Planning is widely perceived as an approach to economic life that both subordinates decisions about production and distribution to a supposedly objective Science and as an illegitimate subjection of economic laws to a commanding political Will. This article excavates two key phases in the Soviet experiment with a planned economy, namely, the New Economic Policy under Lenin and the Stalinist institution of the five-year plan, to explore the way in which planning could be thought of as directly incorporating a dimension of social and class conflict. This archaeological reconstruction of an antagonistic politics of planning is contrasted with the disavowed elements of planning within contemporary business logistics as well as with efforts within critical Marxist theory after 1968 to push against the depoliticizing dimensions of the plan.

This content is only available as a PDF.

References

References
Alimahomed-Wilson, Jake; Ness, Immanuel
.
2018
.
Choke Points: Logistics Workers Disrupting the Global Supply Chain
.
London
:
Pluto Press
.
Allen, R. C.
2003
.
From Farm to Factory: A Reinterpretation of the Soviet Industrial Revolution
.
Princeton, NJ
:
Princeton University Press
.
Althusser, Louis
.
2016
.
Les Vaches noires. Interview imaginaire (le malaise du XXIIe Congrès). Ce qui ne va pas, camarades!
, edited by
Goshgarian, G. M.
.
Paris
:
P.U.F
.
Asor Rosa, Alberto
.
1971
. “
Lavoro intellettuale e utopia dell’avanguarda nel paese del socialismo realizzato
.” In
Socialismo, città, architettura. URSS 1917–1937
, edited by
Rosa, Asor et al
.
Rome
:
Officina Edizioni
.
Balibar, Étienne
.
2017 [1979]
. “
State, Party, Transition
.”
Viewpoint Magazine
. .
Barber, J. D.; Davies, R. W.
.
1994
. “
Employment and Industrial Labour
.” In
The Economic Transformation of the Soviet Union, 1913–45
, edited by
Davies, R. W.; Harrison, Mark; Wheatcroft, S. G.
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Bettelheim, Charles
.
1976
.
Class Struggle in the USSR. First Period: 1917–1923
, translated by
Pearce, Brian
.
New York
:
Monthly Review
.
Blackburn, Robin
.
1991
. “
Fin de Siècle: Socialism after the Crash
.”
New Left Review
1
, no.
185
:
5
66
.
Blackburn, Robin
.
2018
. “
The Corbyn Project: Public Capital and Labour’s New Deal
.”
New Left Review
2
, no.
111
:
5
32
.
Bonacich, Edna; Wilson, Jake B.
.
2008
.
Getting the Goods: Ports, Labor, and the Logistics Revolution
.
New York
:
Cornell University Press
.
Brown, Wendy
.
2015
.
Undoing the Demos: Neoliberalism’s Stealth Revolution
.
Cambridge, MA
:
MIT Press
.
Cacciari, Massimo
.
1975
. “
Preobraženskij e il dibattito sull’industrializzazione durante la NEP
.” In
Cacciari and Perulli
.
Cacciari, Massimo; Perulli, Paolo
.
1975
.
Piano economico e composizione di classe. Il dibat-tito sull’industrializzazione e lo scontro politico durante la NEP
.
Milan
:
Feltrinelli
.
Cacciari, Massimo
.
1977
.
Pensiero negativo e razionalizzazione
.
Venice
:
Marsilio editore
.
Cacciari, Massimo
.
2006
.
Introduction to Max Weber
,
La politica come professione
.
Milan
:
Oscar Mondadori
.
Campling, Liam; Selwyn, Ben
.
2018
. “
Value Chains and the World Economy: Genealogies and Reformulations
.” In
Handbook of the International Political Economy of the Corporation
, edited by
Nölke, Andreas; May, Christian
,
416
34
.
Cheltenham and Northampton
:
Edward Elgar
.
Carr, E. H.
1969
.
The Interregnum
.
Harmondsworth
:
Pelican
.
Carr, E. H.
1970
.
Socialism in One Country
. Vol.
1
.
Harmondsworth
:
Pelican
.
