The diagnosis of a migration crisis has prompted multiple processes of rebordering in Europe and beyond. These include the buildup of physical barriers like walls and fences, the tightening of asylum regimes, the expansion of biometric databases, and the enrollment of authoritarian regimes in controlling Europe’s borders. These developments have prompted a revival of the image of the “fortress” in critical accounts of the European border regime. Building on existing criticisms of the metaphorical Fortress Europe, this article proposes an alternative political imaginary of the European border regime. Starting from a version of the autonomy of migration approach that is based on the notion of appropriation, it proposes to apprehend the European border regime as a parasitic and precarious apparatus of capture. This apparatus of capture tries to recuperate migrants’ practices of appropriation in order to turn the knowledge and creativity of these practices into a driving force for its own development. Important aspects of this dynamic are illustrated through two examples: the refinement of control mechanisms of the European visa regime and the repeated tightening of Germany’s asylum regime since the “summer of migration” in 2015. Taken together, these examples illustrate three aspects of processes of recuperation: first, that legal changes often only formalize previously informal practices of recuperation, second, that the framing of migration in terms of crisis functions as a vehicle for processes of recuperation that, third, are incoherent and thus open up new opportunities for practices of appropriation. In sum, the reading of the European border regime as an apparatus of capture paves the way for more assertive antiracist politics as it invites us to apprehend increasingly violent forms of border control not as signs of strengths of the European border regime, but as indicators of its increasingly desperate fight for survival.

This content is only available as a PDF.

References

References
Amnesty International
.
2014
.
The Human Cost of Fortress Europe: Human Rights Violations against Migrants and Refugees at Europe’s Borders
.
London
:
Amnesty International
. .
Amoore, Louise.
2006
. “
Biometric Borders: Governing Mobilities in the War on Terror
.”
Political Geography
25
, no.
3
:
336
51
.
ANA-ZAR
.
2010
. “
Ihr Handy mal Bitte!” (“Your Cell Phone, Please!”)
.
ANA-ZAR: Anwaltsnachrichten Ausländer- und Asylrecht
5
:
40
.
Andreas, Peter.
2000
.
Border Games. Policing the U.S.-Mexico Divide
.
Ithaca, NY
:
Cornell University Press
.
Andrijasevic, Rutvica.
2010
. “
From Exemption to Excess: Detention and Deportations across the Mediterranean Space
.” In
The Deportation Regime: Sovereignty, Space, and the Freedom of Movement
, edited by De Genova, Nichoals; Preutz, Nathalie Mae,
147
65
.
Durham, NC
:
Duke University Press
.
Bigo, Didier.
2007
. “
Detention of Foreigners, States of Exception, and the Social Practices of Control of the Banopticon
.” In
Borderscapes. Hidden Geographies and Politics at Territory’s Edge
, edited by Rajaram, Prem Kumar; Grundy-Warr, Carl,
3
33
.
Minneapolis
:
University of Minnesota Press
.
Bojadžijev, Manuela; Karakayali, Serhat; Tsianos, Vassilis.
2001
. “
Papers and Roses: Die Autonomie der Migration und der Kampf um Rechte” (“Papers and Roses: The Autonomy of Migration and Struggle for Rights”)
.
Kanak Attak
. .
Brown, Wendy.
2010
.
Walled States, Waning Sovereignty
.
New York
:
Zone
.
Buck-Morss, Susan.
2002
.
Dreamworld and Catastrophe: The Passing of Mass Utopia in East and West
.
Cambridge, MA
:
MIT Press
.
Carr, Mathew.
2012
.
Fortress Europe: Dispatches from a Gated Continent
.
London
:
Hurst
.
Connolly, Andrew.
2015
. “
Fortress Europe
.”
Politico.com
,
September
2
. .
de Certeau, Michel.
1984
.
The Practice of Everyday Life
.
Berkeley
:
University of California Press
.
De Genova, Nicholas et al
2016
. “
‘Migrant Crisis’/‘Refugee Crisis’
.” In
Europe/Crisis: New Keywords of “the Crisis” in and of “Europe” New Keywords Collective
, edited by De Genova, Nicholas; Tazzioli, Martina. .
EC (European Commission)
.
2017
. “
Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament on a More Effective Return Policy in the European Union—A Renewed Action Plan
.”
