Abstract

In August 1927 the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in Jiangxi seemed moribund, yet by the end of 1930 the movement was larger and more active than ever before. How did this occur? Past studies have especially emphasized Mao Zedong's famous rural guerrilla strategy, but this was only part of the story. Equally significant was the little-studied success of members of the Jiangxi hill-country elite who were also in the CCP in using established schools and educational societies, time-honored traditions of local strongman behavior, and existing bandit–secret society gangs to build many localized base areas. Such techniques were congenial to CCP leaders and essential to the movement's survival in the early days when its prestige and material resources were at a very low ebb, and when radical reforms would almost certainly have failed. Nevertheless, this strategy also fostered parochial attitudes and organizational weaknesses that clashed with the later efforts of Mao and his allies to carry out mass mobilization and fundamental land reform. Only after a prolonged and violent crisis within the base areas did the “Maoist” policies vital for the revolution's long-term growth begin to overcome the policies of elite coalition building that had been necessary for the movement to obtain its initial foothold in the Jiangxi hill country.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

List of References

Hiroshi, Abe.
1965
. “
Shinmatsu no kindai gakkō: Kōsei sho o chūshin ni
” [Modern schools in the late Qing period: Jiangxi].
Rekishi hyōron
173
:
47
60
; 175:51–66.
Averill, Stephen C.
1982
. “Revolution in the Highlands: The Rise of the Communist Movement in Jiangxi Province.” Ph.D. diss.
Cornell University
.
Averill, Stephen C.
1983
. “
The Shed People and the Opening of the Yangzi Highlands
.”
Modern China
9.1
:
84
126
.
Borthwick, Sally.
1983
.
Education and Social Change in China: The Beginnings of the Modern Era
.
Stanford, Calif.
:
Hoover Institution Press
.
Qihan, Chen.
1959
. “
Xingguo de chuqi geming douzheng
” [The first period of revolutionary struggle in Xingguo]. In
XHLY
1
:
407
–17.
Zhengren, Chen.
1980
. “
Mao Zedong tongzhi chuangjian Jinggangshan geming genjudi de weida shijian
” [The great practice of comrade Mao Zedong in founding the Jinggangshan revolutionary base area]. In
JWSZL
1
:
34
65
.
Tianfang, Cheng.
1968
.
Cheng Tianfang caonian huiyilu
[Remembrances of Cheng Tianfang's early years].
Taibei
.
Chow, Tse-tsung.
1967
.
The May Fourth Movement: Intellectual Revolution in Modern China
.
Stanford, Calif.
:
Stanford University Press
.
Clubb, O. Edmund.
1965
.
Twentieth-Century China
.
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Zihui, Deng and Dingcheng, Zhang.
1959
Minxi baodong yu hong shier jun
” [The Western Fujian Uprising and the Red Twelfth Army]. In
XHLY
1
:
379
406
.
Defeng, Du.
1982
. “
Zenyang kandai Li Liejun zhenya Jiangxi huitang
” [How should one regard Li Liejun's suppression of the Jiangxi secret societies].
JSHKX
2
:
99
107
.
“Fang Zhimin Zhuan” bianxie zu
1982
.
Fang Zhimin zhuan
[A biography of Fang Zhimin].
Nanchang
:
Jiangxi renmin chuban she
.
Grimm, Tillman.;
1977
. “Academies and Urban Systems in Kwangtung.” In
The City in Late Imperial China
, ed. Skinner, G. William,
475
–98.
Stanford, Calif.
:
Stanford University Press
.
Qi, Guo and Xia, Dong.
1982
. “
Jiangxi Suqu chuqi de xiaofan yu Futian Shibian
” [The Futian Incident and the suppression of counterrevolutionaries in the early period of the Jiangxi soviet areas].
DSYJZL
5
:
7
25
.
Kan-chih, Ho.
1959
.
A History of the Modern Chinese Revolution
.
Beijing
:
Foreign Languages Press
.
Hofheinz, Roy.
1977
.
The Broken Wave: The Chinese Communist Peasant Movement, 1922–1928
.
Cambridge, Mass.
:
Harvard University Press
.
Tso-liang, Hsiao.
1961
.
Power Relations Within the Chinese Communist Movement, 1930–1934
.
Seattle
:
University of Washington Press
.
Tso-liang, Hsiao
1969
.
The Land Revolution in China, 1930–1934: A Study of Documents
.
Seattle
:
University of Washington Press
.
Delan, Hu.
1981
. “Shao Sniping qingshao nian shidai de douzheng shenghuo” [The struggle activities of Shao Shiping during his youth]. In NQYH,
67
77
.
Yueyi, Hu.