Carr, E. H.; Davies, R. W.
.
1974
.
Foundations of a Planned Economy
. Vol.
1
.
Harmondsworth
:
Pelican
.
Chattopadhyay, Paresh
.
2004
. “
Socialism and Value Categories in Early Soviet Doctrine: Lenin, Trotsky, Bucharin, Preobrazhensky
.” In
The New Value Controversy and the Foundations of Economics
, edited by
Freeman, Alan; Kliman, Andrew; Wells, Julian
.
Cheltenham
:
Edward Elgar
.
Davies, R. W.
1989
.
The Industrialisation of Soviet Russia 3: The Soviet Economy in Turmoil: 1929–30
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Davies, R. W.
1990
.
From Tsarism to the New Economic Policy: Continuity and Change in the Economy of the USSR
.
Basingstoke
:
Macmillan
.
Davies, R. W.
1994
. “
Changing Economic Systems: An Overview
.” In
The Economic Transformation of the Soviet Union, 1913–45
, edited by
Davies, R. W.; Harrison, Mark; Wheatcroft, S. G.
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Davies, R. W.
1998
.
Soviet Economic Development from Lenin to Khrushchev
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Day, Richard B.
.
1981
.
The “Crisis” and the “Crash”: Soviet Studies of the West, 1917–1939
.
London
:
New Left Books
.
Di Leo, Rita
.
1971
. “
Dalla NEP al Piano
.” In
Rosa, Asor et al
,
Socialismo, città, architettura. URSS 1917–1937
.
Rome
:
Officina Edizioni
.
Dobb, Maurice
.
1966
.
Soviet Economic Development since 1917
, 6th rev ed.
London
:
Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
Dyer-Witheford, Nick
.
2013
. “
Red Plenty Platforms
.”
Culture Machine
14
:
1
27
.
Ellenstein, Jean
.
1975
.
Storia del fenomeno staliniano
.
Rome
:
Editori Riuniti
.
Ellman, Michael
.
1979
.
Socialist Planning
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Gary Gereffi, John Humphrey; Sturgeon, Timothy
.
2005
. “
The Governance of Global Value Chains
.”
Review of International Political Economy
12
, no.
1
:
78
104
.
Grappi, Giorgio
.
2016
.
Logistica
.
Rome
:
Ediesse
.
Groman, Vladimir
.
1925
.
Planavoe Khozyaistvo
, no.
7
:
151
66
.
Hayek, Friedrich A.
.
2005
.
The Road to Serfdom with The Intellectuals and Socialism
.
London
:
Institute for Economic Affairs
.
Hayek, Friedrich A.
.
1973
.
Law, Legislation and Liberty
.
London
:
Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
Hui, Wang
.
2006
. “
Depoliticized Politics, from East to West
.” Translated by
Connery, Christopher
.
New Left Review
2
, no.
41
:
29
45
.
James, C. L. R.
1977
. “
Lenin and the Problem
.” In
Nkrumah and the Ghana Revolution
.
London
:
Allison and Busby
.
James, C. L. R.
2009
. “
Lenin and the Trade Union Debate in Russia
.” In
You Don’t Play with Revolution: The Montreal Lectures of C. L. R. James
, edited by
Austin, David
.
Oakland
:
AK Press
.
Kornai, János
.
1986
. “
The Soft Budget Constraint
.”
Kyklos
39
, no.
1
:
3
30
.
Lefebvre, Henri
.
2009
.
State, Space, World: Selected Essays
, edited by
Brenner, Neil; Elden, Stuart
.
Minneapolis
:
University of Minnesota Press
.
Lenin, Vladimir Ilyich
.
2003
. “
One Step Forwards, Two Steps Back
.” In
Collected Works
, vol.
7
.
London
:
Lawrence and Wishart
.
Lenin, Vladimir Ilyich
.
1921
. “
Purging the Party
.” In
Collected Works
, vol.
33
.
Moscow
:
Progress Publishers
.
Lenin, Vladimir Ilyich
.