Brussels: European Commission
. .
EP and Council (European Parliament and the Council of the European Union)
.
2008
. “
Regulation (EC) No 767/2008 of the European Parliament and Council of 9 July 2008 Concerning the Visa Information System (VIS) and the Exchange of Data between Member States on Short-stay Visas (VIS Regulation)
.”
Official Journal of European Union
, no.
218
:
60
81
. .
Follis, Karolina.
2012
.
Building Fortress Europe: The Polish-Ukrainian Frontier
.
Philadelphia
:
University of Pennsylvania Press
.
Foucault, Michel.
(1977) 1980
. “
The Confession of the Flesh
.” In
Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings
, edited by Gordon, Colin,
194
228
.
New York
:
Pantheon
.
Georgi, Fabian.
2017
. “
Autoritärer Festungskapitalismus. Fünf Thesen zur Migrationspolitik in Europa und den USA” (“Authoritarian Fortress Capitalism. Five Hypotheses on Migration Policy in Europe and the United States”)
.
Prager Frühling: Magazin für Freiheit und Sozialismus (Prague Spring: Magazine for Freedom and Socialism)
. .
Gibney, Mathew; Hansen, Randall.
2003
. “
Deportation and the Liberal State: The Forcible Return of Asylum Seekers and Unlawful Migrants in Canada, Germany, and the United Kingdom
.”
New Issues in Refugee Research: Working Paper No. 77
.
Geneva
:
UNHCR
.
Gillespie, Marie et al.
2016
. “
Mapping Refugee Media Journeys: Smartphones and Social Media Networks
.”
Milton Keynes, UK: Open University and France Médias Monde
. .
Gouteyron, Adrien.
2007
.
Rapport d’information fait sur les services des visas, annexe au procèsverbale N° 353 de la séance du 27 juin 2007 (Information Report on Visa Departments, Annex to Minutes, No. 353 of the June 27 2007 Session)
.
Paris
:
Commission des Finances, du contrôle budgétaire, et des comptes économiques de la Nation
.
Jeandesboz, Julien; Pallister-Wilkins, Polly.
2014
. “
Crisis, Enforcement, and Control at the EU Borders
.” In
Crisis and Migration: Critical Perspectives
, edited by Lindley, Anna,
115
35
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Jones, Reece.
2016
.
Violent Borders: Refugees and the Right to Move
.
London
:
Verso
.
Jünemann, Annette; Scherer, Nikolas; Fromm, Nicolas, eds.
2017
.
Fortress Europe? Challenges and Failures of Migration and Asylum Policies
.
Berlin
:
Springer
.
Karakayali, Serhat; Rigo, Enrica.
2010
. “
Mapping the European Space of Circulation
.” In
De Genova and Preutz, Deportation Regime
,
123
44
.
Karakayali, Serhat; Tsianos, Vassilis.
2005
. “
Mapping the Order of New Migration. Undokumentierte Arbeit und die Autonomie der Migration” (“Undocumented Labor and the Autonomy of Migration”)
.
Peripherie
25
, nos.
97–98
:
35
64
.
Karakayali, Serhat; Tsianos, Vassilis.
2007
. “
Movements that Matter. Eine Einleitung
.” In
Turbulente Ränder. Neue Perspektiven auf Migration an den Grenzen Europas
, edited by Migration, Transit,
7
17
.
Bielefeld
:
Transcript-Verlag
.
Kasparek, Bernd; Speer, Marc.
2015
. “
Of Hope. Hungary and the Long Summer of Migration
.”
Bordermonitoring.eu
,
September
9
. .
Lehnert, Mathias.
Forthcoming
. “
Anwaltliche Arbeit im Asylrecht seit 2015” (“Legal Counseling in Asylum Law since 2015”)
. In
Aktuelle Probleme der Migrationspolitik (Contemporary Problems of Migration Policy)
, edited by Lehner, Roman; Wapler, Friederike.
Berlin
:
Berliner Wissenschaftsverlag
.
Lindley, Anna.
2014
. “
Exploring Crisis and Migration: Concepts and Issues
.” In
Crisis and Migration: Critical Perspectives
, edited by Lindley, Anna,
1
23
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Meiritz, Anett; Elmer, Christina.
2015
. “
Debatte um Familiennachzug: Flüchtlinge mal x = Panikmache” (“Debate on Family Reunification: Refugees Multiplied by x = Fearmongering”)
.
