Reviewing a Bancroft Prize–winning book presents a challenge: what else is there to say about a work recognized as one of the year’s best in American history? Moreover, Saltwater Frontier is not a typical piece of academic scholarship. It combines synthesis with careful analysis of published, translated, and unpublished Dutch and English works and of archaeological and environmental surveys. Lipman strives for a different kind of history writing here, a “narrative” that is “concise and provocative rather than magisterial or definitive” (14). This choice reflects the author’s desire to write for a broader public, another rare quality. Satisfying an audience that includes scholars, indigenous communities, and lay readers is a difficult task, but this well-written and engaging book succeeds because Lipman offers a set of bold new premises about where and under what terms intercultural exchange took place.

Lipman’s major contribution is...

Article PDF first page preview

Article PDF first page preview
You do not currently have access to this content.