This article examines two overlapping controversies at the Institute of Contemporary Art in Boston, Massachusetts, in the early 1990s over the attempted censorship of both Robert Mapplethorpe’s show The Perfect Moment and Elia Sulieman’s Palestinian film and video art exhibition Uprising. By analyzing the print news discourse on these controversies, namely, regarding the representations of children in The Perfect Moment and in two of the Uprising films (Children of Fire by Mai Masri and Intifada: Introduction to the End of an Argument by Suleiman and Jayce Salloum), the author articulates how Palestinian cultural politics were constructed as “politically queer” during the 1990s culture wars, which thereby contributed to the rise of homonormativity, increased visibility of leftist LGBTQ-Palestinian solidarity politics, and the development of Israeli pinkwashing as a political strategy. Through this analysis, the article advances a theory of “compulsory Zionism” as a concept through which to analyze the confluence of racial, ethnic, and sexual politics that haunt and animate Palestine solidarity politics in the United States.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Alsultany, Evelyn.
2011
. “Arab Jews, Diasporas, and Multicultural Feminism: An Interview with Ella Shohat
”. In Arab and Arab American Feminisms: Gender, Violence, and Belonging
, edited by Abdulhadi, Rabab; Alsultany, Evelyn; Nabier, Nadine, 46
–59
. Syracuse, NY
: Syracuse University Press
.Alsultany, Evelyn.
2012
. Arabs and Muslims in the Media: Race and Representation after 9/11
. New York
: New York University Press
.Arens, R.
1983
. “Israel’s Responsibility in Lebanon
”. Journal of Palestine Studies
13
, no. 1
: 102
–8
.Bajko, Matthew S.
2010
. “LGBT Israeli Festival Draws Protests
.” Bay Area Reporter
, April
15
.Brookman, Philip; Singer, Debra.
1992
. “Chronology
”. In Culture Wars: Documents from the Recent Controversies in the Arts
, edited by Bolton, Richard, 331
–63
. New York
: New Press
.Cheng, Jih-Fei.
2016
. “How to Survive: AIDS and Its Afterlives in Popular Culture
.” Women’s Studies Quarterly
44
, nos. 1–2
: 73
–92
.Chetrit, S. S.
2009
. Intra-Jewish Conflict in Israel: White Jews, Black Jews
. New York
: Routledge
.Cohen, Cathy J.
1997
. “Punks, Bulldaggers, and Welfare Queens: The Radical Potential of Queer Politics?
” GLQ
3
, no. 4
: 437
–65
.Denning, Michael.
1992
. “The Academic Left and the Rise of Cultural Studies
”. Radical History Review
54
: 21
–47
.Downing, John D. H.
2000
. Radical Media: Rebellious Communication and Social Movements
. Thousand Oaks, CA
: Sage
.Duggan, Lisa.
2003
. The Twilight of Equality? Neoliberalism, Cultural Politics, and Attacks on Democracy
. Boston
: Beacon
.Epstein, Steven.
1997
. “Specificities: AIDS Activism and the Retreat from the ‘Genocide’ Frame
”. Social Identities
3
, no. 3
: 415
–38
.Gilbert, Matthew.
1991a
. “Israeli Filmmakers View Palestinians with Sympathetic Eye
.” Boston Globe
, June
13
. search.proquest.com/docview/294609260
.Gilbert, Matthew.
1991b
. “Poignant Views at the ICA
.” Boston Globe
, May
. .Hall, Stuart.
1997
. Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices
. London
: Sage
.Hartigan, Patti.
1990a
. “Artists Criticize ICA Restriction: Third Edition
.” Boston Globe
, July
11
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1990b
. “Mapplethorpe Show to Open Amid Controversy ICA Founder Raps Selections
.” Boston Globe
, August
1
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1991a
. “Censorship Is Again the Cry in ICA Flap
.” Boston Globe
, April
26
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1991b
. “Curator Withdraws from ICA Series
.” Boston Globe
, June
12
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1991c
. “Grossman Quits ICA Board over Palestinian Films
”. Boston Globe
, April
24
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1991d
. “ICA Announces That Film Series Will Go On
”. Boston Globe
, June
13
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1991e
. “Palestinian Film Series Withdrawn from ICA
”. Boston Globe
, May
2
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1991f
. “Panel to Join Palestinian Series at ICA
”. Boston Globe
, April
25
. .Hartigan, Patti.
