Abstract

This essay is an exploration of one aspect of the politics of gender representation in Thailand, namely, how the portrayals of Siamese women in Thai popular histories form part of the present-day shaping of gender relations. I argue that moving in tandem with developments in academic historiography, popular history since the 1980s has become a battleground for cultural hegemony.

Hitherto the preserve of antiquarians, popular history has caught the interest of the emergent middle class, who are intent on inscribing their reading of the past on the Thai cultural landscape. Where gender relations are concerned, the middle class has worked out a modern rationale for the traditional view that women are subordinate to men. However, critical scholars, alert to what they see as the perpetuation of the historical subordination of women through the medium of popular history, have sought to stem the tide by addressing their critiques of the middle-class interpretations to a popular audience.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

List of References

Archival Sources

Kong chotmaihet haeng chat [National Archives of Thailand]

Documents of the Fifth Reign (R 5)

Nakhonban [Ministry of Local Government (N)]

Yutthithan [Ministry of Justice (Y)]

Documents of the Sixth Reign (R6)

Nakhonban [Ministry of Local Government (N)]

Published Sources

Rabibhadana, Akin.
1969
The Social Organization of Thai Society in the Early Bangkok Period, 1782–1873
. Southeast Asia Program Data Paper No. 74.
Ithaca
:
Cornell University, Department of Asian Studies
.
Raphiphat, Akhin and Ieosriwong, Nithi.
1990
. “
Pakhaoma phasin lae kangkaengnai
” (Loin-cloths and underpants). Gloss provided by
Sinlapa watthanatham
. Sinlapa watthanatham
12
.
2
:
106
–16.
Breazeale, Kennon.
1971
. “
A Transition in Historical Writing: The Works of Prince Damrong Rachanuphap
.”
Journal of the Siam Society
59
.
2
:
25
49
.
Iamkrasin, Chali.
1987
.
Ro ha kab krungsayam
(The Fifth Reign and Siam).
Bangkok
:
Odeon Store
.
Huat, Chua Beng.
1995
.
Communitarian Ideology and Democracy in Singapore
.
London
:
Routledge
.
Rachanuphab, Damrong. [1914]
1977
. “Chaochommanda Thiang” (Consort Thiang). In
Phrasanom ek
(Chief consorts). Reprint,
Bangkok
.
Mettarikanon, Dararat.
1982
. “Sophaeni kab ratthaban thai pho so 2411–2503” (Prostitution and the Thai Government's policy, 1868–1960). Master's thesis,
Department of History, Chulalongkorn University
.
Darian-Smith, Kate, and Hamilton, Paula, eds.
1994
.
Memory and History in Twentieth-Century Australia
.
Melbourne
:
Oxford University Press
.
De la Loubère, Simon. [
1963
] n.d.
A New Historical Relation of the Kingdom of Siam
.
London
.
Reprint, Bangkok, n.d.
Nivat, Dhani, Prince, .
1941
.
Prawat Thao Worachan
(The History of Thao Worachan).
Cremation Volume, Thao Worachan (Wad)
.
Bangkok
.
Lysa, Hong.
1991
. “Warasan setthasat kanmu'ang: Critical Scholarship in Post-1976 Thailand.” In
Thai Constructions of Knowledge
, edited by Chitakasem, Manas and Turton, Andrew.
London
:
School of African and Oriental Studies
.
Haas, Mary, comp.
1964
.
Thai-English Student's Dictionary
.
Stanford
:
Stanford University Press
.
Tejapira, Kasian.
1994
. “The Post-modernization of Thainess.” Paper presented at the workshop on postmodernist scholarship in Southeast Asia. Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore.
Chotmarak, Lawan.
1978
.
Rakraek khong rachakan thi ha
(The first love of the Fifth Reign).
Bangkok
:
Duangkamol
.
Leonowens, Anna. [1872]
1991
.
The Romance of the Harem
.
Edited and with an introduction by Susan Morgan. Charlottesville
:
University of Virginia Press
.
McVey, Ruth.
1992
. “The Materialisation of the Southeast Asian Entrepreneur.” In
Southeast Asian Capitalists
, edited by McVey, Ruth.
Cornell
:
Southeast Asia Program
.
Aeusrivongse, Nidhi.
1994
a. “
The Early Bangkok Period: Literary Change and its Social Causes
.”
Asian Studies Review: Journal of the Asian Studies Association of Australia
18
.
1
(July):
69
76
.
Aeusrivongse, Nidhi.
1994
b.
Maihet watthanatham ruamsamai
(Notes on contemporary culture).
Bangkok
:
Phraeo Press
.
Ieosriwong, Nlthl.
1982
