Hollywood movie novelizations are novels based on mainstream films and published about the time these films are released in theaters. The present article explores the ambiguous status of this generally little-esteemed and frequently ignored form of adaptation. On the one hand, novelizations are works of literature that can be enjoyed without knowledge of the film they are based on; on the other, they can be (and often are) seen as mere tools of film advertising. This latter aspect becomes particularly evident when looking at the cover design of a novelization. It invariably features the film’s artwork (the poster image, stills, and/or typography used for promoting the film) and frequently highlights the film’s stars rather than the book’s author. By analyzing a selection of book covers of novelized versions of recent films and comparing the novelization of Terminator Salvation (Foster 2009b) with the film (Terminator Salvation 2009, dir. McG) it is based on, the article traces and examines the frictions between the opposing forces—literature and film marketing—that define the genre.

References

References
The Adventures of Baron Munchhausen
1988
Directed by
Gilliam
Terry
, performers
Neville
John
Idle
Eric
Polley
Sarah
(
Culver City, CA
:
Columbia
).
Alice in Wonderland
2010
Directed by
Burton
Tim
, performers
Wasikowska
Mia
Depp
Johnny
Carter
Helena Bonham
(
Burbank, CA
:
Walt Disney
).
Allison
Deborah
2007
Film/Print: Novelisations and Capricorn One
,”
M/C Journal
10
(
2
), journal.media-culture.org.au/0705/07-allison.php.
Anderson
Kevin J.
1997
The X Files: Ruins
(
New York
:
HarperPrism
).
Austen
Jane
2005
Pride and Prejudice
(
London
:
Penguin
).
Avatar
2009
Directed by
Cameron
James
, performers
Worthington
Sam
Saldana
Zoe
Weaver
Sigourney
(
Los Angeles, CA
:
20th Century-Fox
).
Baer
William
2004
On the Waterfront: A Conversation with Budd Schulberg
,” in
The Muse upon My Shoulder: Discussions of the Creative Process
, edited by
McTague
Sylvia Skaggs
,
174
96
(
Cranbury, NJ
:
Associated University Press
).
Baetens
Jan
2005
Novelization: A Contaminated Genre?
,”
Critical Inquiry
32
:
43
60
.
2007
From Screen to Text: Novelization, the Hidden Continent
,” in
The Cambridge Companion to Literature on Screen
, edited by
Cartmell
Deborah
Whelehan
Imelda
,
226
38
(
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
).
2008
La novellisation: Du film au roman
(
Brussels
:
Les Impressions Nouvelles
).
2010
Expanding the Field of Constraint: Novelization as an Example of Multiply Constrained Writing
,”
Poetics Today
31
:
51
79
.
Baetens
Jan
Lits
Marc
, eds.
2004
La novellisation: Du film au roman/Novelization: From Film to Novel
(
Louvain, Belgium
:
Louvain University Press
).
Bolt
Robert
1986
The Mission
(
New York
:
Jove
).
1990
A Man for All Seasons
(
London
:
Vintage
).
Boulle
Pierre
2001
[1963]
Planet of the Apes
(
New York
:
Del Rey
).
Bram Stoker’s Dracula
1992
Directed by
Coppola
Francis Ford
, performers
Oldman
Gary
Ryder
Winona
Hopkins
Anthony
(
San Francisco, CA
:
American Zoetrope
).
Busch
Jenna
2009
Interview with Alan Dean Foster, Author of Terminator Salvation: The Official Movie Novelization
,”
Huffington Post
,
August
10
, www.huffingtonpost.com/jenna-busch/interview-with-alan-dean_b_254723.html.
Butler
Michael
Shryack
Dennis
1979
The Gauntlet
(
London
:
Star
).
Butler
Nancy
2009
Pride and Prejudice
(
New York
:
Marvel
).
Capricorn One
1978
Directed by
Hyams
Peter
, performers
Gould
Elliott
Brolin
James
Vaccaro
Brenda
(
Boston, MA
:
Associated General Films
).
Carroll
Lewis
2011
[1865]
Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland
(
London
:
Puffin
).
Charmed
1998–2006
Created by
Burge
Constance M.
, performers
Combs
Holly Marie
Milano
Alyssa
Krause
Brian
(
Los Angeles, CA
:
Spelling
).
