The hermeneutics of suspicion is a term coined by Paul Ricoeur to describe the practice of reading texts against the grain to expose their repressed or hidden meanings. This essay examines the distinctive features of such a hermeneutics as they have shaped literary theory and criticism in recent decades. Suspicious reading, it proposes, is not only an intellectual exercise in demystification, but also a critical style and scholarly sensibility that offers specific pleasures. These pleasures include the aesthetic and ethical satisfactions of fashioning detective-fiction-style plots. The literary critic, like the detective, interprets clues, establishes causal connections, and identifies a guilty party: namely, the literary work accused of whitewashing or concealing social oppression. Deconstructionist critics like Shoshana Felman seek to expose the dangers of such a suspicious hermeneutics but remain thoroughly entangled in the very method they seek to repudiate. The goal of the essay, then, is not to critique and be suspicious of suspicion. Rather, it seeks to take the hermeneutics of suspicion seriously and to understand why it has proved so attractive to contemporary scholars. At the same time, it also suggests that the present-day ubiquity and predictability of this critical method makes its claims to intellectual novelty or political boldness ever harder to sustain.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Anderson, Amanda
2006
The Way We Argue Now
(Princeton, NJ
: Princeton University Press
).Arnold, John H.
2001
Inquisition and Power: Catharism and the Confessing Subject in Medieval Languedoc
(Philadelphia
: University of Pennsylvania Press
).Barthes, Roland
1977
``The Death of the Author
,'' in Image, Music, Text
, translated by Heath, Stephen, 142
–48
(New York
: Hill and Wang
).Berman, Paul Schiff
2001
``Telling a Less Suspicious Story: Notes toward a Non-Skeptical Approach to Legal/Cultural Analysis
,'' University of Connecticut School of Law Articles and Working Papers, Paper 11
.Best, Stephen; Marcus, Sharon, eds.
2009
``The Way We Read Now
.'' Special issue, Representations
108
.Billig, Michael
2000
``Toward a Critique of the Critical
,'' Discourse and Society
11
(3
): 291
–92
.Bruss, Elisabeth
1977
``The Game of Literature and Some Literary Games
,'' New Literary History
9
: 153
–72
.Cusset, François
2008
French Theory: How Foucault, Derrida, Deleuze, and Co. Transformed the Intellectual Life of the United States
, translated by Fort, Jeff; Berganza, Josephine; Jones, Marlon (Minneapolis
: University of Minnesota Press
).de Certeau, Michel
2002
``Reading as Poaching
,'' in The Practice of Everyday Life
, 165
–76
(Los Angeles
: University of California Press
).Farmer, Lindsay
2007
``Arthur and Oscar (and Sherlock): The Reconstructive Trial and the `Hermeneutics of Suspicion,'
'' International Commentary on Evidence
vol. 5
, 1
, article 4
.Farrell, John
2006
Paranoia and Modernity: Cervantes to Rousseau
(Ithaca, NY
: Cornell University Press
).Felman, Shoshana
1982
``Turning the Screw of Interpretation
,'' in Literature and Psychoanalysis: The Question of Reading: Otherwise
, edited by Felman, Shoshana, 94
–207
(Baltimore
: Johns Hopkins University Press
).Felski, Rita
2009
``After Suspicion
,'' Profession
8
: 28
–35
. Forthcoming. ``The Demon of Interpretation.''
