...Dennis Dalton Communism and Nationalism in India: M. N. Roy and Comintern Policy 1920–1939 . By John Patrick Haithcox . Princeton : Princeton University Press , 1971 . xiv. 389 pp. Illustrations. Notes. Selected Bibliography. Index. $12.50. Copyright © The Association for Asian...

...John P. Haithcox Abstract The Seventh Plenum of the Executive Committee of the Communist International (ECCI), which was held between November 22 and December 16, 1926, principally to consider the Chinese question, met at a crucial period in the history of the Chinese Communist movement. During...

...John P. Haithcox Abstract Before the opening of the Second World Congress of the Communist International (July 19–August 7, 1920) [which met on the first day in Petrograd but subsequently in Moscow], Lenin prepared a draft thesis on the national and colonial question. M. N. Roy, a young Bengali...

...John Patrick Haithcox Peaceful Transition to Communism in India: Strategy of the Communist Party . By Victor M. Fic . Bombay : Nachiketa Publications , 1969 . xi, 478 pp. Appendix, Bibliography, Index. Rs. 50.00. Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1971 1971 490...

...John P. Haithcox Krishna Menon: A Biography . By T. J. S. George . New York : Taplinger Publishing Co., Inc. ix, 267 . Who's Who, Bibliography, Index. $5.00. Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1966 1966 142 at least an introduction, in an engaging way laying...

...John Patrick Haithcox Student Politics in Bombay . By Philip G. Altbach . Bombay : Asia Publishing House , 1968 . 218 pp $5.75. Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1971 1971 912 JOURNAL OF ASIAN STUDIES differences in the traditional order determine differing...

...John Patrick Haithcox The Red Rebel in India: A Study of Communist Strategy and Tactics . By V. B. Sinha . New Delhi : Associated Publishing House , 1968 . xi, 262 pp. Index. Rs. 24.00. Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1970 1970 BOOK REVIEWS 729 heartening...

... received equal credit. The list of Contributors appearing in the August, 1965 issue (XXIV, no. 4) failed to include the names of John P. Haithcox, whose article appears on page 459; Robert E. Ward, whose article appears on page 401; and Kwanha Yim, whose article appears on page 63. Donn V. Hart...

... received equal credit. The list of Contributors appearing in the August, 1965 issue (XXIV, no. 4) failed to include the names of John P. Haithcox, whose article appears on page 459; Robert E. Ward, whose article appears on page 401; and Kwanha Yim, whose article appears on page 63. Donn V. Hart...

... HAITHCOX] 912 BANERJI, Bankura [ j . H. BROOMFIELD] 913 BARNABAS, Citizens' Grievances and Administration: A Study in Participation and Alienation [c. P. BHAMBHRl] 209 BARRIER, The Sikhs and their Literature: A Guide to Tracts, Books and Periodicals, 1849-1919 [HENRY SCHOLBERG] BARRIER AND WALLACE...

... litical writing, of which, unfortunately, we already have a surfeit. JOHN PATRICK HAITHCOX Carleton College Pakistan's Development: Social Goals and Private Incentives. BY GUSTAV F. PAPANEK. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1967, xxii, 354 pp. Statistical Appendix, Index. $8.95. The book...

... of M. N. Roy. Haithcox has managed to enter into this experience, reconstruct and communicate its meaning. This achievement not only provides students of M. N. Roy with an indispensable source, but also sets high scholarly standards for political analyses of other Indian leaders. Barnard College DENNIS...

... in the Amritsar thesis (pp. 356 57)? These and similar questions are not raised in this study. JOHN PATRICK HAITHCOX Carleton College Indian Communism: Split Within a Split. BY MOHAN RAM. Delhi: Vikas Publications, 1969. ix, 293 pp. Bibliography, Index. Rs. 27.50. Here is a tract for the times, rather than...

... movement was "at no time in the vanguard of the independence movement" (p. 203). Its involvement in the factional struggles between various political groups, I would contend, largely accounts for this fact. JOHN PATRICK HAITHCOX Carleton College Bankura. BY AMIYA KUMAR BANERJI. West Bengal District...

... comment. In summary, I think that Mr. Cohen asks very significant questions, and that his answers are intelligent, but they are somewhat thin. CAROLYN M. ELLIOTT University of California, Santa Cruz Communism and Nationalism in India: M. N. Roy and Comintern Policy 1920-1939. BY JOHN PATRICK HAITHCOX...

... Policy: a New Interpretation, by JOHN P. HAITHCOX The Beginnings of Bureaucracy in China: The Origin of the Hsien, by H. o. CREEL Some Fundamental Issues in the History of Chinese Painting, by MAX LOEHR Aspects of the Power of Darkness in Lu Hsun, by T. A. HSIA Japanese Writers and the Greater East Asia...

... Menon: A Biography [John B. Haithcox] Ghoshal, A History of Indian Public Life: The Pre-Maurya and the Maurya Periods [John W. Spellman] Gokhale, Aso\a Maurya [J. P. Sharma] Government of Pakistan and UNESCO, Scientific Problems of the Humid Tropical Zone Deltas and Their Implications: Proceedings...

... between government and the military. JOHN P. HAITHCOX The University of Michigan, Dearborn Many Worlds: An Autobiography. By K. P. S. MENON. London: Oxford University Press, 1965. 313 pp. Index. $4.65. K. P. S. Menon's life story is one of eminent success: a rise from humble beginnings in Kerala to one...

...? or The Goddess on the Tree-top, by NUR YALMAN Nationalism and Communism in India: The Impact of the 1927 Comintern Failure in China, by JOHN P. HAITHCOX Address by Sir George Sansom Editorial Japan's Cultural Identity, by ROBERT N. BELLAH Ch'ing-i and Chinese Policy Formation During the Nineteenth Century...

...: A Study in India-Pakistan Relations [ROBERT A. HUTTENBACK] 449 HAITHCOX, Communism and Nationalism in India: M. N. Roy and Comintern Policy 1920-1939 [DENNIS DALTON] HIEBERT, Konduru: Structure and Integration in a South Indian Village [ALAN R. BEALS] 704 7°9 HEIMSATH AND MANSINGH, A Diplomatic History...