1991g
. “Remaining Film Pulled from ICA Series
”. Boston Globe
, May
3
. .Hobson, Emily K.
2016
. Lavender and Red: Liberation and Solidarity in the Gay and Lesbian Left
. Oakland
: University of California Press
.Hochberg, Gil.
2010
. “Introduction: Israelis, Palestinians, Queers: Points of Departure
”. GLQ
16
, no. 4
: 493
–516
.Hochberg, Gil.
2015
. Visual Occupations: Violence and Visibility in a Conflict Zone
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
.Jackman, Michael; Upadhyay, Nishant.
2014
. “Pinkwatching Israel, Whitewashing Canada: Queer (Settler) Politics and Indigenous Colonization in Canada
.” Women’s Studies Quarterly
42
, nos. 3–4
: 195
–210
.Jankovic, Coleen.
2013
. “ ‘You Can’t Film Here’: Queer Political Fantasy and Thin Critique of Israeli Occupation in the Bubble
”. Canadian Journal of Film Studies
22
, no. 2
: 97
–119
.Juhasz, Alexandra.
1995
. AIDS TV: Identity, Community, and Alternative Video
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
.LeTigre, Tony K.
2011
. “Protesters Call out Frameline over Israeli Sponsorship
”. Bay Area Reporter
, June
23
.Lowe, Lisa.
1996
. Immigrant Acts: On Asian American Cultural Politics
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
.Mbembé, Achille; Meintjes, Libby.
2003
. “Necropolitics
”. Public Culture
15
, no. 1
: 11
–40
.McAlister, Melani.
2005
. Epic Encounters: Culture, Media, and U.S. Interests in the Middle East since 1945
. 2nd ed. Berkeley
: University of California Press
.Melamed, Jodi.
2006
. “The Spirit of Neoliberalism: From Racial Liberalism to Neoliberal Multiculturalism
”. Social Text
, no. 89
: 1
–24
.Melamed, Jodi.
2011
. “Reading Tehran in Lolita: Making Racialized and Gendered Difference Work for Neoliberal Multiculturalism
.” In Strange Affinities: The Gender and Sexual Politics of Comparative Racialization
, edited by Hong, Grace Kyungwon; Ferguson, Roderick A., 76
–109
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
.Mercer, K.
1997
. “Just Looking for Trouble: Robert Mapplethorpe and Fantasies of Race
”. Cultural Politics
11
: 240
–54
.Mercer, K.; Julien, I..
1994
. “True Confessions
”. In Black Male: Representations of Masculinity in Contemporary American Art
, edited by Golden, Thelma, 191
–200
. New York
: Whitney Museum of American Art/Harry N.Abrams Inc.
Naber, Nadine; Desouky, Eman; Baroudi, Lina.
2006
. “The Forgotten -‘ism’: An Arab US Women’s Perspective on Zionism, Racism, and Sexism
”. In Color of Violence: The Incite! Anthology
, edited by Incite! Women of Color Against Violence
, 97
–112
. Cambridge, MA
: South End
.Pally, Marcia.
1993
. “Cincinnati: City under Siege
”. In War of Words: The Censorship Debate
, edited by Beahm, G. W., 123
–31
. Kansas City, MO
: Andrews McMeel
.Parachini, Allan.
1989
. “NEA Faces New Controversy in New York Show Art: National Endowment Seeks Voluntary Return of $10,000 to Quiet Criticism
”. Los Angeles Times
, November
6
. .Peterson, Luke Matthew.
2015
. Israel-Palestine in the News Media: Contending Discourses
. New York
: Routledge
.Puar, Jasbir K.