Fetterley, Judith
1978
The Resisting Reader: A Feminist Approach to American Fiction
(Bloomington
: Indiana University Press
).Ginzburg, Carlo
1989
``Clues: Roots of an Evidential Paradigm
,'' in Clues, Myths, and the Historical Method
, translated by John, ; Tedeschi, Anne C., 96
–125
(Baltimore
: Johns Hopkins University Press
).Hunter, Ian
2007
``The Time of Theory
,'' Postcolonial Studies
10
(1
): 5
–22
.Jameson, Fredric
1981
The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act
(Ithaca, NY
: Cornell University Press
).Jones, Anna Marie
2007
Problem Novels: Victorian Fiction Theorizes the Sensational Self
(Columbus
: Ohio State University Press
).Josselson, Ruthellen
2004
``The Hermeneutics of Faith and the Hermeneutics of Suspicion
,'' Narrrative Inquiry
14
(1
): 1
–28
.Latour, Bruno
2004
``Why Has Critique Run Out of Steam? From Matters of Fact to Matters of Concern
,'' Critical Inquiry
30
(2
): 225
–48
.Levine, George
1994
``Introduction: Reclaiming the Aesthetic
,'' in Aesthetics and Ideology
, edited by Levine, George, 1
–30
(New Brunswick, NJ
: Rutgers University Press
).Love, Heather
2010
``Close but Not Deep: Literary Ethics and the Descriptive Turn
,'' New Literary History
41
(2
): 371
–92
.Macherey, Pierre
1975
A Theory of Literary Production
(London
: Routledge and Kegan Paul
).Miller, D. A.
1989
The Novel and the Police
(Los Angeles
: University of California Press
).Moretti, Franco
2005
``Clues
,'' in Signs Taken for Wonders: On the Sociology of Literary Forms
, 130
–56
(London
: Verso
).Park, You-me; Rajan, Rajeswari Sunder
2000
The Postcolonial Jane Austen
(London
: Routledge
).Pyrhonen, Heta
1999
Mayhem and Murder: Narrative and Moral Problems in the Detective Story
(Toronto
: University of Toronto Press
).Radway, Janice
1997
A Feeling for Books: The Book-of-the-Month Club, Literary Taste, and Middle-Class Desire
(Chapel Hill
: University of North Carolina Press
).Ricoeur, Paul
1970
Freud and Philosophy: An Essay on Interpretation
(New Haven, CT
: Yale University Press
).Ross, Stephen
2009
``Introduction: The Missing Link
,'' in Modernism and Theory
, edited by Ross, Stephen (New York
: Routledge
).Ryan, Marie-Laure
2003
Narrative as Virtual Reality: Immersion and Interactivity in Literature and Electronic Media
(Baltimore
: Johns Hopkins University Press
).Sedgwick, Eve Kosofsky
1997
``Paranoid Reading and Reparative Reading: or, You're so Paranoid, You Probably Think This Introduction Is about You
,'' in Novel Gazing: Queer Readings in Fiction
, edited by Sedgwick, Eve Kosofsky, 1
–37
(Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
).Smith, Barbara Herrnstein
1995
Critical Terms for Literary Study
(Baltimore
: Johns Hopkins University Press
).Stewart, David.
1989
``The Hermeneutics of Suspicion
,'' Journal of Literature and Theology
4
(3
): 296
–307
.Strowick, Elisabeth
2005
``Comparative Epistemology of Suspicion: Psychoanalysis, Literature, and the Human Sciences
,'' Science in Context
18
(4
): 649
–69
.Thiele, Leslie Paul
1991
``Reading Nietzsche and Foucault: A Hermeneutics of Suspicion?
'' American Political Science Review
85
(2
): 581
–92
.Thomas, Ronald R.
2000
Detective Fiction and the Rise of Forensic Science
(Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
).Thrailkill, Jane F.
2007
Affecting Fictions
(Cambridge, MA
: Harvard University Press
).Todorov, Tzetvan
1977
The Poetics of Prose
, translated by Howard, Richard (Ithaca, NY
: Cornell University Press
).Wimsatt, William K.; Beardsley, Monroe C.
1954
``The Affective Fallacy
,'' in The Verbal Icon: Studies in the Meaning of Poetry
, by Wimsatt, William K., 21
–39
(Lexington
: University Press of Kentucky
).© 2011 by Porter Institute for Poetics and Semiotics
2011
This content is made freely available by the publisher. It may not be redistributed or altered. All rights reserved.