Ciencin
Scott
2002
Jurassic Park III
(
Harlow, UK
:
Pearson Education
).
Close Encounters of the Third Kind
1977
Directed by
Spielberg
Steven
, performers
Dreyfuss
Richard
Truffaut
François
Garr
Teri
.
Culver City, CA
:
Columbia
.
Coburn
James
2007
New Indiana Jones Film Has Edmond Actor
,”
Edmond Sun
,
September
17
, www.edmondsun.com/archive/x519221606.
Coe
Jonathan
2005
Diary of an Obsession
,”
Coe
Jonathan
, www.jonathancoewriter.com/oddsAndEnds/diaryOfAnObsession.html.
Collins
Max Allan
2010
CSI Miami: Florida Getaway
(
London
:
Pocket
).
Cooper
James Fenimore
1986
[1826]
The Last of the Mohicans
(
New York
:
Penguin
).
Corzine
Amy
2008
Jane Eyre: The Graphic Novel
(
Litchborough, UK
:
Classical Comics
).
Cowboys and Aliens
2011
Directed by
Favreau
Jon
, performers
Craig
Daniel
Ford
Harrison
Wilde
Olivia
.
University City, CA
:
Universal
.
Cox
John
2004
The Raymond Benson CBn Interview (Part IV)
,” CommanderBond.net,
April
15
, commanderbond.net/2339/the-raymond-benson-cbn-interview-part-iv.html.
Crabb
Kelly Charles
2005
The Movie Business: The Definitive Guide to the Legal and Financial Secrets of Getting Your Movie Made
(
New York
:
Simon and Schuster
).
CSI Miami
2002
Created by
Donahue
Ann
Mendelsohn
Carol
Zuiker
Anthony E.
, performers
Caruso
David
Procter
Emily
Rodriguez
Adam
.
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
:
Alliance Atlantis Communications
.
David
Peter
2011
Transformers: Dark of the Moon
(
New York
:
Del Rey
).
Defoe
Daniel
2001
[1719]
Robinson Crusoe
(
London
:
Penguin
).
Desmond
John M.
Hawkes
Peter
2006
Adaptation: Studying Film and Literature
(
Boston
:
McGraw-Hill
).
Dickens
Charles
2003
[1859]
A Tale of Two Cities
(
London
:
Penguin
).
Dorian Gray
2009
Directed by
Parker
Olive
, performers
Barnes
Ben
Firth
Colin
Hall
Rebecca
.
London
:
Ealing Studios
.
Eggers
Dave
2010
The Wild Things
(
London
:
Penguin
).
Eisner
Will
2008
Comics and Sequential Art: Principles and Practices from the Legendary Cartoonist
(
London
:
Norton
).
E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial
1982
Directed by
Spielberg
Steven
, performers
Thomas
Henry
Barrymore
Drew
Coyote
Peter
.
University City, CA
:
Universal
.
eXistenZ
1999
Directed by
Cronenberg
David
, performers
Law
Jude
Leigh
Jennifer Jason
Holm
Ian
.
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
:
Alliance Atlantis Communications
.
A Fistful of Dollars
1964
Directed by
Leone
Sergio
, performers
Eastwood
Clint
Volonté
Gian Maria
Koch
Marianne
(
Frankfurt, DE
:
Constantin Film
).
Foster
Alan Dean
2009a
Star Trek
(
London
:
Pocket
).
2009b
Terminator Salvation
(
London
:
Titan
).
2009c
Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
(
New York
:
Del Rey
).
Gallagher
Diana G.
2008
Charmed: Trickery Treat
(
London
:
Pocket
).
The Gauntlet
1977
Directed by
Eastwood
Clint
, performers
Eastwood
Clint
Locke
Sondra
Hingle
Pat
.
Burbank, CA
:
Malpaso
.
Gelder
Ken
1994
Reading the Vampire
(
New York
:
Routledge
).
Genette
Gérard
1997
Paratexts: Thresholds of Interpretation
, edited by
Lewin
Jane E.
(
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
).
Gilliam
Terry
McKeown
Charles
1989
The Adventures of Baron Munchhausen: Story of the Screenplay
(
London
:
Mandarin
).
