Abstract
This article reconstructs the path of the German economist Friedrich A. Lutz (1901–75) to American economics. The correspondence with his former teacher Walter Eucken, the founder of the Freiburg school, constitutes a crucial yet unexplored source for the article. Through Lutz's case, this article demonstrates the growing gulf between German and Anglo-Saxon economics during the late 1930s. In his native Germany, Lutz was trained in methodologically and institutionally focused economics, which differed fundamentally from the mathematical economics dominating Anglo-Saxon academia. He realized that an academic career in the United States would be impossible if he did not adapt to the new methods and if he did not abandon the methods of the German tradition. This gave rise to his internal Methodenstreit. After his emigration in 1938, he constantly experienced doubts and tensions because he was convinced that without considering institutions, mathematical economics could never explain the occurrence and essence of macroeconomic phenomena. Despite his stellar career at Princeton, it was only after his move to Zurich in 1953, where he taught history and theory of socioeconomics for the rest of his life, that Lutz could reconcile this internal Methodenstreit.
Friedrich A. Lutz, Walter Eucken, Friedrich A. Hayek, emigration, Freiburg school, ordoliberalism, history of macroeconomics
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Albert, Hans.
2009
. “Zur Wissenschaftslehre und Methodologie Walter Euckens
.” In Phänomenologie und die Ordnung der Wirtschaft: Edmund Husserl, Rudolf Eucken, Walter Eucken, Michel Foucault
, edited by Hans-Helmuth Gander, Nils Goldschmidt, and Uwe Dathe, 83
–102
. Würzburg
: Ergon
.American Economic Association
. 1944
. Readings in Business Cycle Theory: Selected by a Committee of the American Economic Association
. Committee chaired by Gottfried Haberler. Homewood, Ill.
: Richard D. Irwin
.American Economic Association
. 1951
. Readings in Monetary Theory: Selected by a Committee of the American Economic Association
. Committee chaired by Friedrich A. Lutz and Lloyd W. Mints. Homewood, Ill.
: Richard D. Irwin
.Barkai, Haim.
1991
. “Schmoller on Money and the Monetary Dimension of Economics
.” History of Political Economy
23
, no. 1
: 13
–39
.Benes, Michael, and Jaromir Kumhof.
2012
. “The Chicago Plan Revisited
.” IMF Working Paper 2012/202.Berman, Edward H.
1983
. The Influence of the Carnegie, Ford, and Rockefeller Foundations on American Foreign Policy: The Ideology of Philanthropy
. Albany
: SUNY Press
.Bernholz, Peter.
1989
. “Ordo-Liberals and the Control of the Money Supply
.” In German Neo-liberals and the Social Market Economy
, edited by Alan Peacock and Hans Willgerodt, 191
–215
. New York
: St. Martin's Press
.Bernholz, Peter.
2007
. “Die Nationalbank 1945–1982: Von der Devisenbann-Wirtschaft zur Geldmengensteuerung bei flexiblen Wechselkursen
.” In Die Schweizerische Nationalbank 1907–2007
, 119
–214
. Zurich
: Schweizerische Nationalbank
.Blaug, Mark. (1962)
2003
. Economic Theory in Retrospect
. Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.Blümle, Gerold, and Nils Goldschmidt.
2006
. “From Economic Stability to Social Order: The Debate about Business Cycle Theory in the 1920s and Its Relevance for the Development of Theories of Social Order by Lowe, Hayek, and Eucken
.” European Journal of the History of Economic Thought
13
, no. 4
: 543
–70
.Böhm, Franz, Walter Eucken, and Hans Grossmann-Doerth. (1936)
1989
. “The Ordo Manifesto of 1936
.” In Germany's Social Market Economy: Origins and Evolution
, edited by Alan Peacock and Hans Willgerodt, 15
–26
. London
: Palgrave Macmillan
.Boulding, Kenneth E.
1953
. “A Note on the Theory of Investment of the Firm
.” Kyklos
6
, no. 1
: 77
–82
.Brintzinger, Klaus-Rainer.
1996
. Die Nationalökonomie an den Universitäten Freiburg, Heidelberg und Tübingen, 1918–1945
. Frankfurt
: Peter Lang
.Caldwell, Bruce.
2011
. “The Chicago School, Hayek, and Neoliberalism
.” In Building Chicago Economics: New Perspectives on the History of America's Most Powerful Economics Program
, edited by Robert Van Horn, Philip Mirowski, and Thomas A. Stapleford, 301
–14
. New York
: Cambridge University Press
.Caldwell, Bruce, and Hansjörg Klausinger.
