This essay examines the electoral failure of Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour Party from one specific perspective. Assuming that, as the most thorough subsequent analysis has concluded, there was no way for Labour to hold together its electoral coalition during the 2017–19 Brexit negotiations, it argues that Corbyn’s one electoral chance came at the June 2017 election. Given Labour’s long history of electoral failure, and the specific limitations imposed by the UK electoral system, the essay posits that it was an irrational and catastrophic mistake for Corbyn to reject the offer of an alliance of left-of-center parties made by the Green and Scottish National Parties in April 2017. The essay seeks to explain the genesis of this decision with reference to the long history of “Bennism”: the political tendency and philosophy associated with the career and ideas of Corbyn’s mentor, the prominent British politician Tony Benn. It argues that the strategic and analytical prejudices and shortcomings of this tradition ultimately proved fatal to Corbynism’s electoral prospects.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

References

Arblaster, Anthony.
1986
. “
Labour’s Future and the Coalition Debate
.”
New Left Review
1
, no.
157
. .
Benn, Tony; Winstone, Ruth.
2006
.
The End of an Era: Diaries 1980–90
.
London
:
Arrow Books
.
Eaton, George.
2018
. “
The Meaning of Corbynism
.”
New Statesman
,
March
5
. .
Finlayson, Alan.
2003
.
Making Sense of New Labour
.
London
:
Lawrence & Wishart
.
Gilbert, Jeremy.
2004
. “
The Second Wave: The Specificity of New Labour Neo-liberalism
.”
Soundings
26
, no.
26
:
25
45
. .
Gilbert, Jeremy.
2016
. “
Corbynism and Its Futures
.”
Near Futures Online
1
, no.
1
. .
Gilbert, Jeremy.
2020a
. “
It Was the Centrist Dads Who Lost It
.”
OpenDemocracy
,
January
13
. .
Gilbert, Jeremy.
2020b
. “
History Is Clear: Labour Must Lead an Alliance for Democratic Reform
.”
OpenDemocracy
,
January
18
. .
Gilbert, Jeremy.
2020c
. “
We Lost Because We Weren’t Big Enough
.”
OpenDemocracy
,
September
9
. .
Graeber, David.
2020
. “
The Center Blows Itself Up: Care and Spite in the ‘Brexit Election.’
New York Review of Books
(blog),
January
13
. .
Hall, Stuart.
1985
. “
Faith, Hope or Clarity
.”
Marxism Today
,
January
.
Hall, Stuart; Jacques, Martin.
1989
.
New Times: The Changing Face of Politics in the 1990s
.
London
:
Verso
.
Hannah, Simon.
2018
.
A Party with Socialists in It: A History of the Labour Left
.
London
:
Pluto
.
Jacques, Martin.
2017
. “
Why Jeremy Corbyn Is a New Leader for the New Times
.”
New Statesman
,
June
20
. .
Jessop, Bob; Bromley, Simon; Ling, Tom.
1985
. “
Thatcherism and the Politics of Hegemony: A Reply to Stuart Hall
.”
New Left Review
1
, no.
153
. .
Jones, Owen.
2021
.
This Land: The Story of a Movement
.
Penguin Books
.
Lawson, Neal.
2015
. “
Without the Soft Left, Labour Is Doomed to Splinter
.”
The Guardian
,
July
24
. .
Livingstone, Ken.
2008
. “
Yes, I Lost. But Still Labour Must Learn from London
.”
The Guardian
,
May
8
. .
Mason, Paul.
2017
. “
Coalition, Collaboration and Tactical Voting: That’s How to Halt Hard Brexit
.”
The Guardian
,
April
19
. .
Mason, Rowena.
2020
. “
‘Hostility to Corbyn’ Curbed Labour Efforts to Tackle Antisemitism, Says Leaked Report
.”
The Guardian
,
April
12
. .
McKibbin, Ross.
2011
.
Parties and People: England 1914–1951
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
Medhurst, John.
2014
.
That Option No Longer Exists: Britain 1974–76
.
Arlesford
:
Zero Books
.
Milburn, Keir.
2019
.
Generation Left
.
Radical Futures
.
Cambridge, UK
:
Polity
.
Miliband, Ralph.
1960
. “
The Sickness of Labourism
.”
New Left Review
1
, no.
1
. .
Murray, Andrew.
2020
.
The Fall and Rise of the British Left
.
London
:
Verso
.
Nunns, Alex.
2016
.
The Candidate: Jeremy Corbyn’s Improbable Path to Power
.
New York
:
OR Books
.
Panitch, Leo; Leys, Colin.
2001
.
The End of Parliamentary Socialism: From New Left to New Labour
. 2nd ed.
London
:
Verso
.
Panitch, Leo; Leys, Colin.
2020
.
Searching for Socialism: The Project of the Labour New Left from Benn to Corbyn
.
London
:
Verso
.
Perryman, Mark, ed.
2017
.
The Corbyn Effect
.
London
:
Lawrence & Wishart
.
Rowbotham, Sheila; Segal, Lynne; Wainwright, Hilary.
2013
.
Beyond the Fragments: Feminism and the Making of Socialism
.
London
:
Merlin
.
Rush, Martyn.
2021
. “
Tony Benn’s Plan to Democratise Britain—and Abolish the Monarchy
.”
Tribune
,
February
26
. .
Srnicek, Nick; Williams, Alex.
2015
.
Inventing the Future: Postcapitalism and a World without Work
.
London
:
Verso
.
Süß, Rahel Sophia; Kolioulis, Alessio; Gilbert, Jeremy.
2018
. “
Radical Democracy and Municipal Movements
.”
OpenDemocracy
,
December
22
. .
Wainwright, Hilary.
2018
.
A New Politics from the Left
.
Cambridge, UK
:
Polity
.
Walker, Peter; Elgot, Jessica.
2017
. “
Labour and Lib Dems Reject Greens’ Call for Electoral Pact against Tories
.”
The Guardian
,
April
19
. .