The Glass Key
1942
Directed by
Heisler
Stuart
, performers
Ladd
Alan
Lake
Veronica
Donlevy
Brian
.
Los Angeles, CA
:
Paramount
.
Glut
Donald F.
1985
The Empire Strikes Back
(
New York
:
Del Rey
).
Goedhart
Bernie
2007
Transcript: Interview with Dave Eggers
,”
Gazette: Postmedia Network
,
December
7
, www.canada.com/montrealgazette/news/arts/story.html?id=0872e59b-6145-4dae-8604-22dcc9e8dd62.
Golden
Christopher
2005
King Kong
(
London
:
Pocket Star
).
Goldman
William
2006
The Screenwriter
,” in
The Movie Business Book
, edited by
Squire
Jason E.
,
60
71
(
Maidenhead, UK
:
McGraw Hill
).
Goodman
Evelyn
Orlando
Joe
Christie
Stuart
Dickens
Charles
1996
A Tale of Two Cities (Classics Illustrated)
(
New York
:
Acclaim Classics and Young Readers
).
Goulart
Ron
1978
Capricorn One
(
New York
:
Fawcett Gold Medal
).
Hagberg
David
2003
Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
(
New York
:
TOR
).
Hammett
Dashiell
1931
The Glass Key
(
New York
:
Knopf
).
Hardwick
Michael
Hardwick
Mollie
1970
The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes
(
New York
:
HarperCollins
).
Harris
Thomas
1988
The Silence of the Lambs
(
New York
:
St. Martin’s
).
Haupman
Ira
1981
Novelization: The Theater’s New Crisis
,”
Theater
12
(
2
):
87
91
.
Hawtree
Christopher
2007
Obituary: Leslie Waller
,”
Guardian
,
April
18
, www.guardian.co.uk/news/2007/apr/19/guardianobituaries.booksobituaries1.
Hutcheon
Linda
2006
A Theory of Adaptation
(
New York
:
Routledge
).
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
2008
Directed by
Spielberg
Steven
, performers
Ford
Harrison
Blanchett
Cate
LaBeouf
Shia
.
Los Angeles, CA
:
Paramount
.
Jewell
Peter
2008
Collector’s Tales: A Personal Overview of Film Fiction at Bill Douglas Centre
,”
Film History
20
(
2
):
149
63
.
Jones
William B.
2001
Classics Illustrated: A Cultural History, with Illustrations
(
Jefferson, NC
:
McFarland
).
Jurassic Park III
2001
Directed by
Johnston
Joe
, performers
Neill
Sam
Macy
William H.
Leoni
Téa
.
University City, CA
:
Universal
.
Kanter
Albert Lewis
Foley
June
Severin
John Powers
Addeo
Stephen
Cooper
James Fenimore
1997
The Last of the Mohicans
(
New York
:
Acclaim Classics and Young Readers
).
Kent
Roberta
Gotler
Joel
2006
Exploiting Book-Publishing Rights
,” in
The Movie Business Book
, edited by
Squire
Jason E.
,
91
97
(
Maidenhead, UK
:
McGraw Hill
).
King Kong
2005
Directed by
Jackson
Peter
, performers
Watts
Naomi
Black
Jack
Brody
Adrien
.
Universal City, CA
:
Universal
.
Kotzwinkle
William
1982
E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial
(
London
:
Sphere
).
Larson
Randall D.
1995
Films into Books: An Analytical Bibliography of Film Novelizations, Movie, and TV Tie-Ins
(
Metuchen, NJ
:
Scarecrow
).
Last Man Standing
1996
Directed by
Hill
Walter
, performers
Willis
Bruce
Dern
Bruce
Sanderson
William
.
Los Angeles, CA
:
New Line Cinema
.
Leitch
Thomas M.
2007
Film Adaptation and Its Discontents: From “Gone with the Wind” to “The Passion of the Christ”
(
Maryland
:
Johns Hopkins University Press
).
2010
The Ethics of Infidelity
,” in
Adaptation Studies: New Approaches
, edited by
Albrecht-Crane
Christa
Cutchins
Dennis Ray
,
61
77
(
Madison, NJ
:
Fairleigh Dickinson University Press
).
