Abstract
Several studies have shown that a wife’s strong (socio)economic position is associated with an increase in the risk of divorce. Less is known about such effects for cohabiting relationships. Using a unique and large-scale sample of administrative records from The Netherlands, we analyze the link between couples’ income dynamics and union dissolution for married and cohabiting unions over a 10-year period. We find negative effects of household income on separation and positive effects of the woman’s relative income, in line with earlier studies. The shape of the effect of the woman’s relative income, however, depends on the type of union. Movements away from income equality toward a maledominant pattern tend to increase the dissolution risk for cohabiting couples, whereas they reduce the dissolution risk for married couples. Movements away from income equality toward a female-dominant pattern (reverse specialization) increase the dissolution risks for both marriage and cohabitation. The findings suggest that equality is more protective for cohabitation, whereas specialization is more protective for marriage, although only when it fits a traditional pattern. Finally, we find that the stabilizing effects of income equality are more pronounced early in the marriage and that income equality also reduces the dissolution risk for same-sex couples.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Becker, G.S. (
1981
). A Treatise on the Family
. Cambridge, MA
: Harvard University Press
.Becker, G.S., Landes, E.M., & Michael, R.T. (
1977
). An Economic Analysis of Marital Instability
. Journal of Political Economy
, 85
, 1141
–87
. 10.1086/260631Blossfeld, H.P., & Muller, R. (
2002
). Union Disruption in Comparative Perspective: The Role of Assortative Partner Choice and Careers of Couples
. International Sociology
, 32
, 3
–35
.Blumstein, P., & Schwartz, P. (
1983
). American Couples: Money, Work, Sex
. New York
: William Morrow
.Bracher, M., Santow, G., Morgan, S.P., & Trussel, J. (
1993
). Marriage Dissolution in Australia: Models and Explanations
. Population Studies
, 47
, 403
–25
. 10.1080/0032472031000147216Brines, J., & Joyner, K. (
1999
). The Ties That Bind: Principles of Cohesion in Cohabitation and Marriage
. American Sociological Review
, 64
, 333
–55
. 10.2307/2657490Brüderl, J., Diekmann, A., & Engelhardt, H. (
1997
). Erhöht eine Probeehe das Scheidingsrisiko? Eine empirische Untersuchung mit dem Familiensurvey
. Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie
, 49
, 205
–22
.Brüderl, J., & Kalter, F. (
2001
). The Dissolution of Marriages: The Role of Information and Marital-Specific Capital
. Journal of Mathematical Sociology
, 25
, 403
–21
. 10.1080/0022250X.2001.9990262Cherlin, A.J. (
1979
). Work Life and Marital Dissolution
. In G. Levinger, & O.C. Moles (Eds.), Divorce and Separation: Context, Causes and Consequences
(pp. 151
–66
). New York
: Basic Books
.Cherlin, A.J. (
1992
). Marriage, Divorce, Remarriage
. Cambridge, MA
: Harvard University Press
.Ciano-Boyce, C., & Shelley-Sireci, L. (
2002
). Who Is Mommy Tonight? Lesbian Parenting Issues
. Journal of Homosexuality
, 43
(2
), 1
–13
. 10.1300/J082v43n02_01Clarkberg, M., Stolzenberg, R.M., & Waite, L.J. (
1995
). Attitudes, Values, and Entrance Into Cohabitational Versus Marital Unions
. Social Forces
, 74
, 609
–32
. 10.2307/2580494De Rose, A. (
1992
). Socioeconomic Factors and Family Size as Determinants of Marital Dissolution in Italy
. European Sociological Review
, 8
, 71
–91
.Hall, D.R., & Zhao, J.Z. (
1995
). Cohabitation and Divorce in Canada: Testing the Selectivity Hypothesis
. Journal of Marriage and the Family
, 57
, 421
–27
. 10.2307/353695Heckert, D.A., Nowak, T.C., & Snyder, K.A. (
1998