2022
. Hayek: A Life, 1899–1950
. Chicago
: University of Chicago Press
.Chandler, Lester V.
1978
. “The Department of Economics
.” In A Princeton Companion
, edited by Alexander Leitch, 149
–51
. Princeton, N.J.
: Princeton University Press
.Craver, Earlene.
1986
. “Patronage and the Directions of Research in Economics: The Rockefeller Foundation in Europe, 1924–1938
.” Minerva
24
, nos. 2–3
: 205
–22
.Cubitt, Charlotte E.
2006
. A Life of Friedrich August von Hayek
. Gamlingay
: Authors OnLine
.Dal Pont Legrand, Muriel, and Harald Hagemann.
2013
. “Lutz and Equilibrium Theories of the Business Cycle
.” Œconomia
3
, no. 2
: 241
–62
.Dathe, Uwe, and Nils Goldschmidt.
2003
. “Wie der Vater, so der Sohn: Neuere Erkenntnisse zu Walter Euckens Leben und Werk anhand des Nachlasses von Rudolf Eucken in Jena
.” ORDO–Jahrbuch für die Ordnung von Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft
54
:49
–74
.Ellis, Howard S. (1934)
1937
. German Monetary Theory, 1905–1933
. Cambridge, Mass.
: Harvard University Press
.Eucken, Walter.
1923
. Kritische Betrachtungen zum deutschen Geldproblem
. Jena
: G. Fischer
.Eucken, Walter.
1929
. “Kredit und Konjunktur
.” In Wandlungen des Kapitalismus: Auslandsanleihen, Kredit und Konjunktur. Verhandlungen des Vereins für Socialpolitik in Zürich 1928
, edited by Franz Boese, 287
–305
, 386
–91
. Munich
: Duncker & Humblot
.Eucken, Walter. (1940)
1950
. The Foundations of Economics: History and Theory in the Analysis of Economic Reality
. London
: William Hodge
.Faßbender, Siegfried.
1943
. Nationalsozialistische Wirtschaft und völkische Freiheit
. Leipzig
: Lutzeyer
.Goldschmidt, Nils.
2013
. “Walter Eucken's Place in the History of Ideas
.” Review of Austrian Economics
26
, no. 2
: 127
–47
.Goldschmidt, Nils, and Michael Wohlgemuth.
2008
. “Zur Einführung: Unsere Aufgabe (1936)
.” In Grundtexte zur Freiburger Tradition der Ordnungsökonomik
, edited by Nils Goldschmidt and Michael Wohlgemuth, 21
–25
. Tübingen
: Mohr Siebeck
.Grudev, Lachezar.
2019
. “Friedrich A. Lutz’ Epistemological and Methodological Messages during the German-Language Business Cycle Debate
.” Journal of Contextual Economics–Schmollers Jahrbuch
139
, no. 1
: 1
–28
.Grudev, Lachezar.
2020
. “Walter Eucken's Concept of Economic Order and Business Cycle Analysis
.” ORDO–Jahrbuch für die Ordnung von Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft
71
:17
–45
.Grunenberg, Antonia. (2008)
2016
. Hannah Arendt und Martin Heidegger: Geschichte einer Liebe
. Munich
: Piper
.Gusman, Rosaria G.
1984
. “Note bio-bibliographiche 1912–1976
.” In Moneta, dualismo e pianificazione nel pensiero di Vera C. Lutz
, edited by Fondazione Luigi Einaudi, 89
–110
. Bologna
: Società editrice il Mulino
.Haberler, Gottfried.
1944
. Introduction to Readings in Business Cycle Theory: Selected by a Committee of the American Economic Association
, xii
–xvi
. Committee chaired by Gottfried Haberler. Homewood, Ill.
: Richard D. Irwin
.Haberler, Gottfried.
1984
. “Vera e Friedrich Lutz: Una famosa coppia di economisti dei nostri tempi
.” In Moneta, dualismo e pianificazione nel pensiero di Vera C. Lutz
, edited by Fondazione Luigi Einaudi, 47
–53
. Bologna
: Società editrice il Mulino
.Hagemann, Harald.
1997
. Introduction to Zur deutschsprachigen wirtschaftswissenschaftlichen Emigration nach 1933
, edited by Harald Hagemann, 7
–36
. Marburg
: Metropolis
.Hagemann, Harald.