Lerangis
Peter
2000
M. Night Shyamalan’s “The Sixth Sense”
(
New York
:
Scholastic
).
The Lord of the Rings
2001–3
Directed by
Jackson
Peter
, performers
Wood
Elijah
McKellen
Ian
Astin
Sean
.
Los Angeles, CA
:
New Line Cinema
.
Luceno
James
2008
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull
(
New York
:
Scholastic
).
Maberry
Jonathan
2010
The Wolfman
(
New York
:
Tor
).
Mahlknecht
Johannes
2011
Promotion vs. Suppression: Intermedial Relationships between Early Narrative Film and Its Fan Magazine Fictionizations
,” in
The Visual Culture of Modernism
, edited by
Klarer
Mario
Madsen
Deborah L.
,
105
18
(
Tübingen, Germany
:
Narr
).
Marich
Robert
2009
Marketing to Moviegoers: A Handbook of Strategies and Tactics
(
Carbondale
:
Southern Illinois University Press
).
The Matrix
1999
Directed by
Wachowski
Andy
Wachowski
Larry
, performers
Reeves
Keanu
Fishburne
Laurence
Moss
Carrie-Ann
.
Burbank, CA
:
Warner
.
McCarthy
Cormac
2005
No Country for Old Men
(
London
:
Vintage
).
McKee
Ryan
8 Stars You Maybe Didn’t Know Auditioned for ‘Twilight’
Next Movie
,
October
11
.
McLean
Adrienne L.
2003
‘New Films in Story Form’: Movie Story Magazines and Spectatorship
,”
Cinema Journal
42
(
3
):
3
26
.
The Mission
1986
Directed by
Joffé
Roland
, performers
De Niro
Robert
Irons
Jeremy
McAnally
Ray
(
Burbank, CA
:
Warner
).
Moonraker
1979
Directed by
Gilbert
Lewis
, performers
Moore
Roger
Chiles
Lois
Lonsdale
Michael
(
Los Angeles, CA
:
Eon
).
Motion Picture Association of America
2011
What Each Rating Means
,” www.mpaa.org/ratings/what-each-rating-means.
Naremore
James
, ed.
2000
Film Adaptation
(
New Brunswick, NJ
:
Rutgers University Press
).
No Country for Old Men
2007
Directed by
Coen
Joel
Coen
Ethan
, performers
Jones
Tommy Lee
Bardem
Javier
Brolin
Josh
(
Hollywood, CA
:
Paramount Vantage
).
Novak
John Luther
1999
eXistenZ
(
London
:
Pocket
).
The Omen
1976
Directed by
Donner
Richard
, performers
Peck
Gregory
Remick
Lee
Stephens
Harvey
(
Los Angeles, CA
:
20th Century-Fox
).
O’Neill
Joseph
2003
Film: The Best Novelists, the Worst Movie Adaptations
,”
New York Times
,
November
9
, www.nytimes.com/2003/11/09/movies/film-the-best-novelists-the-worst-movie-adaptations.html.
On the Waterfront
1954
Directed by
Kazan
Elia
, performers
Brando
Marlon
Malden
Karl
Cobb
Lee J.
(
Culver City, CA
:
Columbia
).
Out of the Past
1947
Directed by
Tourneur
Jacques
, performers
Mitchum
Robert
Greer
Jane
Douglas
Kirk
(
New York
:
RKO
).
Owenashi
2006
Comic Book Novels: What, JUST Words?
Penny Arcade
,
November
, forums.penny-arcade.com/discussion/7613/comic-book-novels
. . . what-just-words.
Planet of the Apes
2001
Directed by
Burton
Tim
, performers
Wahlberg
Mark
Carter
Helena Bonham
Roth
Tim
(
Los Angeles, CA
:
20th Century-Fox
).
Pride and Prejudice
2005
Directed by
Wright
Joe
, performers
Knightley
Keira
Macfadyen
Matthew
Blethyn
Brenda
(
Universal City, CA
:
Focus Features
).
The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes
1970
Directed by
Wilder
Billy
, performers
Stephens
Robert
Lee
Christopher
Blakely
Colin
(
Hollywood, CA
:
Mirisch
).
