The question posed in this article is whether single-payer health care systems are more likely to provide equal treatment for equal need (horizontal equity) than are multipayer systems. To address this question, we compare access to primary and specialty health care services across selected neighborhoods, grouped by average household income, in a single-payer system (the English NHS), a multiple-payer system with universal coverage (French National Health Insurance), and the U.S. multiple-payer system characterized by large gaps in health insurance coverage. We find that Paris residents, including those with low incomes, have better access to health care than their counterparts in Inner London and Manhattan. This finding casts doubt on the notion that the number of payers influences the capacity of a health care system to provide equitable access to its residents. The lesson is to worry less about the number of payers and more about the system's ability to assure access to primary and specialty care services.

This content is only available as a PDF.
Billings, J., G. M. Anderson, L. S. Newman.
1996
. Recent Findings on Preventable Hospitalizations.
Health Affairs
15
(
3
):
239
-249.
Billings, J., L. Zeitel, J. Lukomnik, T. S. Carey, A. E. Blank, and L. Newman.
1993
. Impact of Socioeconomic Status on Hospital Use in New York City.
Health Affairs
12
(
1
):
162
-173.
Blendon, R. J., C. Schoen, C. M. DesRoches, R. Osborn, K. L. Scoles, and K. Zapert.
2002
. Inequities in Health Care: A Five-Country Survey.
Health Affairs
21
(
3
):
182
-191.
Blustein, J., K. Hanson, and S. Shea.
1998
. Preventable Hospitalizations and Socioeconomic Status.
Health Affairs
17
(
2
):
177
-189.
Bureau of Vital Statistics of the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene,
1999
-2003.
Cissé, B., S. Luchini, and J. P. Moatti.
2007
. Progressivity and Horizontal Equity in Health Care Finance and Delivery: What about Africa?
Health Policy
80
:
51
-68.
French Bureau of the Census.
1999
.
Census of the Population
.
French Ministry of Health's Hospital Reporting System: Programme pour la Médicalisation des Systèmes d'Information (PMSI)
,
1999
-2001.
Gusmano, M. K., V. G. Rodwin, and D. Weisz.
2006
. A New Way to Compare Health Systems: Avoidable Hospital Conditions in Manhattan and Paris.
Health Affairs
25
:
510
-520.
____. Forthcoming.
A New Way to Compare Health Systems: Access to Care in New York, London, and Paris
. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Gusmano, M. K., V. G. Rodwin, D. Weisz, and D. Das.
2007
. A New Approach to the Comparative Analysis of Health Systems: Invasive Treatment for Heart Disease in the U.S., France, and Their Two World Cities.
Health Economics, Policy, and Law
2
:
73
-92.
Hamnett, C.
2003
.
Unequal City: London in the Global Arena
. London: Routledge.
Hurst, J., and M. Jee-Hughes.
2001
.
Performance Measurement and Performance Management in OECD Health Systems
. Labour Market and Social Policy Occasional Papers No. 47. Paris: OECD.
Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM),
1995
-1999.
Lu, J-f. R., G. M. Leung, S. Kwon, K. Y. K. Tin, E. van Doorslaer, and O. O'Donnell.
2007
. Horizontal Equity in Health Care Utilization Evidence from Three High-Income Asian Economies.
Social Science and Medicine
64
:
199
-212.
Macinko, J., B. Starfield, and L. Shi.
2003
. The Contribution of Primary Care Systems to Health Outcomes within Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Countries, 1970-1998.
Health Services Research
38
:
831
-865.
Millman, M., ed.
1993
.
Access to Health Care in America
. Committee on Monitoring Access to Personal Health Care Services, Institute of Medicine. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
Oliver, A. J.
2008
. Unpublished manuscript.
Reflections on the Development of UK Health Inequalities Policy
. London School of Economic and Political Science.
Oster, A., and A. B. Bindman.
2003
. Emergency Department Visits for Ambulatory Care Sensitive Conditions: Insights into Preventable Hospitalizations.
Medical Care
41
:
198
-207.
Parchman, M. L., and S. Culler.
1994
. Primary Care Physicians and Avoidable Hospitalizations.
Journal of Family Practice
39
(
2
):
123
-128.