Spiegel Online
,
October
7
. .
Mezzadra, Sandro.
2005
.
Derecho de fuga: Migraciones, ciudadanía y globalización (The Right to Escape: Migrations, Citizenship, and Globalization)
.
Madrid
:
Traficantes de Suenos
.
Mezzadra, Sandro.
2011
. “
The Gaze of Autonomy: Capitalism, Migration, and Social Struggles
.” In
The Contested Politics of Mobility Borderzones and Irregularity
, edited by Squire, Vicky,
121
42
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Mezzadra, Sandro; Neilson, Brett.
2013
.
Border as Method, Or, the Multiplication of Labor
.
Durham, NC
:
Duke University Press
.
Mitropoulos, Angela.
2007
. “
Autonomy, Recognition, Movement
.” In
Constituent Imagination. Militant Investigations, Collective Theorization
, edited by Shukaitis, Stevphen; Graeber, David; Biddle, Erika,
127
36
.
Oakland, CA
:
AK Press
.
Moulier Boutang, Yann.
1993
. “
Interview
.” In
Strategien der Unterwerfung. Strategien der Befreiung. Materialien für einen neuen Antiimperialismus Nr. 5 (Strategies of Subjugation. Strategies of Liberation. Materials for a New Anti-imperialism No. 5)
, edited by Berlin, Schwarze Risse; Göttingen, Rote Straße,
29
56
.
Berlin
:
Schwarze Risse
.
Moulier Boutang, Yann.
1998
.
De l’esclavage au salariat. Économie historique du salariat bride
.
Paris
:
Presse Universitaires de France
.
Moulier Boutang, Yann.
2007
. “
Europa, Autonomie der Migration, Biopolitik” (“Europe, Autonomy of Migration, Biopolitics”)
. In
Empire und die biopolitische Wende. Die Internationale Diskussion im Anschluss an Negri und Hardt (Empire and the Biopolitical Turn. The International Debate Following Negri and Hardt)
, edited by Pieper, Marianne; Atzert, Thomas; Karakayali, Serhat; Tsianos, Vassilis,
169
78
.
Frankfurt am Main
:
Campus
.
Negri, Antonio.
(1977) 2005
. “
Domination and Sabotage: On the Marxist Method of Social Transformation
.” In
Books for Burning: Between Civil War and Democracy in 1970s Italy
, edited by Negri, Antonio,
231
90
.
London
:
Verso
.
Negri, Antonio.
(1982) 2005
. “
Archaeology and Project: The Mass Worker and the Social Worker
.”
Libcom.org
,
July
29
. .
NTV
.
2015
. “
Der Brief an Merkel im Wortlaut: ‘Aufnahmekapazitäten sind erschöpft’” (“The Letter to Merkel in Full: ‘Reception capacities are exhausted’”)
.
NTV
,
October
7
. .
Panagiotidis, Efthimia; Tsianos, Vassilis.
2007
. “
Denaturalizing ‘Camps’: Überwachen und Entschleunigen in der Schengener Ägäis-Zone” (“Denaturalizing ‘Camps’: Surveillance and Deceleration in the Aegean Zone of Schengen”)
. In
Turbulente Ränder. Neue Perspektiven auf Migration an den Grenzen Europas (Turbulent Margins: New Perspectives on Migration at the Borders of Europe)
, edited by
Transit Migration Forschungsgruppe
,
57
86
.
Bielefeld
:
Transcript-Verlag
.
Papadopoulos, Dimitris; Stephenson, Niamh; Tsianos, Vassilis.
2008
.
Escape Routes. Control and Subversion in the Twenty-first Century
.
London
:
Pluto Press
.
Pro Asyl
.
2017
. “
Sachverständigen-Stellungnahme von PRO ASYL für die öffentliche Anhörung am 27. März 2017 vor dem Innenausschuss des Deutschen Bundestages zum Gesetzesentwurf der Bundesregierung ‘Entwurf eines Gesetzes zur besseren Durchsetzung des Ausreisepflicht’ BR-Drucksache 179/17” (“Expert Opinion of Pro Asyl for the March 27th 2017 Public Hearing at the Committee for Internal Affairs of the German Parliament on the Legislative Proposal of the German Government ‘Proposal for a Law for Better Enforcement of the Obligation to Leave the Country’ BR-print issue 179/17”)
. .