). The Impact of Husbands’ and Wives’ Relative Earnings on Marital Disruption
. Journal of Marriage and Family
, 60
, 690
–703
. 10.2307/353538Jalovaara, M. (
2003
). The Joint Effects of Marriage Partners’ Socioeconomic Positions on the Risk of Divorce
. Demography
, 40
, 67
–81
. 10.1353/dem.2003.0004Kalmijn, M., De Graaf, P.M., & Poortman, A.R. (
2004
). Interactions Between Cultural and Economic Determinants of Divorce in The Netherlands
. Journal of Marriage and Family
, 66
, 75
–89
. 10.1111/j.1741-3737.2004.00006.xKiernan, K. (
2002
). Cohabitation in Western Europe: Trends, Issues, and Implications
. In A. Booth, & A.C. Crouter (Eds.), Just Living Together: Implications of Cohabitation on Families, Children, and Social Policy
(pp. 3
–32
). University Park
: The Pennsylvania State University
.Latten, J.J., & Cuyvers, P.F. (
1994
). Relatie en gezinsvorming in de jaren negentig
. Voorburg/Heerlen
: CBS
.Lesthaeghe, R., & Surkuyn, J. (
1988
). Cultural Dynamics and Economic Theories of Fertility Change
. Population and Development Review
, 14
, 1
–45
. 10.2307/1972499Liefbroer, A. 1991a. “Kiezen tussen ongehuwd samenwonen en trouwen” [Choosing between marriage and cohabitation]. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Vrije Universiteit.
Liefbroer, A. (
1991
). The Choice Between a Married and Unmarried First Union for Young Adults: A Competing Risk Analysis
. European Journal of Population
, 7
, 273
–98
. 10.1007/BF01796842Liefbroer, A.C., & Dykstra, P.A. (
2000
). Levenslopen in verandering: Een studie naar ontwikkelingen in de levenslopen van Nederlanders geboren tussen 1900 en 1970
. Den Haag
: Wetenschappelijke Raad voor het Regeringsbeleid
.Liu, G., & Vikat, A. (
2004
). Does Divorce Risk Depend on Spouses’ Relative Income? A Register-Based Study of First Marriages in Sweden in 1981-1998
. Rostock, Germany
: Max-Planck Institute for Demographic Research
.Manting, D. (
1994
). Dynamics in Marriage and Cohabitation: An Inter-temporal, Life Course Analysis of First Union Formation and Dissolution
. Amsterdam
: Thesis Publishers
.Manting, D. (
1994
). Meer scheidingen dan echtscheidingen
. Maandstatistiek van de Bevolking
, 42
, 6
–8
.Manting, D., & Loeve, J.A. (
2004
). Economic Circumstances and Union Dissolution of Couples in the 1990s in The Netherlands
. Voorburg/Heerlen
: Statistics Netherlands
.McManus, P.A., & DiPrete, T.A. (
2001
). Losers and Winners: The Financial Consequences of Divorce for Men
. American Sociological Review
, 66
, 246
–68
. 10.2307/2657417Morgan, S.P., & Rindfuss, R.R. (
1985
). Marital Disruption: Structural and Temporal Dimensions
. American Journal of Sociology
, 90
, 1055
–77
. 10.1086/228176Nock, S.L. (
1995
). Commitment and Dependency in Marriage
. Journal of Marriage and the Family
, 57
, 503
–14
. 10.2307/353702Ono, H. (
1998
). Husband’s and Wife’s Resources and Marital Dissolution
. Journal of Marriage and the Family
, 60
, 674
–89
. 10.2307/353537Oppenheimer, V.K. (
1997
). Women’s Employment and the Gain to Marriage: The Specialization and Trading Model of Marriage
. Annual Review of Sociology
, 23
, 431
–53
. 10.1146/annurev.soc.23.1.431Oppenheimer, V.K. (
2003
). Cohabiting and Marriage During Young Men’s Career-Development Process
. Demography
, 40
, 127
–49
.Poortman, A.R., & Kalmijn, M. (
2002
). Women’s Labour Market Position and Divorce in The Netherlands: Evaluating Economic Interpretations of the Work Effect
. European Journal of Population
, 18
, 175
–202
.Raftery, A.E. (
1996
). Bayesian Model Selection in Social Research
. In P.V. Marsden (Ed.), Sociological Methodology
(pp. 111
–63
). Oxford
: Basil Blackwell
.Rindfuss, R.R., & Van den Heuvel, A. (
1990
). Cohabitation: A Precursor to Marriage or an Alternative to Being Single?
