...Rabah Benkemoune This article shows that Charles Dunoyer sought to reinterpret Sismondi's theory of crises in a manner that would render it compatible with Say's political economy. While Sismondi considered that crises of overproduction proved the dysfunctionality of an economy founded upon free...

...Martin S. Staum Department of History, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta T2N 1N4, Canada. Copyright © 1998 by Duke University Press 1998 References Adenot , René . 1907 . Les idées économiques et politiques de Charles Dunoyer . Toulouse: Marques. Allix , Edgard...

.... ———. 1826a . Du développement progressif des idées religieuses . In Constant 1980. ———. 1826b . Review of Ch. Dunoyer, L'industrie et la morale considérés dans leur rapport avec la liberté. Revue encyclopédique (February): 416 -35. ———. 1829a . De M. Dunoyer, et de quelques-uns de ses...

... economic liberalism of Charles Dunoyer.11 In his 1840 pamphlet, Réforme électorale, Pecqueur 10. In his classic work, René Rémond (1954) distinguished three political Rights in nine- teenth-century France: Bonapartism, Legitimism, and Orleanism. Orleanism flourished with the reign of King Louis...

... was equally concerned with matters of political economy; those that were had the most profound immediate effect on Charles Comte and Charles Dunoyer. The classic account of the Ideologues is FranGois Picavet, Les Zdtologues: Essai sur l’histoire des idtes et des thtories scient$ques, religieuses...

... and J.-B. Say, Charles Dunoyer and Charles Comte, whose voluntarist market economicsthe government of men must be replaced by the administration of things”-was transformed by their erstwhile associates Saint-Simon and Auguste Comte into author- itarian technocracy. Baker concludes...

... Saint-Simon, who advocated the need for a new Christianity, and fi nish by looking at sev- eral fi gures, like Frédéric Bastiat and Charles Dunoyer, who pushed French political economy back toward a more orthodox position and who saw traditional Christianity as amenable with political economy...

... Blanqui, Joseph Gamier, LCon Faucher, and above all, Charles Dunoyer and Frkdkric Bastiat.’ Compared to English liberals, these French economists were more optimistic and doctrinaire.8 Say’s interpretation of Smith was a system which was more logical, systematic, and self-contained: he...

... (Say 1824: 30). The radical French economic liberal Charles Dunoyer, for his part, summarized well the feelings toward Sismondi of many contem- porary political economists, who might be inclined to agree with certain of his observations, like the phenomenon of overproduction (Say 1820; Torrens 1819...

... and those of Saint-Simon and Auguste Comte. This is clarified by comparison with Condorcet’s second generation of disciples through Destutt de Tracy and J.-B. Say, Charles Dunoyer and Charles Comte, whose voluntarist market economicsthe government of men must be replaced by the administration...

... 5 3 NAMES Aftalion, A. Cournot, A. Proudhon, P. J. Aupetit, A. Dunoyer, C. Rossi, P. Bastiat, F. Dupont-White, C. Saint-Simon, C.-H. Blanc, L. Dupuit, J. Say...

... . 1977 . “ Pierre-Louis Roederer, Jean-Baptiste Say, and the Concept of Industrie .” History of Political Economy 9 ( 4 ): 455 – 75 . Leroux Robert . 2016 . The Foundations of Industrialism: Charles Comte, Charles Dunoyer and Liberal Thought in France . New York : Peter Lang...

... French liberals such as Bastiat and Dunoyer. Investigating that hypothesis must be left for another occasion-or for another researcher. 160 History of Political Economy I6:2 (1984) first in Innsbruck and then at Vienna . . . ; . . . or to a lot of German works written by men he never...

... 9. The problems identifi ed by Sismondi led the fi rst French liberals, especially Blanqui, Rossi, Dunoyer, and Molinari, to search for solutions (Benkemoune 2002, pt. 2; 2005a). Gen- erally, they refused the legislative solutions proposed by Sismondi. But there is no historical evidence...

... on Charles Dunoyer, Charles Cornte, Louis Say, and Joseph Gar- nier. See Hayek 1964, 115; Allix 1912,448-49; Kennedy 1978, 232, 270-71. 41. Similarly, Gonnard says (1943, 435): “The psychological point of view in political economy has never been completely abandoned, since A. Smith and Condillac...

... education, the emerging liberals certainly condemned price controls, limits on wealth, and neo-mercantilist regulation. They cleared the way for the harsher lib- eral individualism of the leading French economists of the July Monarchy, Charles Comte, Charles Dunoyer, and FrCdCric Ba~tiat Except...

... army, civil servant 1832 1 Liberal DROZ, F. X . 1773 1850 army, teacher (philos.) 1833 Chr. Pol. Ec. DUNOYER, C. 1786 1862 journalist, civil servant 1832 Liberal DUPIN...

... 36 History of Political Economy 32:1 (2000) 1861b. Du principe de propriété—le juste–l’utile. Journal des écono- mistes, 2d ser., 29:321–47, 30:28–55. 1861c. Réponse à M. Dunoyer à propos de son rapport sur l’ouvrage intit...

...). Consequently, some important and active nineteenth-century French economists such as Jean-Baptiste Say, Pellegrino Rossi, Paul Leroy-Beaulieu, Neymark, Charles Dunoyer, and Joseph Garnier, could not teach economics in the French faculties of law (www.contrepoints .org/2015/11/13/228864 entretien-avec-serge...

... acquaintance with economic theory. He attended Say’s lectures at the Conservatoire des arts et métiers and came into contact with Charles Dupin, Jean-Antoine Chaptal, Charles Dunoyer, and their views on the forces productives et commerciales of Saint-Simonian deriva- tion. In the same period, Fuoco met...