The U.S. Congress enacted expansive (and expensive) health care reforms amid the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression. Public acquiescence provided crucial political cover; elites on both sides struggled mightily to sway popular opinion. Were reformers' efforts made easier or more difficult by the tough economic times? Using newly available data on Americans' perceptions of economic insecurity and attitudes toward public policy, this article explores the relationship between economic circumstances and political attitudes. The findings suggest that the Great Recession both facilitated and impeded efforts to rally the public in favor of reform: perceptions of past declines in the U.S. economy bolstered government intervention, but household economic insecurity both distracted attention from large medical expenses (which otherwise legitimized collective action) and undermined Americans' support for additional government spending. Equally consequential, reformers' efforts to adapt to economic stringency by portraying reform as exclusively about affordability missed opportunities for broadening popular support for these interventions; in the longer run this may, unless corrected, prove a decisive misstep in shepherding the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act through its long time line of implementation.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

References

Amenta, E.; Paulsen, J. D..
1996
.
Social Politics in Context: The Institutional Politics Theory and Social Spending at the End of the New Deal
.
Social Forces
75
:
33
60
.
American National Election Studies (ANES)
.
2009
.
2008 – 2009 Panel Study [dataset]
.
Stanford University and the University of Michigan
. http://electionstudies.org/studypages/2008_2009panel/anes2008_2009panel.htm
(accessed August 11, 2011)
.
Attewell, P.
1999
.
The Impact of Family on Job Displacement and Recovery
.
Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science
562
:
66
82
.
Bartels, L.
2005
.
Homer Gets a Tax Cut: Inequality and Public Policy in the American Mind
.
Perspectives on Politics
3
:
15
31
.
Bentolila, S.; Ichino, A..
2008
.
Unemployment and Consumption Near and Far Away from the Mediterranean
.
Journal of Population Economics
21
:
255
280
.
Brodie, M.; Altman, D.; Dean, C.; Buscho, S.; Hamel, E..
2010
.
Liking the Pieces, Not the Package: Contradictions in Public Opinion during Health Care Reform
.
Health Affairs
29
:
1125
1130
.
Brodie, M.; Hamel, E. C.; Altman, D. E.; Blendon, R. J.; Benson, J. M..
2003
.
Health News and the American Public, 1996 – 2002
.
Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
28
:
927
950
.
Conover, P.; Feldman, S.; Knight, K..
1987
.
The Personal and Political Underpinnings of Economic Forecasts
.
American Journal of Political Science
31
:
559
583
.
Cook, F.; Barrett, E..
1992
.
Support for the American Welfare State: Views of Congress and the Public
.
New York
:
Columbia University Press
.
Cusack, T.; Iversen, T.; Rehm, P..
2006
.
Risks at Work: The Demand and Supply Sides of Government Redistribution
.
Oxford Review of Economic Policy
22
:
365
389
.
Delli Carpini, M; Keeter, S..
1996
.
What Americans Know about Politics and Why It Matters
.
New Haven, CT
:
Yale University Press
.
DiTella, R.; MacCullock, R..
2002
.
Informal Family Insurance and the Design of the Welfare State
.
Economic Journal
112
:
481
503
.
Doonan, M. T.; Tull, K. R..
2010
.
Health Care Reform in Massachusetts: Implementation of Coverage Expansions and a Health Insurance Mandate
.
Milbank Quarterly
88
:
54
80
.
Fritze, J.
2010
.
Next Phase in Health Care War: Applying the Law; Cabinet Braces for Lobbying Blitz by Industry Advocates
.
USA Today
,
April
27
.
Geys, B.; Vermeir, J..
2008
.
Taxation and Presidential Approval: Separate Effects from Tax Burden and Tax Structure Turbulence?
Public Choice
135
:
301
317
.
Hacker, J.
2006
.
The Great Risk Shift
.
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Hacker, J. S.; Rehm, P.; Schlesinger, M..
2010
.
Standing on Shaky Ground: Americans' Experiences with Economic Insecurity
.
Economic Security Index
,
December
. www.economicsecurityindex.org/upload/media/ESI%20report%20final_12%2013.pdf
(accessed August 11, 2011)
.
Hill, R. P.; Hirschman, E. C.; Bauman, J. F..
1996
.
The Birth of Modern Entitlement Programs: Reports from the Field and Implications for Welfare Policy
.
Journal of Public Policy and Marketing
15
:
263
277
.
Iyengar, S.
1991
.
Is Anyone Responsible? How Television Frames Political Issues
.
Chicago
:
University of Chicago Press
.
Jacobs, L.
1993
.
The Health of Nations
.
Ithaca, NY
:
Cornell University Press
.
Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF)
.
2009
.
Kaiser Health Tracking Poll: December 2009
.
Publication No. 8035
.
Menlo Park, CA
:
KFF
.
———.
2010a
.
Kaiser Health Tracking Poll: January 2010
.
Publication No. 8042-T
.
Menlo Park, CA
:
KFF
.
———.
2010b
.