Rath, Christian.
2017
. “
Überwachung von Flüchtlingen: Vielsagende Fotodaten” (“Surveillance of Refugees. Telling Image Data”)
.
die Tageszeitung
,
May
29
. .
Roos, Christoph.
2013
.
The EU and Immigration Policies: Cracks in the Walls of Fortress Europe?
Basingstoke
:
Palgrave
.
Scheel, Stephan.
2013a
. “
Autonomy of Migration despite Its Securitisation? Facing the Terms and Conditions of Biometric Rebordering
.”
Millennium: Journal of International Studies
41
, no.
3
:
575
600
.
Scheel, Stephan.
2013b
. “
Studying Embodied Encounters: Autonomy of Migration beyond Its Romanticization
.”
Postcolonial Studies
16
, no.
3
:
279
88
.
Scheel, Stephan.
2017a
. “
Appropriating Mobility and Bordering Europe through Romantic Love: Uncovering the Intertwinement of Border Regimes and Migratory Practices
.”
Migration Studies
, no.
1
:
389
408
.
Scheel, Stephan.
2017b
. “
‘The Secret Is to Look Good on Paper’: Appropriating Mobility within and against a Machine of Illegalization
.” In
The Borders of “Europe”: Autonomy of Migration, Tactics of Bordering
, edited by De Genova, Nicholas.
Durham, NC
:
Duke University Press
.
Scheel, Stephan.
Forthcoming
.
Autonomy of Migration? Appropriating Mobility within Biometric Border Regimes
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Scherschel, Karin.
2016
. “
Citizenship by Work? Arbeitsmarktpolitik im Flüchtlingsschutz zwischen Öffnung und Selektion” (“Citizenship by Work? Labor Market Policy in the Context of Refugee Protection between Liberalization and Selection”)
.
PROKLA—Zeitschrift für kritische Sozialwissenschaft (Journal for Critical Social Sciences)
46
, no.
2
:
245
66
.
Schinkel, Willem.
2015
. “
The Image of Crisis: Walter Benjamin and the Interpretation of ‘Crisis’ in Modernity
.”
Thesis Eleven
127
, no.
1
:
36
51
.
Sciortino, Giuseppe.
2004
. “
Between Phantoms and Necessary Evils. Some Critical Points in the Study of Irregular Migrations to Western Europe
.”
IMIS-Beiträge
24
:
17
43
.
Shukaitis, Stevphen.
2009
.
Imaginal Machines. Autonomy and Self-Organization in the Revolutions of Everyday Life
.
New York
:
Autonomedia
.
Sommaribas, Adolfo; Koch, Anne; Besch, Sylvain.
2012
.
Establishing Identity for International Protection: Challenges and Practices
.
Luxembourg
:
European Migration Network
. .
Spire, Alexis.
2009
.
Accueillir ou reconduire: Enquête sur les guichets de l’immigration
.
Paris
:
Raisons d’Agir Éditions
.
Tronti, Mario.
1979a
. “
Lenin in England
.” In
Working Class Autonomy and the Crisis
, edited by Notes, Red,
1
6
.
London
:
Red Notes and CSE
.
Tronti, Mario.
1979b
. “
The Strategy of Refusal
.” In
Red Notes, Working Class
,
7
21
.
Tsianos, Vassilis; Karakayali, Serhat.
2010
. “
Transnational Migration and the Emergence of the European Border Regime: An Ethnographic Analysis
.”
European Journal of Social Theory
13
, no.
3
:
373
87
.
Ullrich, Maria.
2017
. “
Media Use During Escape—A Contribution to Refugees’ Collective Agency
.”
Spheres: Journal for Digital Cultures
, no.
4
. .
Van Houtum, Henk; Pijpers, Roos.
2007
. “
The European Union as a Gated Community: The Two-Faced Border and Immigration Regime of the EU
.”
Antipode
39
, no.
2
:
291
309
.
Walters, William.
2004
. “
Secure Borders, Safe Haven, Domopolitics
.”
Citizenship Studies
8
, no.
3
:
237
60
.
Walters, William.
2006
. “
Rethinking Borders beyond the State
.”
Comparative European Politics
4
, nos.
2–3
:
141
59
.