. Population and Development Review
, 16
, 703
–26
. 10.2307/1972963Rogers, S.J. (
2004
). Dollars, Dependency, and Divorce: Four Perspectives on the Role of Wives’ Income
. Journal of Marriage and Family
, 66
, 59
–74
. 10.1111/j.1741-3737.2004.00005.xRoss, H.L., & Sawhill, I.V. (
1975
). Time of Transition: The Growth of Families Headed by Women
. Washington, DC
: The Urban Institute
.Sayer, L.C., & Bianchi, S.M. (
2000
). Women’s Economic Independence and the Probability of Divorce
. Journal of Family Issues
, 21
, 906
–43
. 10.1177/019251300021007005Schoen, R., Astone, N.M., Rothert, K., Standish, N., & Kim, Y.J. (
2002
). Women’s Employment, Marital Happiness, and Divorce
. Social Forces
, 81
, 643
–62
. 10.1353/sof.2003.0019Schor, J. (
1991
). The Overworked American: The Unexpected Decline of Leisure
. New York
: Basic Books
.Simmons, T., & O’Connell, M. (
2003
). Married-Couple and Unmarried-Partner Households 2000
. Washington, DC
: U.S. Census Bureau
.Simpson, I.H., & England, P. (
1981
). Conjugal Work Roles and Marital Solidarity
. Journal of Family Issues
, 34
, 331
–41
.Smock, P.J. (
2000
). Cohabitation in the United States: An Appraisal of Research Themes, Findings, and Implications
. Annual Review of Sociology
, 26
, 1
–20
. 10.1146/annurev.soc.26.1.1Smock, P.J., & Gupta, S. (
2002
). Cohabitation in Contemporary North America
. In A. Booth, & A.C. Crouter (Eds.), Just Living Together: Implications of Cohabitation on Families, Children, and Social Policy
(pp. 53
–84
). College Station, PA
: The Pennsylvania State University
.Solomon, S.E., Rothblum, E.D., & Balsam, K.F. (
2005
). Money, Housework, Sex, and Con ict: Same-Sex Couples in Civil Unions, Those Not in Civil Unions, and Heterosexual Married Siblings
. Sex Roles
, 52
, 561
–75
. 10.1007/s11199-005-3725-7South, S.J. (
2001
). Time-Dependent Effects of Wives’ Employment on Marital Dissolution
. American Sociological Review
, 66
, 226
–45
. 10.2307/2657416South, S.J., & Spitze, G. (
1986
). Determinants of Divorce Over the Marital Life Course
. American Sociological Review
, 51
, 583
–90
. 10.2307/2095590Thomson, E., & Colella, U. (
1992
). Cohabitation and Marital Stability: Quality or Commitment?
. Journal of Marriage and the Family
, 54
, 259
–67
. 10.2307/353057Thornton, A., Axinn, W.G., & Hill, D.H. (
1992
). Reciprocal Effects of Religiosity, Cohabitation, and Marriage
. American Journal of Sociology
, 98
, 628
–51
. 10.1086/230051Von Gostomski, B.C., Hartmann, J., & Kopp, J. (
1998
). Soziostrukturelle Bestimmungsgründe der Ehescheidung: Eine empirische Uberprufung einiger Hypothesen der Familienforschung
. Zeitschrift für Sozialisationsforschung und Erziehungssoziologie
, 18
, 117
–33
.Voydanoff, P. (
1990
). Economic Distress and Family Relations: A Review of the Eighties
. Journal of Marriage and the Family
, 52
, 1099
–115
. 10.2307/353321Wagner, M. (
1993
). Sociale Bedingungen des Ehescheidungsrisikos aus der Perspektive des Lebensverlaufs
. In A. Diekmann, & S. Weick (Eds.), Der Familienzyklus als sozialer Prozeß
(pp. 372
–93
). Berlijn
: Duncker and Humblot
.© Population Association of America 2007
2007
Issue Section:
Articles
