Claiming that the criminal justice system fails to effectively prohibit protest and civil disobedience, corporate lawyers embrace the pervasive use of injunctions and contempt of court charges in struggles over resource extraction in British Columbia, dubbing this approach the “new normal.” Yet even a cursory review of protest policing in Canada reveals that state intervention in resistance movements is alive and well and that Indigenous peoples and allied social movements are made subject to repression, surveillance, and criminalization through the mechanism of injunctions and contempt, among other legal tools. Based on my direct experience with injunctions and contempt in BC as an activist legal support organizer and a settler ally, this article argues that the reliance on injunctions by extractive industries embroils the courts and police in struggles over public and/or collectively held lands and resources that are nonetheless constructed by the law as private disputes, largely insulated from the reach of constitutionally-derived Aboriginal rights. After tracing the long history of BC’s “injunction habit,” I examine the judicial and policy practices that make the “new normal” claim possible—and show how it is ultimately not accurate. As crucial tools in the legal arsenal of settler-colonial states, injunctions and the subsequent use of contempt charges carve out a distinctly colonial space within Canadian law for the criminalization of Indigenous resistance, facilitating access to resources and lands and easing the operation of extractive capitalism.

This content is only available as a PDF.

References

References
Barker Jordan .
2019
. “
Criminal Charges Dropped against Group that Occupied Muskrat Falls in 2016
.”
CBC News
,
May
29
. .
Barker Thom .
2019
. “
Wet’suwet’en Clan Launches Civil Lawsuit against Coastal GasLink
.”
Williams Lake Tribune
,
July
23
. .
Bellrichard Chantelle Ghoussoub Michelle .
2019
. “
Fourteen Arrested as RCMP Break Gate at Gidimt’en Camp Checkpoint Set Up to Stop Pipeline Company Access
.”
CBC News
,
January
7
. .
Bhandar Brenna .
2018
.
Colonial Lives of Property: Law, Land, and Racial Regimes of Ownership
.
Durham, NC
:
Duke University Press
.
Blomley Nicholas .
1996
. “
‘Shut the Province Down’: First Nations Blockades in British Columbia, 1984–1995
.”
BC Studies
III
:
5
.
British Columbia Prosecution Service
.
2018
. “
Civil Disobedience and Contempt of Related Court Orders
” In
Crown Counsel Policy Manual
. .
Hunter John J. L.
2009
. “
Aboriginal Rights Litigation
.” In
Injunctions—British Columbia Law and Practice
, 2nd ed.
Vancouver
:
Continuing Legal Education Society of British Columbia
.
Krawczyk Betty .
2002
.
Lock Me Up or Let Me Go: The Protests, Arrest, and Trial of an Environmental Activist
.
Vancouver
:
Press Gang
.
Lawn Julia E.
1998
The John Doe Injunction in Mass Protest Cases
.”
University of Toronto Faculty of Law Review
56
:
101
.
Manuel Arthur Derrickson with Grand Chief Ronald .
2018
.
The Reconciliation Manifesto: Recovering the Land, Rebuilding the Economy
.
Toronto
:
Lorimer
.
Mazur Dylan .
2019
.
Know Your Rights: Injunctions and Contempt of Court
.
Vancouver
:
British Columbia Civil Liberties Association
.
Metallic Naiomi .
2015
. “
Injunctions against Pickets and Protests in the 21st Century: It’s Time to Stop Applying the Three-Part RJR-MacDonald Test.
Unpublished manuscript on file with the author
.
Miller Jeffrey .
2016
.
The Law of Contempt in Canada
. 2nd ed.
Toronto
:
Carswell
.
Newell Ryan .
2012
. “
Only One Law: Indigenous Land Disputes and the Contested Nature of the Rule of Law
.”
Indigenous Law Journal
11
, no.
1
:
41
.
Pasternak Shiri .
Forthcoming
. “
Why Does a Hat Need so Much Land?
” In
Allotment Stories: Indigenous Responses to Settler Colonial Land Privatization
, edited by O’Brien Jean Justice Daniel Heath .
Royal Canadian Mounted Police
.
2019a
. “
Background on BC RCMP’s Role in Enforcing Injunction Order
bc.rcmp-grc.gc.ca/ViewPage.action?languageId=1&siteNo-deId=2087&contentId=57805 (accessed January 6, 2019).
Royal Canadian Mounted Police
.
2019b
. “
Fourteen Arrested during Enforcement of Injunction Order in Houston, BC
.” (accessed January 7, 2019).
Saul R. Patrick Vanderburgh Eileen E.
2009
. “
Land Use Disputes
.” In
Injunctions: British Columbia Law and Practice
, 2nd ed.
Vancouver
:
Continuing Legal Education Society of British Columbia
.
Scott Dayna Nadine .
2013
. “
Commentary: The Forces That Conspire to Keep Us ‘Idle.’
Canadian Journal of Law and Society
28
, no.
3
:
425
.
Trumpener Betsy .
2019
. “
Contempt Charges Dropped against 14 Protesters Blocking B.C. Pipeline Project
.”
CBC News
,
April
15
. .
Unist’ot’en Camp
.
2019
. “
Unist’ot’en Defends Indigenous Law at Injunction Hearing
.” (accessed August 20, 2019).
Wallstam Maria .
2017
. “
Ten Year Tent City Beats Vancouver in Court!
The Volcano
,
May
22
. .
Ward Cameron .
1993
. “
The Contemptuous Mr. Doe
.”
Advocate (Vancouver)
51
:
861
.
Williams Rick et al .
2017
. “
The New Normal? Natural Resource Development, Civil Disobedience, and Injunctive Relief
.”
Alberta Law Review
55
, no.
2
:
285
315
.