...Walter J. Odronic Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1960 1960 Les premiers conciles bouddhiques . By André Bareau . Paris : Presses Universitaires de France , 1955 . 150 . BOOK REVIEWS 125 tration of the policy and program adopted; and direct reforms, repugnant...

... published in Le Muséon , VI [1905], pp. 213–323. 7 This summary is condensed from Przyluski Jean , Le Concile de Rājagṛha [ Paris : Paul Geuthner , 1926 –1928], pp. 133 – 235 , and also de La Vallée Poussin Louis , “ The Buddhist Councils ,” Indian Antiquary , XXXVII...

... excellence, a form of the most complete Vinaya work" (p. 8) is unconvincing. On the councils, he overlooks the masterful work of Bareau (Les premiers conciles bouddhiques) and Hofinger {Etude sur le concile de Vaisall), and while he does note that the second council and the "Great Schism" separating...

... for the Pali Vinaya presenting "par excellence, a form of the most complete Vinaya work" (p. 8) is unconvincing. On the councils, he overlooks the masterful work of Bareau (Les premiers conciles bouddhiques) and Hofinger {Etude sur le concile de Vaisall), and while he does note that the second council...

... and organization strategists . . . [and] illustrates the workings of the bilateral eco- Les premiers conciles bouddhiques. By ANDR£ BAREAU. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1955. 150. nomic aid and technical assistance program of The Buddhist councils have been studied for the Philippines and the United...

... {shih, vijndna) are ap- which has so admirably been studied and dis- peased and quietened. . . . This is called Ma- cussed by Paul Demieville in his he Concile de hdydna." It is not a question of reality breaking Lhasa, Une controverse sur le quietisme entre out, but of a seeming reflection of reality...

.... In a long note in le concile de Lhasa, Paul Demieville calls attention to Mochizuki Shinko's Bu\\yo \yoten seiritsu shiron,13 where the authenticity of this work is discussed in detail over many pages, beginning on page 493. On page 154 there is mention of " . . . a man who eats cereal grown in the soil...

... this alleged "sutra" is that it has been suspected, in one way or another, for centuries. In a long note in le concile de Lhasa, Paul Demieville calls attention to Mochizuki Shinko's Bu\\yo \yoten seiritsu shiron,13 where the authenticity of this work is discussed in detail over many pages, beginning on page...

... of Buddhism was that of Asoka, primarily recorded in the Dipavamsa, Mahavamsa, and Samantapasadika. Now Frauwallner was certainly not the first researcher to suggest a relationship between the Hlnayana schools and Asoka's missions. Jean Przyluski, for example, devotes an entire chapter of Le Concile de...

... campaigns he conciled and dissolved. Thus, in Wang's perception ducted during his life demonstrates, statesthere exists an essential interdependence or manship and public service inevitably someunity instead of a dichotomy between the inner times involve coercion, violence, utilitarian conand outer, the t'i...

... for Asian Studies, Inc. 1956 1956 1 Cf. Roerich George N. , The Blue Annals ( Calcutta , 1949 ), Part One, p. xv . 2 Demiéville Paul , Le Concile de Lhasa , Bibliothèque de l'Institut des Hautes Études Chinoises, Vol. VII ( Paris , 1952 ), I, 177 , 183 , etc...

..., of which "Le concile de Lhasa" is an outstanding example its date 689 is 1952 and it is not reproduced in either of these volumes should be on the reading list of every advanced student of medieval Chinese culture. The question still remains: do we need personal anthologies of this sort? It appears...

... Tat 14 (1959), 139-41. EKVAIX, R. B. Tibetan self-image. PA 33 (Dec. 1960), 375-82. ENOKI, KAZUO. Tibet. CJSH (1960), 355-57. £TIEMBLE, R. "Zut au Zaine! Du Concile de Lhasa au bombardement de Lhassa." Lettres nouvelles Apr. 28, 1959, 45-50. FITCH, GERALDINE. Tibetan revolt against Chinese rule. New...

... 387 123 397 353 353 540 INDIA Archer, W. G., Indian Miniatures [Stuart C. Welch, Jr.] Archer, W. G., India and Modern Art [Sheila Weiner] Baldwin, George B., Industrial Growth in South India [Henry H. Schloss] Bareau, Andrf, Les premiers conciles bouddhiques [Walter J. Odronic] Berna, James J...

... Demiéville Paul , Le concile de Lhasa ( Paris , 1952 ), pp. 348 –50 and passim. 41 Tsukamoto Zenryū, chapter on Chinese Buddhism in Shina shūkyōshi [ History of Chinese Religions ], Vol. XI of the Shina chiri rekishi taikei (Tokyo, 1942 ), p. 195 . 42 See Gernet...

... Hautes Études Chinoises , 1937 ), V, pp. 190 – 222 . 11 Ibid., p. 190. 12 Przyluski Jean , Le Concile de Rājagrha, Introduction à I'histoire des canons et des sectes bouddhiques , Paris : Librairie Orientaliste Paul Geuthner , 1926 . 13 Poussin (n. 10 above), p...

... and is preparing them for publication. Professor Demieville's latest book Le Concile de Lhassa, une Controverse sur le Qui'etisme entre Bouddhistes de I'lnde et de la Chine^ will be out soon as volume VII of the Bibliotheque de I'lnstitut des Hautes Etudes Chinoises. Professor Ch. Haguenauer's work on Trots etudes...

.... by H. Oldenberg, vol. 2, p. 284f . 7 On the early Buddhist councils see Frauwallner E. , “ Die buddhistischen Konzile ,” Zeitschrijt der Deutschen Morgenlaendischen Gesellschaft 102 ( 1952 ), pp. 240 –61 ; Bareau A. , Les premiers conciles bouddhiques ( Paris , 1955...

.... 1'Europe antique a 1'Europe mddievale. CREEL, H. G. On two aspects of early Techniques et civilisations 2, no. 2 (1952), Taoism. SVJ, 43-53. 37-41. DEMIEVILLE, PAUL. Le concile de Lhasa; Hu SHIH. The Gest Oriental Library at une controverse sur le quiitisme entre Princeton University. Princeton Uni...

... [pref. 1956] 92 p. (his National bibliographies no. 3) UNESCO. RESEARCH CENTRE ON THE . Les premiers conciles bouddhiques. Paris, 1955. xii, 150 p . (Paris. Mus6e Guimet. Annales. Bibliotheque d'eludes, t. 60) . Les sectes bouddhiques du petit vihicule. Saigon, Ecole franchise d'ExtrSme-Orient, 1955...