2002
. Introduction to Equilibrium and the Business Cycle
, edited by Harald Hagemann, vii
–xxvii
. Vol. 4
of Business Cycle Theory: Selected Texts, 1860–1939. London
: Pickering & Chatto
.Hagemann, Harald.
2008
. “Zur Einführung: Friedrich A. Lutz (1901–1975)
.” In Grundtexte zur Freiburger Tradition der Ordnungsökonomik
, edited by Nils Goldschmidt and Michael Wohlgemuth, 273
–78
. Tübingen
: Mohr Siebeck
.Hartwell, Ronald M.
1995
. History of the Mont Pelerin Society
. Indianapolis
: Liberty Fund
.Hayek, Friedrich A. (1941)
1950
. The Pure Theory of Capital
. Chicago
: University of Chicago Press
.Hayek, Friedrich A. (1942)
2010
. “Scientism and the Study of Society
.” In Studies on the Abuse and Decline of Reason: Text and Documents
, edited by Bruce Caldwell, 77
–166
. Vol. 13
of The Collected Works of F. A. Hayek. Chicago
: University of Chicago Press
.Hayek, Friedrich A. (1963)
1995
. “The Economics of the 1930s as Seen from London
.” In Contra Keynes and Cambridge: Essays, Correspondence
, edited by Bruce Caldwell, 49
–73
. Vol. 9
of The Collected Works of F. A. Hayek. Chicago
: University of Chicago Press
.Herrmann-Pillath, Carsten.
1994
. “Methodological Aspects of Eucken's Work
.” Journal of Economic Studies
21
, no. 4
: 46
–60
.Hicks, J. R., and R. G. D. Allen.
1934
. “A Reconsideration of the Theory of Value
.” Pt. 1. Economica
, n.s., 1
, no. 1
: 52
–76
.Hicks, John R.
1984
. “La regione e il mondo
.” In Moneta, dualismo e pianificazione nel pensiero di Vera C. Lutz
, edited by Fondazione Luigi Einaudi, 55
–62
. Bologna
: Società editrice il Mulino
.Howson, Susan.
2011
. Lionel Robbins
. Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.Janssen, Hauke.
(1998) 2012
. Nationalökonomie und Nationalsozialismus: Die deutsche Volkswirtschaftslehre in den dreißiger Jahren des 20. Jahrhunderts
. Marburg
: Metropolis
.Keynes, John Maynard.
1936
. The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money
. London
: Macmillan
.Klausinger, Hansjörg.
2013
. Introduction to pt. 1 of Business Cycles, edited by Hansjörg Klausinger, 1
–45
. Vol. 7 of The Collected Works of F. A. Hayek. Chicago
: University of Chicago Press
.Klinckowstroem, Wendula Gräfin von.
2000
. “Walter Eucken: Eine biographische Skizze
.” In Walter Eucken und sein Werk: Rückblick auf den Vordenker der sozialen Marktwirtschaft
, edited by Lüder Gerken, 53
–115
. Tübingen
: Mohr Siebeck
.Köhler, Ekkehard A., and Stefan Kolev.
2013
. “The Conjoint Quest for a Liberal Positive Program: ‘Old Chicago,’ Freiburg, and Hayek
.” In F. A. Hayek and the Modern Economy: Economic Organization and Activity
, edited by Sandra J. Peart and David M. Levy, 211
–28
. New York
: Palgrave Macmillan
.Köhler, Ekkehard A., and Daniel Nientiedt.
2017
. “The Muthesius Controversy: A Tale of Two Liberalisms
.” History of Political Economy
49
, no. 4
: 607
–30
.Kolev, Stefan.
2020
. “The Legacy of Max Weber and the Early Austrians
.” Review of Austrian Economics
33
, nos. 1–2
: 33
–54
.Kolev, Stefan.
2023
. “When Liberty Presupposes Order: F. A. Hayek's Contextual Ordoliberalism
.” Journal of the History of Economic Thought
, forthcoming.Kolev, Stefan, Nils Goldschmidt, and Jan-Otmar Hesse.
2020
. “Debating Liberalism: Walter Eucken, F. A. Hayek, and the Early History of the Mont Pèlerin Society
.” Review of Austrian Economics
33
:433
–63
.Kolev, Stefan, and Ekkehard A. Köhler.
2022
. “Transatlantic Roads to Mont Pèlerin: ‘Old Chicago’ and Freiburg in a World of Disintegrating Orders
.” History of Political Economy
54
, no. 4
: 745
–84
.Köster, Roman.
2011
. Die Wissenschaft der Außenseiter: Die Krise der Nationalökonomie in der Weimarer Republik
. Göttingen
: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht
.Lange, Oskar.