. “Watthanatham kradumphi kab wannakam ton rattanakosin” (Bourgeoisie culture and the literature of the early Bangkok period). In
Pakkai lae bairua
(Pen and Sail), edited by Ieosriwong, Nithi.
Bangkok
:
Amarin Press
.
Olson, Grant A.
1992
. “
Thai Cremation Volumes: A Brief History of a Unique Genre of Literature
.”
Asian Folklore Studies
41
.
2
:
279
–94.
Phongpaichit, Pasuk.
1982
.
From Peasant Girls to Bangkok Masseuses
. Women, Work, and Development 2.
Geneva
:
International Labour Office
.
Phongpaichit, Pasuk.
1991
. “
Capital Accumulation in Thailand
,”
Journal of Southeast Asian Studies
22
.
2
:
379
–86.
Pateman, Carol.
1988
.
The Sexual Contract
.
Cambridge
:
Polity Press
.
Chomchai, Prachoom.
1965
.
Chulalongkorn the Great
.
Tokyo
:
The Centre for East Asian Cultural Studies
.
Reynolds, Craig J.
1977
. “A Nineteenth-Century Thai Buddhist Defense of Polygamy and Some Remarks on the Social History of Women in Thailand.” In
Proceedings, Seventh IAHA Conference
.
Bangkok
:
Chulalongkorn University
,
927
–70.
Reynolds, Craig J.
1979
.
What is Social History?
Paper No. 8 (Thai and English).
Bangkok
:
Thai Khadi Research Institute, Thammasat University
. Thai version reprinted Bangkok 1984.
Reynolds, Craig J.
1994
. “
Predicaments of Modern Thai History
.”
Southeast Asia Research
2
.
1
:
64
90
.
Reynolds, Craig J.;
1996
. “Tycoons and Warlords: Modern Thai Social Formations and Chinese Historical Romance.” In
Sojourners and Settlers: Histories of Southeast Asia and the Chinese
, edited by Reid, Anthony.
New South Wales
:
Asian Studies Association of Australia in association with Allen and Unwin
.
Reynolds, Craig J., and Lysa, Hong.
1983
. “
Marxism in Thai Historical Studies
.”
Journal of Asian Studies
43
.
1
:
77
104
.
Virasinchai, Sansani.
1991
. “
Chaochommanda Thiang nai rachakan thi si
” (Queen Chao Chom Manda Thiang of the Fourth Reign). Gloss provided by
Sinlapa watthanatham
. Sinlapa watthanatham
13
.
1
:
104
–9.
Virasinchai, Sansani.
1993
. “
Maeo Inao: Chaochommanda Wad
” (Chao Chom Manda Wad). Gloss provided by
Sinlapa watthanatham
. Sinlapa watthanatham
13
.
5
:
160
–67.
Scott, Joan W.
1988
.
Gender and the Politics of History
.
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Watthanatham, Sinlapa (Art and Culture). Bangkok: Chaophraya,
1980
1989
; Matichon, 1990 to present.
Watthanatham, Sinlapa.
1988
. ‘“Mob dokchaba’ prachan krasuang su'ksathikan korani ‘bidbu'an’ prawattisat thai” (Presenting the Ministry of Education with a hibiscus to dishonour its distortion of Thai history).
Skrobenek, Siriporn.
1983
. “The Transnational Sex-Exploitation of Thai Women.” Master's thesis,
Development Studies, The Hague
.
Akira, Suehiro.
1992
. “Capitalist Development in Postwar Thailand: Commercial Bankers, Industrial Elite, and Agribusiness Groups.” In
Southeast Asian Capitalists
, edited by McVey, Ruth.
Ithaca, N.Y.
:
Cornell Southeast Asian Studies Program
.
Patana, Suwadee T..
1994
. “Polygamy or Monogamy: The Debate on Gender Relations in Thai Society, 1913–1935,” 13th International Conference of Historians of Asia (IAHA), Tokyo.
Thapthong, Thepchu.
1983
.
Yingkhomkhieo: prawattisat an khomkheun khong sophaeni nai sangkhomthai
(Women of the green lamp: A bitter history of prostitution in Thai society).
Bangkok
:
Chaophraya
.
Winichakul, Thongchai.
1995
. “
The Changing Landscape of the Past: New Histories in Thailand Since 1973
.”
Journal of Southeast Asian Studies
26
.
1
(March):
99
120
.
Trouillot, Michel-Rolph.
1995
.
Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History
.
Boston
:
Beacon Press
.
Van Esterik, Penny.
1992
. “Thai Prostitution and the Medical Gaze.” In
Gender and Development in Southeast Asia
, edited by Penny, and Esterik, John van.
Montreal
:
Canadian Asian Studies Association, McGill University
.
Boonchalaksi, Wathinee, and Guest, Philip.
Prostitution in Thailand
. The Institute of Population and Social Research.
Bangkok
:
Mahidol University
.
Wyatt, David K.;
1982
. “The ‘Subtle Revolution’ of Rama I.“In
Moral Order and the Question of Change: Essays on Southeast Asian Thought
, edited by Woodside, Alexander B and Wyatt, David K..
New Haven, Conn.
:
Yale University Press
.