2007
. Terrorist Assemblages: Homonationalism in Queer Times
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
.Puar, Jasbir K.
2011
. “Citation and Censorship: The Politics of Talking about the Sexual Politics of Israel
”. Feminist Legal Studies
, no. 2
: 133
–42
.Reddy, Chandan.
2011
. Freedom with Violence: Race, Sexuality, and the US State
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
.Rich, Adrienne.
1980
. “Compulsory Heterosexuality and Lesbian Existence
”. Signs
5
: 631
–60
.Said, Edward.
1984
. “Permission to Narrate
”. Journal of Palestine Studies
13
, no. 3
: 27
–48
. .Salloum, Jayce; dirs.
Suleiman, Elia.
1990
. Introduction to the End of an Argument/Intifada: Speaking for Oneself … Speaking for Others
. Seattle
: Arab Film Distribution
. .Sayigh, R.; Peteet, J..
1986
. “Between Two Fires: Palestinian Women in Lebanon
”. In Caught Up in Conflict: Women’s Responses to Political Strife
, edited by Ridd, R.; Callaway, H., 106
–37
. London
: Palgrave
.Schulman, Sarah.
2011
. “Israel and ‘Pinkwashing’
.” New York Times
, November
23
. .Schulman, Sarah.
2012
. Israel/Palestine and the Queer International
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
.Shadmi, Erella.
1992
. “Women, Palestinians, Zionism: A Personal View
.” News from Within
. (October–November
): 13
–16
.Shaheen, Jack G.
2001
. Reel Bad Arabs: How Hollywood Vilifies a People
. New York
: Olive Branch
.Shohat, Ella.
1988
. “Sephardim in Israel: Zionism from the Standpoint of Its Jewish Victims
.” Social Text
, nos. 19–20
: 1
–35
.Shohat, Ella.
1989
. Israeli Cinema: East/West and the Politics of Representation
. Austin
: University of Texas Press
.Shohat, Ella.
1995
. “Framing Post-Third Worldist Culture: Gender, Nation, and Diaspora in Middle Eastern/North African Film/Video
.” Middle Eastern Identities in Transition
, edited by Friedlander, Jonathan, 65
–108
. Los Angeles
: UCLA Center for Near Eastern Studies
.Shohat, Ella.
2017
. On the Arab-Jew, Palestine, and Other Displacements
. London
: Pluto
.Shohat, Ella; Stam, Robert.
1994
. Unthinking Eurocentrism: Multiculturalism and the Media
. New York
: Routledge
.Stockton, Robert.
1994
. “Ethnic Archetypes and the Arab Image
”. In The Development of Arab-US Identity
, edited by McCarus, Ernest, 119
–54
. Ann Arbor
: University of Michigan Press
.Suleiman, Michael W.
1984
. “Development of Public Opinion on the Palestine Question
”. Journal of Palestine Studies
13
, no. 3
: 87
–116
.Tamari, Salim.
2014
. “A Farcical Moment? Nabulsi Exceptionalism and the 1908 Ottoman Revolution
”. Jerusalem Quarterly
60
: 92
.Telegram and Gazette
. 1991
. “Museum Accused of Censorship: ALL Edition
”. Telegram and Gazette
, May
3
. .Tompkins, Kyla Wazana.
2011
. “History’s Traces: Personal Narrative, Diaspora, and Arab Jewish Experience
”. In Arab and Arab American Feminisms: Gender, Violence, and Belonging
, edited by Abdulhadi, Rabab; Alsultany, Evelyn; Naber, Nadine, 124
–36
. Syracuse, NY
: Syracuse University Press
.Willford, Catherine.
1991
. “After Boston Censorship Attempts, Palestinian Film Series Rescheduled
”. Washington Report on Middle East Affairs
10
, no. 4
: 72
.Ziv, Amalia.
2010
. “Performative Politics in Israeli Queer Anti-Occupation Activism
”. GLQ
16
, no. 4
: 537
–56
.Copyright © 2020 Duke University Press
2020