1982
. “
Da Geming chuqi Jiujiang, Xiushui jiantang pianduan
” [Anecdotes concerning the establishment of the Jiujiang and Xiushui party during the early period of the Great Revolution].
JWSZL
8
:
83
90
.
Muxian, Huang.
1981
. “
Jiangxi gongnong di qi, di jiu zongdui de chuangjian
” [The founding of the Jiangxi Worker-Peasant Red Army's Seventh and Ninth Columns].
JSHKX
1
:
59
62
.
Huang, Philip C. C.
1975
. “
Mao Tse-tung and the Middle Peasants, 1925–1928
Modern China
1.3
:
271–96
.
Huang, Philip C. C..
1978
. “Intellectuals, Lumpenproletarians, Workers, and Peasants in the Communist Movement: The Case of Xingguo County, 1927–1934.” In
Chinese Communists and Rural Society 1927–1934
, by Huang, Philip C. C., Bell, Lynda Schaefer, and Walker, Kathy Lemons,
5
28
. China Research Monographs, no. 13.
Berkeley
:
University of California Center for Chinese Studies
.
Yeluo, Huang and Xianzhao, Xu.
1981
. “Yuan Yubing he Gaizhao she” [Yuan Yubing and the Reform Society]. In NQYH,
19
32
.
Israel, John.
1966
.
Student Nationalism in China, 1927–1937
.
Stanford, Calif.
:
Stanford University Press
.
Ji'an xianzhi [Gazetteer of Ji'an county].
1941
.
Jiangxi guanbao [Jiangxi gazette].
Jiangxi sheng minzheng ting
.
1960
.
Buxiu de geming zhanshi
[Immortal revolutionary warriors].
Nanchang
:
Jiangxi renmin chuban she
.
Jiangxi sheng minzheng ting
.
1980
.
Bixue danxin
[Loyalty until death].
Nanchang
:
Jiangxi renmin chuban she
.
Jiangxi sheng Nanchang shi renmin weiyuan hui bangongting lishi yangezu.
1957
. “
Nanchang dashiji
” [Account of major events in Nanchang].
Jindai shi ziliao
4
:
105
–43
“Jinggangshan geming genjudi de jingji douzheng” bianxie zu.
1977
.
Jinggangshan geming genjudi de jingji douzheng
[The economic struggle in the Jinggangshan revolutionary base area].
Nanchang
:
Jiangxi renmin chuban she
.
Zhen, Ke.
1959
. “Ganxi Suweiai quyu de xianzhuang” [Conditions in the West Jiangxi soviet area]. In ZGZJ,
145
–51.
Kuhn, Philip A.;
1975
. “Local Self-Government Under the Republic: Problems of Control, Autonomy, and Mobilization.” In
Conflict and Control in Late Imperial China
, ed. Wakeman, FredericJr, and Grant, Carolyn,
257
–98.
Berkeley and Los Angeles
:
University of California Press
.
Laves, Edward.
1980
. “Rural Society and Modern Revolution: The Rise of the Jiangxi Soviet.” Ph.D diss.
University of Chicago
.
Ting, Li.
1959
Milin xinghuo
” [A spark of fire in the deep forest]. In
XHLY
1
:
418
– 25.
Ting, Li.
1980
. “
Chongxian nongmin baodong
[The peasant uprising in Chongxian].
JWSZL
1
:
133–39
.
Shan, Lin.
1971
. “
Lean Zhang Tianmin xiansheng yishi
” [Anecdotes about Mr. Zhang Tianmin of Lean].
Jiangxi wenxian
63
:
24
28
.
Xiaonong, Liu.
1980
. “
Yuan Wencai, Wang Zuo ji qi budui shimo
” [The beginning and end of the detachment of Yuan Wencai and Wang Zuo].
JWSZL
3
:
101
–20.
Dangping, Lu et al., eds.
1972
.
Jiang Bozhang xianshengshiwenji
[The collected poetry and prose of Mr. Jiang Bozhang].
Taibei
.
Zedong, Mao.
1949
.
Nongcun diaocha
[Rural investigations].
Shanghai
:
Xinhua shudian
.
Zedong, Mao.
1964
.
Selected Works of Mao Tse-tung
.
4
vols.
Beijing
:
Foreign Languages Press
.
Min, Mia.
1962
.
Fang Chih-min—Revolutionary Fighter
.
Beijing
:
Foreign Languages Press
.
Ru, Peng.
1981
. “
Gongtong zhandou de suiyue—huiyi Chen Zhengren tongzhi
” [Years of common combat—remembering comrade Chen Zhengren].
HQPP
21
:
177
–99.
Zhou, Qiu.
1982
. “
Huiyi Yudu baodong,
” [Remembering the Yudu Uprising].
JWSZL
8
:
62
82
.
Rue, John.
1966
.