Queenan
Joe
2009
Read ’Em and Weep
,”
Guardian
,
July
9
, www.guardian.co.uk/film/2009/jul/10/joe-queenan-movie-novelisation.
Quick
William T.
2001
Planet of the Apes
(
New York
:
HarperCollins
).
Rosenberg
Scott Mitchell
Van Lente
Fred
Foley
Andrew
Lima
Luciano
2011
Cowboys and Aliens
(
New York
:
HarperCollins
).
Ross
Bernard L.
1978
Capricorn One
(
London
:
Futura
).
Rudnick
Elizabeth
2011
Thor
(
New York
:
Marvel
).
Saberhagen
Fred
1992
Bram Stoker’s Dracula
(
New York
:
Signet
).
Schmitt
Claudia
2007
Der Held als Filmsehender: Filmerleben in der Gegenwartsliteratur
(
Würzburg, Germany
:
Königshausen and Neumann
).
Schulberg
Budd
1979
Waterfront
(
Cambridge
:
Bentley
).
Scott
A. O.
2005
Among the Believers
,”
New York Times
,
September
11
, www.nytimes.com/2005/09/11/magazine/11BELIEVERS.html.
Seltzer
David
2006
The Omen
(
New York
:
Signet
).
Sendak
Maurice
1988
[1963]
Where the Wild Things Are
(
London
:
HarperCollins
).
Shail
Andrew
2008
The Motion Picture Story Magazine and the Origins of Popular British Film Culture
,”
Film History
20
(
2
):
181
97
.
Shrek
2001
Directed by
Adamson
Andrew
Jenson
Vicky
, performers
Myers
Mike
Murphy
Eddie
Diaz
Cameron
(
Universal City, CA
:
DreamWorks
).
The Silence of the Lambs
1991
Directed by
Demme
Jonathan
, performers
Foster
Jodie
Hopkins
Anthony
Glenn
Scott
(
New York
:
Orion
).
Singer
Ben
1993
Fiction Tieins and Narrative Intelligibility 1911–18
,”
Film History
5
(
4
):
489
504
.
The Sixth Sense
1999
Directed by
Shyamalan
M. Night
, performers
Willis
Bruce
Osment
Haley Joel
Collette
Toni
.
Burbank, CA
:
Hollywood
.
Slumdog Millionaire
2008
Directed by
Boyle
Danny
, performers
Patel
Dev
Pinto
Freida
Shukla
Saurabh
.
London
:
Celador
.
Spielberg
Steven
1977
Close Encounters of the Third Kind
(
New York
:
Dell
).
Stam
Robert
Raengo
Alessandra
, eds.
2005
Literature and Film: A Guide to the Theory and Practice of Film Adaptation
(
Malden, MA
:
Blackwell
).
Star Trek
2009
Directed by
Abrams
J. J.
, performers
Pine
Chris
Quinto
Zachary
Pegg
Simon
.
Hollywood, CA
:
Paramount
.
Star Wars
1977
Directed by
Lucas
George
, performers
Hamill
Mark
Ford
Harrison
Fisher
Carrie
.
San Francisco, CA
:
Lucasfilm
.
Star Wars: Episode V—The Empire Strikes Back
1980
Directed by
Kershner
Irvin
, performers
Fisher
Carrie
Ford
Harrison
Hamill
Mark
.
San Francisco, CA
:
Lucasfilm
.
Stevenson
Robert Louis
1999
[1883]
Treasure Island
(
New York
:
Penguin
).
Sutherland
T. T.
2010
Disney Alice in Wonderland
(
New York
:
Disney
).
Swarup
Vikas
2005
Q and A
(
New York
:
Scribner
).
Tangled
2010
Directed by
Greno
Nathan
Howard
Byron
, performers
Moore
Mandy
Levi
Zachary
Murphy
Donna
.
Burbank, CA
:
Walt Disney
.
Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
2003
Directed by
Mostow
Jonathan
, performers
Schwarzenegger
Arnold
Stahl
Nick
Loken
Kristanna
.
Boston, MA
:
C2
.
Terminator Salvation
2009
Directed by
McG
, performers
Bale
Christian
Worthington
Sam
Yelchin
Anton
.
Culver City, CA
:
Sony
.
