This essay examines the evolving symbiosis of authoritarian state power and neoliberal governance in the Middle East in the wake of the 2007–8 economic crisis and popular uprisings in 2011–13. I revisit the debates on “authoritarian resilience” in the region to highlight that the efforts to push through neoliberal reforms in the face of popular opposition have expanded the scope of authoritarian rule. However, the strengthening of the executive power further creates antagonisms which are bound to result in the weakening of the state’s institutional capacity and legitimacy to enforce those reforms. These considerations highlight the fissures of “authoritarian resilience” in the region and signal that state centralization and the strengthening of executive power could produce avenues for contesting both neoliberalism and authoritarianism.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Abbott, Pamela; Teti, Andrea.
2017
. “Socio-Economic Inequality and the Failure of Development Strategies for the Middle East
.” Arab Transformations Policy Brief No. 3
. www.arabtrans.eu/publications-and-reports-/policy-briefs/
.Abdelrahman, Maha.
2012
. “A Hierarchy of Struggles? The ‘Economic’ and the ‘Political’ in Egypt’s Revolution
.” Review of African Political Economy
39
, no. 134
: 614
–28
.Albrecht, Holger; Schlumberger, Oliver.
2004
. “‘Waiting for Godot’: Regime Change without Democratization in the Middle East
.” International Political Science Review
25
, no. 4
: 371
–92
.Allinson, Jamie.
2015
. “Class Forces, Transition, and the Arab Uprisings: A Comparison of Tunisia, Egypt, and Syria
.” Democratization
22
, no. 2
: 294
–314
.Arsel, Murat; Akbulut, Bengi; Adaman, Fikret.
2015
. “Environmentalism of the Malcontent: Anatomy of an Anti-Coal Power Plant Struggle in Turkey
.” Journal of Peasant Studies
42
, no. 2
: 371
–95
.Atasoy, Yıldız.
2016
. “Repossession, Re-informalization, and Dispossession: The ‘Muddy Terrain’ of Land Commodification in Turkey
.” Journal of Agrarian Change
17
, no. 4
: 657
–79
.Ayubi, Nazih N.
1995
. Over-Stating the Arab State: Politics and Society in the Middle East
. London
: I. B. Tauris
.Bailey, David J. et al.
2017
. Beyond Defeat and Austerity: Disrupting (the Critical Political Economy of) Neoliberal Europe
. Abingdon, UK
: Routledge
.Baumann, Hannes.
2016
. Citizen Hariri: Lebanon’s Neoliberal Reconstruction
. New York
: Oxford University Press
.Beinin, Joel.
2009
. “Workers’ Protest in Egypt: Neo-liberalism and Class Struggle in Twenty-First Century
.” Social Movement Studies
8
, no. 4
: 449
–54
.Bellin, Eva.
2012
. “Reconsidering the Robustness of Authoritarianism in the Middle East: Lessons from the Arab Spring
.” Comparative Politics
44
, no. 2
: 127
–49
.Bermeo, Nancy.
2016
. “On Democratic Backsliding
.” Journal of Democracy
27
, no. 1
: 5
–19
.Bogaert, Koenraad.
2013
. “Contextualizing the Arab Revolts: The Politics behind Three Decades of Neoliberalism in the Arab World
.” Middle East Critique
22
, no. 3
: 213
–34
.Bozkurt-Güngen, Sümercan.
2018
. “Labour and Authoritarian Neoliberalism: Changes and Continuities under the AKP Governments in Turkey
.” South European Society and Politics
23
, no. 2
: 219
–38
.Bruff, Ian.
2014
. “The Rise of Authoritarian Neoliberalism
.” Rethinking Marxism: A Journal of Economics, Culture, and Society
26
, no. 1
: 113
–29
.Bush, Sarah.
2015
. The Taming of Democracy Assistance: Why Democracy Promotion Does Not Confront Dictators
. Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.Cammett, Melani; Diwan, Ishac.
2016
. “The Roll-Back of the State and the Rise of Crony Capitalism
.” In The Middle East Economies in Times of Transition
, edited by Diwan, Ishac; Galal, Ahmed, 63
–98
. Basingstoke, UK
: Palgrave Macmillan
.Chacko, Priya; Jayasuriya, Kanishka.
2017
. “‘Trump, the Authoritarian Populist Revolt and the Future of the Rules-Based Order in Asia
.” Australian Journal of International Affairs
71
, no. 2
: 121
–27
.Chalcraft, John.
2016
. Popular Politics in the Making of the Modern Middle East
. Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.Charbel, Jano.
2016
. “June 30, Three Years On: Independent Labor Movements Suffer More Losses Than Gains
.” Mada Masr
, July
3
. .Clua-Losada, Mònica; Ribera-Almandoz, Olatz.