1939
. “Saving and Investment: Saving in Process Analysis
.” Quarterly Journal of Economics
53
, no. 4
: 620
–22
.Lenel, Hans O.
1976
. “Zum Gedenken an Friedrich A. Lutz
.” ORDO–Jahrbuch für die Ordnung von Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft
27
:3
–5
.Leonard, Robert.
2010
. Von Neumann, Morgenstern, and the Creation of Game Theory: From Chess to Social Science, 1900–1960
. Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.Lerner, Abba.
1939
. “Saving and Investment: Definitions, Assumptions, Objectives
.” Quarterly Journal of Economics
53
, no. 4
: 611
–19
.Löwe, Adolf.
1926
. “Wie ist Konjunkturtheorie überhaupt möglich?
” Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv
24
, no. 2
: 165
–97
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1927
. Der Kampf um den Kapitalbegriff in der neuesten Zeit: Inaugural-Dissertation an der Eberhards-Karls-Universität Tübingen
. Tübingen
: Eugen Göbel
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1932
. Das Konjunkturproblem in der Nationalökonomie
. Jena
: Gustav Fischer
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1935a
. “Goldwährung und Wirtschaftsordnung
.” Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv
41
, no. 1
: 224
–51
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1935b
. “Zur Theorie des Geldmarktes: Zugleich eine Analyse des englischen Geldmarktes bei freier Währung
.” Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv
42
, no. 2
: 216
–47
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1936
. “Über die Umlaufsgeschwindigkeit des Geldes
.” Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik
144
, no. 1
: 385
–409
.Lutz, Friedrich A. (1936)
1962
. Das Grundproblem der Geldverfassung
. In Geld und Währung: Gesammelte Abhandlungen, edited by Karl Friedrich Maier, 28
–102
. Tübingen
: J. C. B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck)
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1938
. “The Outcome of the Saving-Investment Discussion
.” Quarterly Journal of Economics
52
, no. 4
: 588
–614
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1939
. “Saving and Investment: Final Comment
.” Quarterly Journal of Economics
53
, no. 4
: 627
–31
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1940a
. “Die Grundlagen der Nationalökonomie by W. Eucken
.” American Economic Review
30
, no. 3
: 587
–88
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1940b
. “The Structure of Interest Rates
.” Quarterly Journal of Economics
55
, no. 3
: 36
–63
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1943
. “Professor Hayek's Theory of Interest Rates
.” Economica
10
, no. 40
: 302
–10
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1944
. “History and Theory in Economics
.” Economica
11
, no. 44
: 210
–14
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1945
. “The Interest Rate and Investment in a Dynamic Economy
.” American Economic Review
35
, no. 5
: 811
–30
.Lutz, Friedrich A. (1956)
1989
. “Observations on the Problem of Monopolies
.” In Germany's Social Market Economy: Origins and Evolution
, edited by Alan Peacock and Hans Willgerodt, 152
–70
. London
: Palgrave Macmillan
.Lutz, Friedrich A. (1967)
2008
. “Verstehen und Verständigung in der Wirtschaftswissenschaft
.” In Grundtexte zur Freiburger Tradition der Ordnungsökonomik
, edited by Nils Goldschmidt and Michael Wohlgemuth, 278
–98
. Tübingen
: Mohr Siebeck
.Lutz, Friedrich A.
1971
. Politische Überzeugungen und nationalökonomische Theorie: Zürcher Vorträge
. Edited by Alfred Bosch and Reinhold Veit. Tübingen
: J. C. B. Mohr (Paul Siebeck)
.Lutz, Friedrich A., and Douglas C. Hague, ed.
1961
. The Theory of Capital
. London
: Macmillan
.Lutz, Friedrich A., and Vera Lutz.
1951
. The Theory of Investment of the Firm
. Princeton, N.J.
: Princeton University Press
.Lutz, Vera C.
1962
. Italy: A Study in Economic Development
. Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.Lutz, Vera C.
1969
. Central Planning for the Market Economy: An Analysis of the French Theory and Experience
. London
: Longmans
.Masera, Rainer A.
1983
. “Inflation, Stabilization and Economic Recovery in Italy after the War: Vera Lutz's Assessment
.” Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review
144
:29
–50
.Nobel Prize–Winning Economist: Friedrich A. von Hayek
. 1983
. Los Angeles
: Regents of the University of California
.Richter, Rudolf.