Kaiser Health Tracking Poll: May 2010
.
Publication No. 8075-T
.
Menlo Park, CA
:
KFF
.
———.
2010c
.
Kaiser Health Tracking Poll: June 2010
.
Publication No. 8082-T
.
Menlo Park, CA
:
KFF
.
———.
2010d
.
Pop Quiz: Assessing Americans' Familiarity with the Health Care Law
.
Publication No. 8148
.
Menlo Park, CA
:
KFF
.
Kessler, D.; Brady, D..
2009
.
Putting the Public's Money Where Its Mouth Is
.
Health Affairs Web exclusive
28
:
W917
W925
. http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/28/5/w917.full.html.
Kluegel, J.; Smith, E..
1986
.
Beliefs about Inequality: American Views about What Is and What Ought to Be
.
New York
:
Aldine de Gruyter
.
Kusnet, D.; Mishel, L.; Teixeira, R..
2006
.
Talking Past Each Other: What Everyday Americans Really Think (and Elites Don't Get) about the Economy
.
Washington, DC
:
Economic Policy Institute
.
Lerner, J.; Keltner, D..
2001
.
Fear, Anger and Risk
.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
81
:
146
159
.
Loewenstein, G.; Weber, E.; Hsee, C.; Welch, N..
2001
.
Risk as Feelings
.
Psychological Bulletin
127
:
267
286
.
Manski, C.
2004
.
Measuring Expectations
.
Econometrica
72
:
1329
1376
.
Mares, I.
2003
.
The Politics of Social Risk: Business and Welfare State Development
.
Cambridge, MA
:
Cambridge University Press
.
Miron-Shatz, T.
2009
.
Am I Going to Be Happy and Financially Stable? How American Women Feel When They Think about Financial Security
.
Judgment and Decision Making
4
:
102
112
.
Morone, J.
2010
.
Presidents and Health Reform: From Franklin D. Roosevelt to Barack Obama
.
Health Affairs
29
:
1096
1100
.
Mughan, A.; Lacy, D..
2002
.
Economic Performance, Job Insecurity, and Electoral Choice
.
British Journal of Political Science
32
:
513
553
.
Oberlander, J.
2010
.
Long Time Coming: Why Health Reform Finally Passed
.
Health Affairs
29
:
1112
1116
.
Orszag, P. R.; Emanuel, E. J..
2010
.
Health Care Reform and Cost Control
.
New England Journal of Medicine
,
June
16
. healthpolicyandreform.nejm.org/?p=3564.
Page, M. E.; Stevens, A. H..
2004
.
The Economic Consequences of Absent Parents
.
Journal of Human Resources
39
:
80
107
.
Ricciardi, V.
2008
.
The Financial Psychology of Worry and Women
.
Social Science Research Network (SSRN) Working Paper Series
.
July
17
.
New York
:
SSRN
. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1093351.
Rivers, L.; Arvai, J..
2007
.
Win Some, Lose Some: The Effect of Chronic Losses on Decision Making under Risk
.
Journal of Risk Research
10
:
1085
1099
.
Rodrik, D.
1998
.
Why Do More Open Economies Have Bigger Governments?
Journal of Political Economy
106
:
997
1032
.
Scheve, K.; Slaughter, M. J..
2004
.
Economic Insecurity and the Globalization of Production
.
American Journal of Political Science
48
:
662
674
.
Schlesinger, M.
2004
.
Reprivatizing the Public Household? Medical Care in the Context of American Public Values
.
Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
29
:
969
1004
.
Schlesinger, M.; Lee, T..
1993
.
Is Health Care Different? Popular Support for Federal Health and Social Policies
.
Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
18
:
551
628
.
Shapiro, R. Y.; Jacobs, L..
2010
.
Simulating Representation: Elite Mobilization and Political Power in Health Care Reform
.
Forum
8
(
1
):
1
15
. www.bepress.com/forum/vol8/iss1/art4.
Skocpol, T.
2010
.
The Political Challenges That May Undermine Health Reform
.
Health Affairs
29
:
1288
1292
.
Slovic, P.
1999
.
Trust, Emotion, Sex, Politics, and Science: Surveying the Risk-Assessment Battlefield
.
Risk Analysis
19
:
689
701
.
Sofaer, S.
2009
.
Navigating Poorly Charted Territory: Patient Dilemmas in Health Care “Nonsystems.”
Medical Care Research and Review
66
:
75S
93S
.
Sunstein, C.
2002
.
Probability Neglect: Emotions, Worst Cases and the Law
.
Yale Law Journal
112
:
61
107
.
Swenson, P. A.
2002
.
Capitalists against Markets: The Making of Labor Markets and Welfare States in the United States and Sweden
.
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Taylor-Gooby, P.; Dean, H.; Munro, M.; Parker, G..
1999
.
Risk and the Welfare State
.
British Journal of Sociology
50
:
177
179
.
Tuohy, C. J.
1999
.
Accidental Logics: The Dynamics of Change in the Health Care Arena in the United States, Britain, and Canada
.
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.