2017
. “Authoritarian Neoliberalism and the Disciplining of Labour
.” In States of Discipline: Authoritarian Neoliberalism and the Contested Reproduction of Capitalist Order
, edited by Tansel, Cemal Burak, 29
–45
. London
: Rowman and Littlefield International
.Connell, Raewyn; Dados, Nour.
2014
. “Where in the World Does Neoliberalism Come From? The Market Agenda in Southern Perspective
.” Theory and Society
43
, no. 2
: 117
–38
.Çelik, Aziz.
2015
. “Turkey’s New Labour Regime under the Justice and Development Party in the First Decade of the Twenty-First Century: Authoritarian Flexibilization
.” Middle Eastern Studies
51
, no. 4
: 618
–35
.De Smet, Brecht; Bogaert, Koenraad.
2017
. “Resistance and Passive Revolution in Egypt and Morocco
.” In States of Discipline: Authoritarian Neoliberalism and the Contested Reproduction of Capitalist Order
, edited by Tansel, Cemal Burak, 211
–33
. London
: Rowman and Littlefield International
.Diamond, Larry.
2015
. “Facing Up to the Democratic Recession
.” Journal of Democracy
26
, no. 1
: 141
–55
.Duboc, Marie.
2014
. “Challenging the Trade Union, Reclaiming the Nation: The Politics of Labor Protest in Egypt, 2006–11
.” In Beyond the Arab Spring: The Evolving Ruling Bargain in the Middle East
, edited by Kamrava, Mehran, 223
–48
. Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.Emek, Çalışmaları Topluluğu.
2018
. İşçi Sınıfı Eylemleri Raporu 2017 (Report on Working Class Protests in 2017)
. Emek Çalışmaları Topluluğu
, May
. .Eraydın, Ayda; Taşan-Kok, Tuna.
2014
. “State Response to Contemporary Urban Movements in Turkey: A Critical Overview of State Entrepreneurialism and Authoritarian Interventions
.” Antipode: A Radical Journal of Geography
46
, no. 1
: 110
–29
.Fraser, Nancy.
2015
. “Legitimation Crisis? On the Political Contradictions of Financialized Capitalism
.” Critical Historical Studies
2
, no. 2
: 157
–89
.Galston, William A.
2018
. “Trump and the Decline of Democracy
.” Wall Street Journal
, January
16
. .Hale, Sondra.
2014
. “The New Middle East Insurrections and Other Subversions of the Modernist Frame
.” Journal of Middle East Women’s Studies
10
, no. 3
: 40
–61
.Hall, Stuart.
2011
. “The Neo-Liberal Revolution
.” Cultural Studies
25
, no. 6
: 705
–28
.Hanieh, Adam.
2013
. Lineages of Revolt: Issues of Contemporary Capitalism in the Middle East
. Chicago
: Haymarket
.Hanieh, Adam.
2016
. “Beyond Authoritarianism: Rethinking Egypt’s ‘Long Revolution’
.” Development and Change
47
, no. 5
: 1171
–79
.Harvey, David.
1990
. The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change
. Cambridge, MA
: Blackwell
.Heydemann, Steven; Leenders, Reinoud.
2011
. “Authoritarian Learning and Authoritarian Resilience: Regime Responses to the ‘Arab Awakening’
.” Globalizations
8
, no. 5
: 647
–53
.Hinnebusch, Raymond.
2015
. “Change and Continuity after the Arab Uprising: The Consequences of State Formation in Arab North African States
.” British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies
42
, no. 1
: 12
–30
.Hollis, Rosemary.
2012
. “No Friend of Democratization: Europe’s Role in the Genesis of the ‘Arab Spring’
.” International Affairs
88
, no. 1
: 81
–94
.IMF (International Monetary Fund)
. 2007
. Regional Economic Outlook: Middle East and Central Asia
. Washington, DC
: IMF
.Ipsos
. 2018
. “Türkiye Barometresi Yeni Yıl Özel Sayısı” (“Turkey Barometer New Year Special Issue”)
. January
25
. .Joya, Angela.
2011
. “The Egyptian Revolution: Crisis of Neoliberalism and the Potential for Democratic Politics
.” Review of African Political Economy
38
, no. 129
: 367
–86
.Joya, Angela.
2017
. “Neoliberalism, the State, and Economic Policy Outcomes in the Post-Arab Uprisings: The Case of Egypt
.” Mediterranean Politics
22
, no. 3
: 339
–61
.Kadri, Ali.
