...Ted Gayer; E. Roy Weintraub Negotiating at the Boundary: Patinkin vs. Phipps Ted Gayer and E. Roy Weintraub Economistsand mathematiciansthemselvesdo not fully understand the way they have negotiated the more or less rigid boundary that sepa- ratestheir disciplines. Scholarsin both...

.... Baumol, an economist at Princeton, and Cecil G. Phipps, a math- ematician with a burgeoning interest in mathematical economics based at the University of Florida. Baumol recommended publication, believ- ing the proof to be “a very important paper indeed” (Referee No. 1, 1953).8 8. Weintraub...

... within a story—seven of them, in fact: of Marshall and the Cam- bridge mathematical tripos, of Volterra and his student Evans, of different attempts to appropriate Hilbert, of Debreu and the Bourbaki school, of Phipps and Patinkin, of a paper of Arrow-Debreu and Phipps, of two brothers Sidney and Hal...

... it interesting, parts even delightful. There are indeed stories within a story—seven of them, in fact: of Marshall and the Cam- bridge mathematical tripos, of Volterra and his student Evans, of different attempts to appropriate Hilbert, of Debreu and the Bourbaki school, of Phipps and Patinkin, of a paper...

... within a story—seven of them, in fact: of Marshall and the Cam- bridge mathematical tripos, of Volterra and his student Evans, of different attempts to appropriate Hilbert, of Debreu and the Bourbaki school, of Phipps and Patinkin, of a paper of Arrow-Debreu and Phipps, of two brothers Sidney and Hal...

... mathematical tripos, of Volterra and his student Evans, of different attempts to appropriate Hilbert, of Debreu and the Bourbaki school, of Phipps and Patinkin, of a paper of Arrow-Debreu and Phipps, of two brothers Sidney and Hal, of the travails of a Swarthmore graduate. The fact that one story concerned...

... and the Bourbaki school, of Phipps and Patinkin, of a paper of Arrow-Debreu and Phipps, of two brothers Sidney and Hal, of the travails of a Swarthmore graduate. The fact that one story concerned the storyteller himself, and another his father and uncle, and yet another an interview, Rushdie-style, with one...

... and the Bourbaki school, of Phipps and Patinkin, of a paper of Arrow-Debreu and Phipps, of two brothers Sidney and Hal, of the travails of a Swarthmore graduate. The fact that one story concerned the storyteller himself, and another his father and uncle, and yet another an interview, Rushdie-style, with one...

... within a story—seven of them, in fact: of Marshall and the Cam- bridge mathematical tripos, of Volterra and his student Evans, of different attempts to appropriate Hilbert, of Debreu and the Bourbaki school, of Phipps and Patinkin, of a paper of Arrow-Debreu and Phipps, of two brothers Sidney and Hal...

... tutorial in Peter Hall's The Political Power of Economic Ideas. Finally, I thank Terri Phipps for her help with processing the manuscript. Copyright © 1994 by Duke University Press 1994 References Arrow , Kenneth J. 1985 . Maine and Texas American Economic Review 75 : 320 -23...

... of Henry Simons. In The Optimum Quantity of Money and Other Essays . Chicago: Aldine. ____. 1970 . A Theoretical Framework for Monetary Analysis. Journal of Political Economy 78 . 2 :193-238. Gayer, T., and E. R. Weintraub. 2000 . Negotiating at the Boundary: Patinkin vs. Phipps. HOPE 32...

... the name Poulett Thomson in remembrance of his mother, an heiress to the ancient family of Poulett from Goathurst, Somerset. Then George, the eldest son, married the heiress Emma Phipps Scrope on 22 March 1821, discarding half his names to become simply George Poulett Scrope. And so, he later boasted...

... of race relations. This has been a great stimulus not only to passing laws, but also in changing the climate of opinion” (Rose and Rose 1951). 11. Clark and his wife, Mamie Phipps Clark, showed that segregation led to psychological damage. Using black and white dolls and asking children about...