Abstract
The goal of the 1996 Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act was to end needy parents’ dependence on governmental benefits, in part by promoting marriage. The prereform welfare system was widely believed to discourage marriage because it provided benefits primarily to single mothers. However, welfare reform may have actually decreased the incentives to be married by giving women greater financial independence via the program’s new emphasis on work. This article uses vital statistics data on marriages and divorces during 1989–2000 to examine the role of welfare reform (state waivers and implementation of Temporary Assistance to Needy Families) and other state-level variables on flows into and out of marriage. The results indicate that welfare reform has led to fewer new divorces and fewer new marriages, although the latter result is sensitive to specification and the choice of data.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Becker, G.S. (
1973
). A Theory of Marriage: Part I
. Journal of Political Economy
, 81
, 813
–46
. 10.1086/260084Becker, G.S., Landes, E.M., & Michael, R.T. (
1977
). An Economic Analysis of Marital Instability
. Journal of Political Economy
, 85
, 1141
–87
. 10.1086/260631Bennett, N.G., Bloom, D.E., & Craig, P.H. (
1989
). The Divergence of Black and White Marriage Patterns
. American Journal of Sociology
, 95
, 692
–722
. 10.1086/229330Bitler, M.P., Gelbach, J.B., & Hoynes, H.W. (
2002
). The Impact of Welfare Reform on Living Arrangements
. Cambridge, MA
: National Bureau of Economic Research
.Bitler, M.P. (
2003
). Some Evidence on Race, Welfare Reform, and Household Income
. American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings
, 93
, 293
–98
. 10.1257/000282803321947227Blank, R.M. (
2001
). Declining Caseloads/Increased Work: What Can We Conclude About the Effects of Welfare Reform?
. Economic Policy Review
, 7
(2
), 25
–36
.Blank, R.M. (
2002
). Evaluating Welfare Reform in the U.S
. Journal of Economic Literature
, 40
, 1105
–66
. 10.1257/002205102762203576Blank, R.M., & Schmidt, L. (
2001
). Work, Wages and Welfare
. In Blank, R.M., & Haskins, R. (Eds.), The New World of Welfare
(pp. 70
–96
). Washington, DC
: Brookings Institution
.Blau, F.D., Kahn, L.M., & Waldfogel, J. (
2000
). Understanding Young Women’s Marriage Decisions: The Role of Labor and Marriage Market Conditions
. Industrial and Labor Relations Review
, 53
, 624
–47
. 10.2307/2696140Brien, M.J. (
1997
). Racial Differences in Marriage and the Role of Marriage Markets
. Journal of Human Resources
, 32
, 741
–78
. 10.2307/146427Brien, M.J., Lillard, L.A., & Waite, L.J. (
1999
). Interrelated Family-Building Behaviors: Cohabitation, Marriage, and Nonmarital Conception
. Demography
, 36
, 535
–51
. 10.2307/2648089Clarkberg, M., Stolzenberg, R.M., & Waite, L.J. (
1995
). Attitudes, Values, and Entrance Into Cohabitational Versus Marital Unions
. Social Forces
, 74
, 609
–34
. 10.2307/2580494Corcoran, M., Danziger, S.K., Kahil, A., & Seefeldt, K.S. (
2000
). How Welfare Reform Is Affecting Women’s Work
. Annual Review of Sociology
, 26
, 241
–69
. 10.1146/annurev.soc.26.1.241Duncan, G.J., & Chase-Lansdale, P.L. (
2001
). Work, Wages and Welfare
. In Blank, R.M., & Haskins, R. (Eds.), The New World of Welfare
(pp. 391
–420
). Washington, DC
: Brookings Institution
.Ellwood, D.T. (
2000
). The Impact of the Earned Income Tax Credit and Social Policy Reforms on Work, Marriage, and Living Arrangements
. National Tax Journal
, 53
, 1063
–105
.Ellwood, D.T. (
1985
). The Impact of AFDC on Family Structure and Living Arrangements
. In Bane, M.J., & Ehrenberg, R.G. (Eds.), Research in Labor Economics
(pp. 137
–207
). Greenwich, CT
: JAI Press
.Ellwood, D.T., & Jencks, C. (
2001
). The Growing Differences in Family Structure: What Do We Know? Where Do We Look for Answers?
. Cambridge, MA
: John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University
.Fitzgerald, J.M., & Ribar, D.C. (
2004
). Welfare Reform and Female Headship
. Demography
, 41
, 189
–212
. 10.1353/dem.2004.0014Fraker, T.M., Ross, C.M., Stapulonis, R.A., Olsen, R.B., Kovac, M.D., Dion, M.R., & Rangarajan, A. (
2002
). The Evaluation of Welfare Reform in Iowa
. Princeton, NJ
: Mathematica Policy Research
.Goldscheider, F.K., & Waite, L.J. (
1986
). Sex Differences in the Entry Into Marriage
. American Journal of Sociology
, 92
, 91
–109
. 10.1086/228464Goldstein, J.R. (
1999
). The Leveling of Divorce in the United States
. Demography
, 36
, 409
–14
. 10.2307/2648063Grogger, J., & Bronars, S.G. (
2001
). The Effect of Welfare Payments on the Marriage and Fertility Behavior of Initially Unwed Mothers: Results From a Twins Experiment
. Journal of Political Economy
, 109
, 529
–45
. 10.1086/321016Grogger, J., Karoly, L.A., & Klerman, J.A. (
2002
). Consequences of Welfare Reform: A Research Synthesis
. Santa Monica, CA
: RAND
.Harknett, K., & Gennetian, L.A. (
2003
). How an Earnings Supplement Can Affect Union Formation Among Low-Income Single Mothers
. Demography
, 40
, 451
–78
. 10.1353/dem.2003.0024Hoffman, S.D., & Duncan, G.J. (
1995
). The Effect of Incomes, Wages, and AFDC Benefits on Marital Disruption
. Journal of Human Resources
, 30
, 19
–41
. 10.2307/146189Horn, W.F., & Sawhill, I.V. (
2001
). Fathers, Marriage, and Welfare Reform
. In Blank, R.M., & Haskins, R. (Eds.), The New World of Welfare
(pp. 421
–41
). Washington, DC
: Brookings Institution
.Hoynes, H.W. (
1997
). Does Welfare Play Any Role in Female Headship Decisions?
