823). Parfit calls his view Nonnaturalist Cognitivism. Beyond, however, insisting that normative facts and properties...

... : Springer . Koslicki Kathrin 2008 . The Structure of Objects . New York : Oxford University Press . Koslicki Kathrin 2013 . “ Ontological Dependence: An Opinionated Survey .” In Varieties of Dependence: Ontological Dependence, Grounding, Supervenience, Response-Dependence , ed...

... of objective, nonintrinsic features, such as occlusion shape and aperture color, both of which are relative to a point. Finally, some are resemblances in respect of response-dependent features. For example, some paintings mimic the effect of simultaneous contrast, which occurs in conditions of bright...

..., and the education aims to accomplish precisely this. For the successfully educated individual, therefore, anger and indignation are not entirely unconscious and automatic processes that flow from internalized ideals housed outside of reason, rather these emotional responses depend on prior rational judgments.73...

.... It is innovative and rigorous, and makes genuine progress on the classic long-standing philosophical problem of whether or not we are free, and if so, in what this freedom consists. Whether or not we are free depends only on facts about the actual world rather than the availability of alternative possibilities...

...Christopher Isaac Noble [email protected] Coope Ursula , Freedom and Responsibility in Neoplatonist Thought . Oxford : Oxford University Press , 2020 . 288 pp. © 2022 by Cornell University 2022 What does it mean to be free, and what are the metaphysical conditions...