Mao Tse-tung in Opposition, 1927–1935
.
Stanford, Calif.
:
Stanford University Press
.
Schram, Stuart.
1967
.
Mao Tse-tung
.
Baltimore
:
Penguin Books
.
Shao, Shiping.
1959
. “Zhongguo gongnong hongjun dishi juntuan dansheng qian gan dongbei chuqi nongmin yundong de gaikuang” [Conditions in the early peasant movement in Northeast Jiangxi before the birth of the Chinese Worker Peasant Tenth Red Army]. In ZGZJ,
242
–55.
Shiping, Shao et al.
1980
. “
Min-Zhe-Wan-Gan (Gan dongbei) dangshi
” [History of the party in the Fujian-Zhejiang-Anhui-Jiangxi (Northeast Jiangxi) area].
JWSZL
1
:
66–103
.
Feng, Shi.
1975
.
Fang Zhimin
.
Shanghai
:
Shanghai renmin chuban she
.
Skinner, G. William.
1977
. “Cities and the Hierarchy of Local Systems.” In
The City in Late Imperial China
, ed. Skinner, G. William,
275
352
.
Stanford, Calif.
:
Stanford University Press
.
Smedley, Agnes.
1972
.
The Great Road: The Life and Times of Chu The
.
New York
:
Monthly Review Press
.
Suleski, Ronald.
1969
. “The Fu-t'ian Incident, December 1930.” In
Early Communist China: Two Studies
, by Suleski, Ronald and Bays, Daniel,
1
27
.
Ann Arbor, Mich
.:
University of Michigan Center for Chinese Studies
.
Tadao, Tanaka.
1930
.
Kakumei Shina nōson no jisshōteki kenkyū
[Practical study of the Chinese countryside in revolution].
Tokyo
.
Wenjie, Wu.
1857
.
Wu Wenjie gong (Wenrong) yiji
[The works of Mr. Wu Wenjie (Wenrong)]. Reprint.
Taiwan
:
Wenhua
.
Cen, Xiao.
1933
. “
AB tuan zai Jiangxi
” [The AB Clique in Jiangxi].
Shehui xinwen
3.8
:
116
–18; 3.9:133–35.
Yi, Xie.
1932
. “Jiangxi gongfei gaikuang” [The general condition of the Communist bandits in Jiangxi]. Changong banyue kan [Communist-suppression bimonthly]
24
25
:37–80.
Zhengdong, Yu.
1934
. “Longgang tebiequ shehui diaocha” [A social survey of the Longgang Special District]. Zhongyang ribao [Central Daily News], July 11.
Dian, Yue.
1982
. “
Da Geming shiqi Dongxiang xian dang de jianli he douzheng
” [The founding and struggle of the party in Dongxiang county during the period of the Great Revolution].
JWSZL
11
:
89
99
.
Biyi, Zeng.
1980
. “
Hui Gu Bai tongzhi
” [Remembering comrade Gu Bai].
HQPP
19
:
88
105
.
Shan, Zeng.
1980
. “
Huiyi Gan xinan Suweiai shiji
” [Recollections of the Southwest Jiangxi soviet period],
JWSZL
1
:
1
13
.
Zhenhe, Zhang and Yuanying, Ding.
1982
. “
Qingmo minbian nianbiao
” [A chronology of popular uprisings in the late Qing].
Jindai shi ziliao
3
:
108
–81; 4:77— 121.
Shengchang, Zheng.
1935
. “Futian shibian zhi jingguo yu fenxi” [The course of the Futian Incident and an analysis of it]. In his
Chiqu zhuwenti pipan
[Criticism on several problems in the Red areas].
Beiping
.
Ping, Zhong.
1981
. “
‘Ci shi dong Jinggang’—donggu diqu de chuqi geming douzheng
,” [“This is the eastern Jinggang”—the early period of revolutionary struggle in the Donggu area].
JWSZL
7
:
53
67
.
[Zhonggong Jiangxi sheng weiyuan hui].
1927
. “Jiangxi sheng wei baogao” [Report of the Jiangxi Provincial Committee]. Zhongyang zhengzbi tongxun, 16.
Zhonggong Ruijin xianyi dangshi bianzuan weiyuan hui.
1959
. Ruijin renmin geming douzheng shi (changgao) [History of the revolutionary struggle of the people of Ruijin (draft)].
Jifa, Zhuang.
1981
.
Qingdai tiandi hui yuanliu kao
[A study of the origin and development of the Qing Dynasty Heaven and Earth Society].
Taibei
:
Guoli gugong bowu yuan
.
Zhuo-ren, [pseud.].
1934
. “
Wanbao yilu
” [Recollections of the Wan'an Uprising].
Shehui xinwen
6
.
15
17
:217–21.