2014
. “Die Geldpolitik im Spiegel der wissenschaftlichen Diskussion
.” In Fünfzig Jahre Deutsche Mark: Notenbank und Währung in Deutschland seit 1948
, edited by Deutsche Bundesbank, 561
–608
. Munich
: C. H. Beck
.Rieter, Heinz, and Matthias Schmolz.
1993
. “The Ideas of German Ordoliberalism, 1938–45: Pointing the Way to a New Economic Order
.” European Journal of the History of Economic Thought
1
, no. 1
: 87
–114
.Ritzmann, Franz.
1976
. “Professor Dr. Friedrich A. Lutz
.” In Rektoratsrede und Jahresbericht 1975/76
, 79
–81
. Zurich
: University of Zurich
.Rühl, Christof.
1994
. “The Transformation of the Business Cycle Theory: Hayek, Lucas, and a Change in the Notion of Equilibrium
.” In Money and Business Cycles: The Economics of F. A. Hayek
, edited by Marina Colonna and Harald Hagemann, 1
:168
–202
. Aldershot
: Edward Elgar
.Scherer, Frederic M.
2000
. “The Emigration of German-Speaking Economists after 1933
.” Journal of Economic Literature
38
, no. 3
: 614
–26
.Schmoller, Gustav. (
1893
) 1949. Die Volkswirtschaft, die Volkswirtschaftslehre und ihre Methoden
. Frankfurt
: Vittorio Klostermann
.Schwartz, Pedro.
1984
. “Central Bank Monopoly in the History of Economic Thought: A Century of Myopia in England
.” In Currency Competition and Monetary Union
, edited by Pascal Salin, 95
–126
. The Hague
: Martinus Nijhoff
.Silber, William.
2013
. Volcker: The Triumph of Persistence
. New York
: Bloomsbury Press
.Smith, Vera C.
1935
. “Free Banking, or A Reconsideration of the Historical and Analytical Basis of Central Banking
.” PhD diss., London School of Economics
.Smith, Vera C. (1936)
1990
. The Rationale of Central Banking and the Free Banking Alternative
. Indianapolis
: Liberty Fund
.Streissler, Erich W.
1994
. “The Influence of German and Austrian Economics on Joseph A. Schumpeter
.” In Schumpeter in the History of Ideas
, edited by Yuichi Shionoya and Mark Perlman, 13
–38
. Ann Arbor
: University of Michigan Press
.Syga-Dubois, Judith.
2019
. Wissenschaftliche Philanthropie und transatlantischer Austausch in der Zwischenkriegszeit: Die sozialwissenschaftlichen Förderprogramme der Rockefeller-Stiftungen in Deutschland
. Vienna
: Böhlau
.Toniolo, Gianni.
2005
. Central Bank Cooperation at the Bank for International Settlements, 1930–1973
. Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.Vanberg, Viktor J.
2008
. “Zur Einführung: Franz Böhm (1895–1977)
.” In Grundtexte zur Freiburger Tradition der Ordnungsökonomik
, edited by Nils Goldschmidt and Michael Wohlgemuth, 43
–48
. Tübingen
: Mohr Siebeck
.Vanberg, Viktor J.
2013
. “Hayek in Freiburg
.” In Influences, from Mises to Bartley
, edited by Robert Leeson, 93
–122
. Pt. 1 of Hayek: A Collaborative Biography. Basingstoke
: Palgrave Macmillan
.Veit-Bachmann, Verena.
2002
. “Unsere Aufgabe: Friedrich A. Lutz (1901–1975) zum hundertsten Geburtstag
.” ORDO–Jahrbuch für die Ordnung von Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft
53
:155
–67
.Veit-Bachmann, Verena.
2003
. “Friedrich A. Lutz: Leben und Werk
.” In Währungsordnung und Inflation: Zum Gedenken an Friedrich A. Lutz (1901–1975)
, edited by Viktor J. Vanberg, 9
–43
. Tübingen
: Mohr Siebeck
.Volcker, Paul, and Christine Harper.
2018
. Keeping at It: The Quest for Sound Money and Good Government
. New York
: Public Affairs
.Yeager, Leland B.
1990
. Preface to The Rationale of Central Banking and the Free Banking Alternative, by Vera C. Smith, xiii
–xxvi
. Indianapolis
: Liberty Fund
.Zelmanovitz, Leonidas.
2019
. “Vera Smith: The Contrarian View
.” Library of Economics and Liberty
. https://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2019/ZelmanovitzSmithV.html.Copyright 2023 by Duke University Press
2023
Issue Section:
Articles
