...Hafeez Malik The Emergence of Pakistan . By Chaudhri Muhammad Ali . New York : Columbia University Press , 1967 . ix, 418 pp. Index. $11.00. Copyright © The Association for Asian Studies, Inc. 1968 1968 BOOK REVIEWS 893 three obscure and overlapping customary dues, the de\um...

... that would en­able them to arg­ ue for the comp­ ati­ b­ il­ity of Is­lam and mod­ er­nity and guar­an­tee the int­ e­gra­tion of Musl­ ims into mode­ rn China with­out jeopardizing their dis­tinct Mus­lim iden­ti­ty. KEYWORDS Isl­amic ref­orm, Ahmadiyya, Muhammad Ali, Wu Tegong, Chi­nese Mus­lim...

... by V. P. Menon, India Wins Freedom by Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, and Mission with Mountbatten by Alan CampbellJohnson. These authors have generally perceived the birth of Pakistan as a "problem of India," and blamed the "irrationality" and "intransigence" of Muhammad Ali Jinnah and the Muslim League...

... to be two theories, both given credence in The Emergence of Pakistan by Ali Chaudhril Muhammad ( New York : Columbia Univ. Press , 1967 ) . 1. The boundary was fixed in advance by agreement with the Congress, and Radcliffe was brought out to conduct a “cover” operation (pp. 208 and 216); 2...

... of political backgrounds, the conference claimed to be a representative body but not a political party. Aziz asserts that the only important Muslim leader who did not participate was Muhammad Ali Jinnah. As a reaction to the Nehru Report, the conference objected to three things. First, the Nehru Report...

...: Soldier and Statesman, Speeches and Statements (1958–65) of Field Marshall Muhammad Ayub Khan, President of Pakistan . Lahore : Muhammad Ali Academy . Kerr Clark . 1960 . Industrialism and Industrial Man . Cambridge : Harvard University Press . Khalid K. B. , ed. 1967 . Asar-i-Latif...

... . 1978 . Bangladesh: Constitutional Quest for Autonomy, 1950–1971 . Wiesbaden : Franz Steiner Verlag . Ahmed Rafiuddin . 1981 . The Bengal Muslims, 1871–1906: A Quest for Identity . Delhi : Oxford University Press . Ali Chaudhri Muhammad . 1967 . The Emergence of Pakistan . New...

... regards some rulers, including Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Liaqat Ali Khan, Ayub Khan, and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, as having held special promise, and others, including Zia al-Haq, as particularly harmful, each ruler ultimately failed to deliver and left Pakistan worse off than before. Talbot entitles the final...

...., Saiyad Muhammad Ali, Ma\h- achievements were those of all Punjabis alike, zan-i-Ahmadi, Agra, 1882; Ja'ffar 'Ali Naqvi, Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs. It was in the fit- Manzurat al-Sa'add fi Ahwdl al-Ghazvdt-o- ness of things that the crowning success of Shuh'add; Nawab WazIr-ud-Daulah, Wasayd Punjabi arms...

... of the Congress was confined to jail for the next two years. Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the chief initiator of the idea of Pakistan, was alone in characterizing the war as a “blessing in disguise” (p. 135) since it was during this period, with the Congress sulking in isolation, that the Muslim League gained ascendancy...

.... . . . The Sikhs became the spearhead of the nationalist movement which had gath- 182 JOURNAL OF ASIAN STUDIES ered the parent communities in its fold. The histories (e.g., Saiyad Muhammad Ali, Ma\h- achievements were those of all Punjabis alike, zan-i-Ahmadi, Agra, 1882; Ja'ffar 'Ali Naqvi, Hindus, Muslims...

... scholarship. The new perspective from which Ayesha Jalal evaluates the role of Muhammad Ali Jinnah in creating Pakistan comes not only from a painstaking distillation of documents but also from the disenchantment with Pakistan that liberal scholars feel as a result of its grave problems of social and regional...

..., the first year of Nawaz Sharif s second incumbency. While Talbot regards some rulers, including Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Liaqat Ali Khan, Ayub Khan, and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, as having held special promise, and others, including Zia al-Haq, as particularly harmful, each ruler ultimately failed to deliver...

... scholarship. The new perspective from which Ayesha Jalal evaluates the role of Muhammad Ali Jinnah in creating Pakistan comes not only from a painstaking distillation of documents but also from the disenchantment with Pakistan that liberal scholars feel as a result of its grave problems of social and regional...

... E D . London: Routledge, 1997. xxxix, 274 pp. $1995 (paper). This is a disappointing book. It is disappointing because the task that Akbar Ahmed sets for himself is an important one, yet the book falls well short of achieving its goal. Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the leader of the movement for Pakistan...

... is Ishtiaq Husain Qureshi's The Muslim Community of the Indo-Pakistan Subcontinent. Among the Muslim thinkers of the colonial period that he discusses are Shah Wali-u'llah, Shah Abdul Aziz, Sayyid Ahmad of Rae Bareli, Sayyid Ahmad Khan, Abul Kalam Azad, Muhammad Iqbal, and Muhammad Ali, although, curiously...

... (1945-47) during which Pakistan emerged (Chapters IV and V), this is best presented in The Emergence of Pakistan by Chaudhari Muhammad Ali (Columbia University Press, 1967). If, however, there is any theoretical focus in this study it is to be found in Part II. In fact Part II is a monograph in itself...

... period (1945-47) during which Pakistan emerged (Chapters IV and V), this is best presented in The Emergence of Pakistan by Chaudhari Muhammad Ali (Columbia University Press, 1967). If, however, there is any theoretical focus in this study it is to be found in Part II. In fact Part II is a monograph...

..., the conference claimed to be a representative body but not a political party. Aziz asserts that the only important Muslim leader who did not participate was Muhammad Ali Jinnah. As a reaction to the Nehru Report, the conference objected to three things. First, the Nehru Report emphatically opposed separate...