Abstract
A number of the issues raised by Godwin in his Enquiry Concerning Political Justice recur in subdued form in Of Population. These are issues that Malthus himself considered only to interpret them differently. Most outstanding of the points of difference between the two were: (1) the augmentability of the food supply, which Malthus put far below Godwin’s estimate; (2) the rate of growth of population which Godwin believed to be negligible and Malthus to be potentially great; (3) man’s disposition to control his numbers when necessary, regarding which Godwin was much more optimistic than Malthus; (4) the interpretation each put upon the constraining role of institutions. The two men had more in common than is usually assumed.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Bonar, James (
1924
). Malthus and His Work
. Second EditionLondon
: George Allen and Unwin
.Boulding, K. (
1955
). The Malthusian model as a general system
. Social and Economic Studies
, 4
, 195
–205
.Clark, Colin (
1951
). The Conditions of Economic Progress
. Second EditionLondon
: Macmillan
.Deane, P., & Cole, W. A. (
1962
). British Economic Growth, 1699–1959
. Cambridge
: University Press
.Drake, M. (
1969
). Population and Society in Norway, 1735–1865
. Cambridge
: University Press
.Fetter, F. W. (
1953
). The authorship of articles in the Edinburgh Review, 1802–47
. Journal of Political Economy
, 61
, 232
–59
10.1086/257374.Godwin, William (
1946
). Enquiry Concerning Political Justice and Its Influence on Morals and Happiness (1793, 1798). Three volume variorum edition, with introduction and notes by F. E. L. Priestley
. Toronto
: University of Toronto Press
.Godwin, William (
1964
). Of Population. An Enquiry Concerning the Power of Increase in the Numbers of Mankind (1820). Reprint of original
. New York
: Augustus M. Kelley
.Howlett, John (
1781
). An Examination of Dr. Price’s Essay on the Population of England and Wales
. London
: T. Payne and Son
.Huzel, J. P. (
1969
). Malthus, the poor law, and population
. Economic History Review
, 22
, 430
–52
10.1111/j.1468-0289.1969.tb00182.x.Lloyd, P. J. (
1969
). Elementary geometric/arithmetic series and early production theory
. Journal of Political Economy
, 77
, 21
–34
10.1086/259491.Lotka, A. J. (
1927
). The size of American families in the eighteenth century
. Journal of the American Statistical Association
, 22
, 154
–70
10.2307/2276769.Malthus, T. R. (
1798
). An Essay on the Principle of Population as it Affects the Future Improvement of Society with Remarks on the Speculations of Mr. Godwin, M. Condorcet, and other Writers
. London
: Macmillan
.Malthus, T. R. (
1890
). G. T. BettanyAn Essay on the Principle of Population or a View of its Past and Present Effects on Human Happiness
. Sixth EditionLondon
: Ward, Lock, and Co.
.Malthus, T. R. (
1830
). A Summary View of the Principle of Population
. London
: John Murray
.Malthus, T. R. (
1936
). The Principles of Political Economy
. Second EditionLondon
: London School of Economics and Political Science
.Malthus, T. R. (
1966
). Patricia JamesThe Travel Diaries of Thomas Robert Malthus
. Cambridge
: University Press
.Mill, J. S. (
1921
). W. J. AshleyPrinciples of Political Economy
. New York
: Longmans, Green and Company
.Ogilvie, William (
1782
). An Essay on the Right of Property in Land
. London
: J. Walter
.Spengler, Joseph J. (
1942
). French Predecessors of Malthus
. Durham
: Duke University Press
.Spengler, Joseph J. (
1945
). Malthus’s total population theory: A restatement and reappraisal
. Canadian Journal of Economics
, 11
, 83
–110
.Spengler, Joseph J. (
1957
). Malthus the Malthusian vs. Malthus the economist
. Southern Economic Journal
, 24
, 1
–11
10.2307/1053640.Spengler, Joseph J. (
1965
). Today’s circumstances and yesterday’s theories: Malthus on services
. Kyklos
, 18
, 601
–13
10.1111/j.1467-6435.1965.tb00991.x.Spengler, Joseph J. (
1966
). Was Malthus right?
. Southern Economic Journal
, 33
, 17
–34
10.2307/1055986.Spengler, Joseph J. 1971. Smith on population. Population Studies, forthcoming.
Taeuber, Conrad, & Taeuber, Irene B. (
1958
). The Changing Population of the United States
. New York
: Wiley
.Taylor, J. S. (
1969
). The mythology of the poor law
. Journal of Economic History
, 29
, 292
–97
.Wallace, Robert. 1761. Various Prospects of Mankind, Nature and Providence. London.
Wrigley, E. A. (
1962
). The supply of raw materials in the industrial revolution
. Economic History Review
, 15
, 1
–16
10.1111/j.1468-0289.1962.tb02224.x.© Population Association of America 1971
1971