Thor
2011
Directed by
Branagh
Kenneth
, performers
Hemsworth
Chris
Hopkins
Anthony
Portman
Natalie
.
Los Angeles, CA
:
Paramount
.
Thorpe
Kiki
2002
Treasure Planet
(
New York
:
Scholastic
).
Toy Story
1995
Directed by
Lasseter
John
, performers
Hanks
Tom
Allen
Tim
Rickles
Don
.
Emeryville, CA
:
Pixar
.
Transformers: Dark of the Moon
2011
Directed by
Bay
Michael
, performers
LaBeouf
Shia
Huntington-Whiteley
Rosie
Gibson
Tyrese
.
Los Angeles, CA
:
Paramount
.
Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
2009
Directed by
Bay
Michael
, performers
LaBeouf
Shia
Fox
Megan
Duhamel
Josh
.
Universal City, CA
:
DreamWorks
.
Treasure Planet
2002
Directed by
Clements
Ron
Musker
John
, performers
Gordon-Levitt
Joseph
Thompson
Emma
Short
Martin
.
Burbank, CA
:
Walt Disney
.
Trimble
Irene
2010
Tangled
(
New York
:
Random House
).
Van Parys
Thomas
2009
The Commercial Novelization: Research, History, Differentiation
,”
Literature-Film Quarterly
,
October
1
, www.thefreelibrary.com/-a0217787236.
Van Parys
Thomas
Jansen
Lien
Vanhoutte
Elisabeth
2004
eXistenZ, a Different Novelization?
Image and Narrative
9
(
October
), www.imageandnarrative.be/inarchive/performance/vanparys.htm.
Vinge
Joan D.
2011
Cowboys and Aliens
(
New York
:
Tor
).
Welsh
James M.
Lev
Peter
, eds.
2007
The Literature/Film Reader: Issues of Adaptation
(
Lanham, MD
:
Scarecrow
).
WENN
2007
Steven Spielberg Furious over Indiana Jones Plot Leak
,” Hollywood.com,
October
1
, www.hollywood.com/news/Spielberg_Furious_over_Indiana_Jones_Plot_Leak/4926622.
“Where the Wild Things Are” [poster]
2009
Internet Movie Poster Database
, www.movieposterdb.com/movie/0386117/Where-the-Wild-Things-Are.html.
Where the Wild Things Are
2009
Directed by
Jonze
Spike
, performers
Cooper
Chris
Keener
Catherine
O’Hara
Catherine
Ruffalo
Mark
Whitaker
Forest
.
Burbank, CA
:
Warner
.
Wilde
Oscar
2009
[1890]
The Picture of Dorian Gray
(
London
:
Penguin
).
Williams
Jenny
2009
Lunch with Alan Dean Foster, Part I: Turning Movies into Books
,”
Wired
,
July
1
, www.wired.com/geekdad/2009/07/alandeanfosterparti.
The Wolf Man
1941
Directed by
Waggner
George
, performers
Rains
Claude
William
Warren
Chaney
Lon
Jr.
University City, CA
:
Universal
.
The Wolfman
2010
Directed by
Johnston
Joe
, performers
Del Toro
Benicio
Hopkins
Anthony
Blunt
Emily
.
University City, CA
:
Universal
.
Wood
Christopher
1979
Moonraker
(
London
:
Jonathan Cape
).
Wray
Sam
Boyette
Pat
1991
Robinson Crusoe
(
New York
:
Berkley
).
The X Files
1993–2002
Created by
Carter
Chris
, performers
Duchovny
David
Anderson
Gillian
Pileggi
Mitch
.
Los Angeles, CA
:
20th Century-Fox
.
Yacobi
Tamar
1995
Pictorial Models and Narrative Ekphrasis
,”
Poetics Today
16
:
599
649
.
Yojimbo
1961
Directed by
Kurosawa
Akira
, performers
Mifune
Toshirô
Tôno
Eijirô
Nakadai
Tatsuya
(
Tokyo, Japan
).

Author notes

This article was written as part of the research project Framing Media: The Periphery of Fiction and Film at the University of Innsbruck, Austria, funded by the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) and headed by Mario Klarer. I would like to take this opportunity to thank Meir Sternberg and the anonymous referees of Poetics Today for their many priceless suggestions that helped improve this article.