Peacock, D., N. Devlin, and R. McGee.
1999
. The Horizontal Equity of Health Care in New Zealand.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health
23
(
2
):
126
-130.
Raine, R., A. Hutchings, and N. Black.
2004
. Is Publicly Funded Health Care Really Distributed According to Need? The Example of Cardiac Rehabilitation in the UK.
Health Policy
67
:
227
-235.
Rodwin, V. G., and M. K. Gusmano, eds.
2006
.
Growing Older in World Cities: New York, London, Paris, and Tokyo
. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press.
Rodwin, V., and L. Neuberg.
2005
. Infant Mortality and Income in Four World Cities: New York, London, Paris, and Tokyo.
American Journal of Public Health
95
:
86
-90.
Roos, N. P., and C. Mustard.
1997
. Variation in Health and Health Care Use by Socioeconomic Status in Winnipeg, Canada: Does the System Work Well? Yes and No.
Milbank Quarterly
75
:
89
-111.
Schoen, C., and M. M. Doty.
2004
. Inequities in Access to Medical Care in Five Countries: Findings from the 2001 Commonwealth Fund International Health Policy Survey.
Health Policy
67
:
309
-322.
Schulz, A. J., D. R. Williams, B. A. Israel, L. B. Lempert.
2002
. Racial and Spatial Relations as Fundamental Determinants of Health in Detroit.
Milbank Quarterly
80
:
677
-705.
Starr, P.
1985
.
The Social Transformation of American Medicine
. New York: Basic Books.
Statewide Planning and Research Cooperative System (SPARCS),
1999
-2002.
Tudor Hart, J.
1971
. The Inverse Care Law.
Lancet
328
:
404
-412.
United Kingdom. Department of Health.
1999
-2003.
Hospital Episode Statistics (HES)
.
United Kingdom. Office of National Statistics.
2001
-2003.
UK Census of the Population
.
United States Census Bureau.
2000
.
United States Census
. Washington, DC: U.S. Census Bureau.
van Doorslaer, E., P. Clarke, E. Savage, and J. Hall.
2008
. Horizontal Inequities in Australia's Mixed Public/Private Health Care System.
Health Policy
86
:
97
-108.
van Doorslaer, E., X. Koolman, and F. Puffer.
2002
. Equity in the use of physician visits in OECD countries: Has equal treatment for equal need been achieved? In
Measuring Up: Improving Health Systems Performance in OECD Countries
, ed. OECD,
225
-248. Paris: OECD.
van Doorslaer, E., C. Masseria, and the OECD Health Equity Research Group Members.
2004
.
Income-related Inequality in the Use of Medical Care in Twenty-one OECD Countries
. OECD Working Paper No. 14. Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
van Doorslaer, E., and A. Wagstaff.
1992
. Equity in the Delivery of Health Care: Some International Comparisons.
Journal of Health Economics
11
:
389
-411.
van Doorslaer, E, A. Wagstaff, H. van der Burg, T. Christiansen, D. De Graeve, I. Duchesne, U.-G. Gerdtham, et al.
2000
. Equity in the Delivery of Health Care in Europe and the U.S.
Journal of Health Economics
19
:
553
-583.
Wagstaff, A., and E. van Doorslaer.
1992
. Equity in the Finance of Health Care: Some International Comparisons.
Journal of Health Economics
11
:
361
-387.
Weissman, J. S., C. Gatsonis, and A. M. Epstein.
1992
. Rates of Avoidable Hospitalization by Insurance Status in Massachusetts and Maryland.
Journal of the American Medical Association
268
:
2388
-2394.
Weisz, D., and M. K. Gusmano.
2006
. The Health of Older New Yorkers. In
Growing Older in World Cities: New York, London, Paris, and Tokyo
, ed. V. Rodwin and M. Gusmano,
58
-77. Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press.
Weisz, D., M. K. Gusmano, V. G. Rodwin, and L. Neuberg.
2007
. Population Health and the Health System: Avoidable Mortality in Three Wealthy Nations and Their World Cities.
European Journal of Public Health
18
(
2
):
166
-172.
Wennberg, J.
1987
. Population Illness Rates Do Not Explain Population Hospitalization Rates.
Medical Care
25
:
354
-359.