1922
. “
The Role and Functions of the Trade Unions under the New Economic Policy
.” In
Collected Works
, vol.
33
.
Moscow
:
Progress Publishers
.
Lewin, Moshe
.
2005 [1968]
.
Lenin’s Last Struggle
.
Ann Arbor
:
University of Michigan Press
.
Lih, Lars
.
2008
.
Lenin Rediscovered: “What Is to be Done?” in Context
.
Chicago
:
Haymarket
.
Linhart, Robert
.
2010
.
Lénine, les paysans, Taylor
.
Paris
:
Éditions du Seuil
.
Marramao, Giacomo
.
1975
. “
Dialettica delle forme a scienza della politica
.”
Critica marxista
8
, no.
6
.
Mitchell, Timothy
.
2011
.
Carbon Democracy: Political Power in the Age of Oil
.
London
:
Verso
.
Moody, Kim
.
2017
.
On New Terrain: How Capital is Reshaping the Battleground of the Class War
.
Chicago
:
Haymarket
.
Negri, Antonio
.
(1971) 2005
. “
Crisis of the Planner-State: Communism and Revolutionary Organization
.” In
Books for Burning: Between Civil War and Democracy in 1970s Italy
.
London
:
Verso
Nove, Alec
.
1969
.
An Economic History of the U.S.S.R
.
Harmondsworth
:
Pelican
.
Perulli, Paolo
.
1971
. “
Riflessi dell’industrializzazione sui movimenti di classe
.”
Contropiano
, no.
1
.
Shvernik, N.
.
1934
.
XVII Congress of the CPSU (B.)
. .
Schmitt, Carl
.
1988
.
The Crisis of Parliamentary Democracy
. Translated by Ellen Kennedy.
Cambridge, MA
:
MIT Press
.
Spulber, Nicolas
.
1964
.
Foundations of Soviet Strategy for Economic Growth: Selected Soviet Essays, 1924–1930
.
Bloomington
:
Indiana University Press
.
Stalin, Joseph
.
(1921) 1953
. “
The Political Strategy and Tactics of the Russian Communists
.” In
Works
, vol.
5
.
Moscow
:
Foreign Languages Publishing House
.
Stalin, Joseph
.
1929a
. “
The Right Deviation in the C.P.S.U.(B.)
.” In
Stalin 1947
.
Stalin, Joseph
.
1929b
. “
Problems of Agrarian Policy in the U.S.S.R
.” In
Stalin 1947
.
Stalin, Joseph
.
1931
. “
The Tasks of Business Executives
.” In
Stalin 1947
.
Stalin, Joseph
.
1935
. “
Speech at the First all-Union Conference of Stakhanovites
.” In
Stalin 1947
.
Stalin, Joseph
.
1947
.
Problems of Leninism
.
Moscow
:
Foreign Languages Publishing House
.
Strumilin, Stanislav
.
1928a
.
Ocherki Sovetskoi Ekonomiki
:
422
34
.
Strumilin, Stanislav
.
1928b
.
O Pyatiletnem Plane Razvitiya Narodnogo Khozyaistva SSSR: Diskussiya v Kommunisticheskoi Akademii
.
Tafuri, Manfredo
.
1971
. “
Il socialismo realizzato e la crisi delle avanguardie
.” In
Rosa, Alberto Asor et al
,
Socialismo, città, architettura. URSS 1917–1937
.
Rome
:
Officina Edizioni
.
Toscano, Alberto
.
2011
. “
Logistics and Opposition
.”
Mute
,
August
9
. .
Toscano, Alberto
.
2014a
. “
Transition Deprogrammed
.”
South Atlantic Quarterly
113
, no.
4
:
761
76
.
Toscano, Alberto
.
2014b
. “
Lineaments of the Logistical State
.”
Viewpoint
, no.
4
. .
Toscano, Alberto; Kinkle, Jeff
.
2015
.
Cartographies of the Absolute
.
Winchester
:
Zero Books
.
Varoufakis, Yanis
.
2018
. “
Three Tribes of Austerity
.”
Project Syndicate
,
August
30
. .