2016
. “Arab Development via the Channels of War and Oil
.” In Development Challenges and Solutions after the Arab Spring
, 1
–15
. Basingstoke, UK
: Palgrave Macmillan
.Kamrava, Mehran.
2014
. “The Rise and Fall of Ruling Bargains in the Middle East
.” In Beyond the Arab Spring: The Evolving Ruling Bargain in the Middle East
, 17
–45
. Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.King, Stephen J.
2009
. The New Authoritarianism in the Middle East and North Africa
. Bloom-ington: Indiana University Press
.Klaas, Brian.
2018
. “Want to See Where Trump Is Taking America? Look at Turkey under Erdogan
.” Washington Post
, January
13
, .Kreuder-Sonnen, Christian.
2018
. “An Authoritarian Turn in Europe and European Studies?
” Journal of European Public Policy
25
, no. 3
: 452
–64
.Mitchell, Timothy.
1999
. “No Factories, No Problems: The Logic of Neo-Liberalism in Egypt
.” Review of African Political Economy
26
, no. 82
: 455
–68
.Mudde, Cas.
2016
. “Europe’s Populist Surge: A Long Time in the Making
.” Foreign Affairs
95
, no. 6
: 25
–30
.Mudge, Stephanie L.
2008
. “What Is Neo-Liberalism?
” Socio-Economic Review
6
, no. 4
: 703
–31
.Naqib, Fadel.
2016
. “The Failure of Arab Macro Policy
.” In Development Challenges and Solutions after the Arab Spring
, edited by Kadri, Ali, 39
–50
. Basingstoke, UK
: Palgrave Macmillan
.Pace, Michelle; Cavatorta, Francesco.
2012
. “The Arab Uprisings in Theoretical Perspective
.” Mediterranean Politics
17
, no. 2
: 125
–38
.Peck, Jamie; Theodore, Nik; Brenner, Neil.
2010
. “Postneoliberalism and Its Malcontents
.” Supplement, Antipode: A Radical Journal of Geography
41
, no. S1
: 94
–116
.Peck, Jamie; Theodore, Nik; Brenner, Neil.
2012
. “Neoliberalism Resurgent? Market Rule after the Great Recession
.” South Atlantic Quarterly
111
, no. 2
: 265
–88
.Rachman, Gideon.
2017
. “Donald Trump, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, and How Democracies Die
.” Financial Times
, May
15
. .Roccu, Roberto.
2018
. “Banking on Ordoliberalism? Security, Stability and Profits in EU’s Economic Reform Promotion in Egypt
.” Mediterranean Politics
23
, no. 1
: 43
–61
.Rupnik, Jacques.
2016
. “Surging Illiberalism in the East
.” Journal of Democracy
27
, no. 4
: 77
–87
.Salem, Sara.
2018
. “Critical Interventions in Debates on the Arab Revolutions: Centring Class
.” Review of African Political Economy
45
, no. 155
: 125
–34
.Sönmez, Mustafa.
2018
. “Turkey’s Impressive Growth Rate Has Dark Side
.” Al-Monitor
, April
2
. .Streeck, Wolfgang.
2014
. Buying Time: The Delayed Crisis of Democratic Capitalism
. London
: Verso
.Tansel, Cemal Burak.
2017
. “Authoritarian Neoliberalism: Towards a New Research Agenda
.” In States of Discipline: Authoritarian Neoliberalism and the Contested Reproduction of Capitalist Order
, 1
–28
. London
: Rowman and Littlefield International
.Tansel, Cemal Burak.
2018
a. “Authoritarian Neoliberalism and Democratic Backsliding in Turkey: Beyond the Narratives of Progress
.” South European Society and Politics
23
, no. 2
: 197
–217
.Tansel, Cemal Burak.
2018
b. “Reproducing Authoritarian Neoliberalism in Turkey: Urban Governance and State Restructuring in the Shadow of Executive Centralization
.” Globalizations
, August
21
. doi.org/.Tepe, Sultan.
2016
. “Urban Renewal Projects and Democratic Capacities of Citizens
.” Mediterranean Quarterly
27
, no. 1
: 71
–96
.Teti, Andrea.
2012
. “Beyond Lies the Wub: The Challenges of (Post)Democratization
.” Middle East Critique
21
, no. 1
: 5
–24
.Tripp, Charles.
2013
. The Power and the People: Paths of Resistance in the Middle East
. Cam-bridge: Cambridge University Press
.White, Jonathan.
2015
. “Emergency Europe
.” Political Studies
63
, no. 2
: 300
–318
.Yom, Sean L.
2016
. From Resilience to Revolution: How Foreign Interventions Destabilize the Middle East
. New York
: Columbia University Press
.Copyright © 2019 by Duke University Press
2019