. Journal of Public Economics
, 65
, 89
–117
. 10.1016/S0047-2727(97)00022-4Kaestner, R. and N. Kaushal. Forthcoming. “Immigrant and Native Responses to Welfare Reform.” Journal of Population Economics.
Klerman, J.A. and S.J. Haider. Forthcoming. “A Stock-Flow Analysis of the Welfare Caseload.” Journal of Human Resources.
Kreider, R.M. and J.M. Fields. 2002. “Number, Timing, and Duration of Marriages and Divorces: 1996.” Current Population Reports, Series P-70, No. 80, February.
Lichter, D.T., Graefe, D.R., & Brown, J.B. (
2003
). Is Marriage a Panacea? Union Formation Among Economically Disadvantaged Unwed Mothers
. Social Problems
, 50
, 60
–86
. 10.1525/sp.2003.50.1.60Lichter, D.T., McLaughlin, D.K., & Ribar, D.C. (
2002
). Economic Restructuring and the Retreat From Marriage
. Social Science Research
, 31
, 230
–56
. 10.1006/ssre.2001.0728Loprest, P. (
2001
). ow Are Families that Left Welfare Doing? A Comparison of Early and Recent Welfare Leavers
. Washington, DC
: Urban Institute
.Manning, W.D., & Smock, P.J. (
1995
). Why Marry? Race and the Transition to Marriage Among Cohabitors
. Demography
, 32
, 509
–20
. 10.2307/2061671Michalopoulos, C., Card, D., Gennetian, L.A., Harknett, K., & Robins, P.K. (
2000
). The Self Sufficiency Project at 36 Months: Effects of a Financial Work Incentive on Employment and Income
. Ottawa
: Social Research and Demonstration Corporation
.Moffitt, R. (
1990
). The Effect of the U.S. Welfare System on Marital Status
. Journal of Public Economics
, 41
, 101
–24
. 10.1016/0047-2727(92)90058-NMoffitt, R. (
1994
). Welfare Effects on Female Headship With Area Effects
. Journal of Human Resources
, 29
, 621
–36
. 10.2307/146113Moffitt, R. (
1998
). The Effect of Welfare on Marriage and Fertility
. In Moffitt, R. (Ed.), Welfare, the Family, and Reproductive Behavior
(pp. 50
–97
). Washington, DC
: National Academy Press
.Moffitt, R. (
2001
). Welfare Benefits and Female Headship in U.S. Time Series
. In Wu, L.L., & Wolfe, B. (Eds.), Out of Wedlock: Causes and Consequences of Nonmarital Fertility
(pp. 143
–72
). New York
: Russell Sage Foundation
.Moffitt, R. (
2002
). Economic Effects of Means-Tested Transfers in the U.S
. Cambridge, MA
: National Bureau of Economic Research
.Moffitt, R. (
2002
). The Temporary Assistance for Needy Families Program
. Cambridge, MA
: National Bureau of Economic Research
.Murray, C. (
2001
). Family Formation
. In Blank, R.M., & Haskins, R. (Eds.), The New World of Welfare
(pp. 137
–68
). Washington, DC
: Brookings Institution
.Oppenheimer, V.K. (
1997
). Women’s Employment and the Gain to Marriage: The Specialization and Trading Model
. Annual Review of Sociology
, 23
, 431
–53
. 10.1146/annurev.soc.23.1.431Ressler, R.A., & Waters, M.S. (
2000
). Female Earnings and the Divorce Rate: A Simultaneous Equations Model
. Applied Economics
, 32
, 1889
–98
. 10.1080/000368400425107Rosenbaum, D.T. (
2000
). Taxes, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and Marital Status
. Evanston, IL, and Chicago
: Joint Center for Poverty Research
.Schoeni, R.F., & Blank, R.M. (
2000
). What Has Welfare Reform Accomplished? Impacts on Welfare Participation, Employment, Income, Poverty, and Family Structure
. Cambridge, MA
: National Bureau of Economic Research
.Schoeni, R.F. (
2003
). Changes in the Distribution of Children’s Family Income Over the 1990s
. American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings
, 93
, 304
–308
. 10.1257/000282803321947245Schultz, T.P. (
1994
). Marital Status and Fertility in the United States: Welfare and Labor Market Effects
. Journal of Human Resources
, 29
, 637
–69
. 10.2307/146114Thorton, A., & Rodgers, W.L. (
1987
). The Influence of Individual and Historical Time on Marital Dissolution
. Demography
, 24
, 1
–22
. 10.2307/2061505Tzeng, J.M., & Mare, R.D. (
1995
). Labor Market and Socioeconomic Effects on Marital Stability
. Social Science Research
, 24
, 329
–51
. 10.1006/ssre.1995.1013Aid to Families With Dependent Children: The Baseline
. (1998
). Washington, DC
: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
.Winkler, A.E. (
1995
). Does AFDC-UP Encourage Two-Parent Families?
. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management
, 14
, 4
–24
. 10.2307/3325430Wood, R.G. (
1995
). Marriage Rates and Marriageable Men: A Test of the Wilson Hypothesis
. Journal of Human Resources
, 31
, 163
–93
. 10.2307/146195© Population Association of America 2004
2004
Issue Section:
Articles
