Abstract
We examine the effect of the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) on migrants ’ wages using data gathered in 39 Mexican communities and their U.S. destination areas. We examine changes in the determinants of wages before and after the passage of IRCA, as well as the effects of its massive legalization program. Migrants ’ wages deteriorated steadily between 1970 and 1995, but IRCA did not foment discrimination against Mexican workers per se. Rather, it appears to have encouraged greater discrimination against undocumented migrants, with employers passing the costs and risks of unauthorized hiring on to the workers. Although available data do not permit us to eliminate competing explanations entirely, limited controls suggest that the post-IRCA wage penalty against undocumented migrants did not stem from an expansion of the immigrant labor supply, an increase in the use of labor subcontracting, or a deterioration of the U.S. labor market.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
ACCRA Cost of Living Index
. (1983
). Louisville, KY
: American Chamber of Commerce Research Association
.Bailey, T. (
1985
). The Influence of Legal Status on the Labor Market Impact of Immigration.
. International Migration Review
, 19
, 220
–38
. 10.2307/2545770Bansak, C. and S. Raphael. 1998. “Immigration Reform and the Earnings of Latino Workers: Do Employer Sanctions Cause Discrimination?” Discussion Paper 98–20, Department of Economics, University of California at San Diego.
Bean, F.D., Espenshade, T.J., White, M.J., & Dymowski., R.F. (
1990
). Post-IRCA Changes in the Volume and Composition of Undocumented Migration to the United States: An Assessment Based on Apprehensions Data.
. In F.D. Bean, B. Edmonston, & J.S Passel (Eds.), Undocumented Migration to the United States: IRCA and the Experience of the 1980s
(pp. 111
–58
). Washington, DC
: The Urban Institute Press
.Bean, F.D., Vernez, G., & Keely, C.B. (
1989
). Opening and Closing the Doors: Evaluating Immigration Reform and Control
. Washington, DC
: The Urban Institute
.Becker, G.S. (
1975
). Human Capital: A Theoretical Analysis With Special Reference to Education.
. Chicago
: University of Chicago Press
.Chiswick, B.R. (
1984
). Illegal Aliens in the United States Labor Market: An Analysis of Occupational Attainment and Earnings.
. International Migration Review
, 18
, 714
–32
. 10.2307/2545894Chiswick, B.R. (
1988
). Illegal Aliens: Their Employment and Employers.
. Kalamazoo, MI
: Upjohn Institute for Employment Research
.Cobb-Clark, D.A., Shiells, CR., & Lowell, B.L. (
1995
). Immigration Reform: The Effects of Employer Sanctions and Legalization on Wages.
. Journal of Labor Economics
, 13
, 472
–98
. 10.1086/298382Coleman, J.S. (
1988
). Social Capital in the Creation of Human Capital.
. American Journal of Sociology
, 94S
, S95
–120
. 10.1086/228943Cornelius, W. (
1989
). Impacts of the 1986 U.S. Immigration Law on Emigration From Rural Mexican Sending Communities.
. Population and Development Review
, 15
, 689
–705
. 10.2307/1972595Dávila, A., Pagán, J., & Grau, M.V. (
1998
). The Impact of IRCA on the Job Opportunities and Earnings of Mexican-American and Hispanic-American Workers.
. International Migration Review
, 32
, 79
–95
. 10.2307/2547561Donato, K.M. (
1994
). U.S. Policy and Mexican Migration to the United States, 1942–92.
. Social Science Quarterly
, 75
, 705
–29
.Donato, K., Durand, J., & Massey, D.S. (
1992
). Changing Conditions in the U.S. Labor Market: Effects of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986.
. Population Research and Policy Review
, 11
, 93
–115
. 10.1007/BF00125533Donato, K. (
1992
). Stemming the Tide? Assessing the Deterrent Effects of the Immigration Reform and Control Act.
. Demography
, 29
, 139
–57
. 10.2307/2061724Donato, K.M., & Massey, D.S. (
1993
). Effect of the Immigration Reform and Control Act on the Wages of Mexican Migrants.
. Social Science Quarterly
, 74
, 523
–41
.Durand, J. 1997. “De Enganchadores a Contratistas: La Fifusion de un Nuevo Sistema de Contratación de Mano de Obra Mexicana.” Paper Presented at the meetings of the Latin American Studies Association, Guadalajara, April 17–19.
Espenshade, T.J. (
1990
). Undocumented Migration to the United States: Evidence From a Repeated Trials Model.
. In F.D. Bean, B. Edmonston, & J.S. Passel (Eds.), Undocumented Migration to the United States: IRCA and the Experience of the 1980s
(pp. 159
–82
). Washington, DC
: The Urban Institute Press
.Espinosa, K., & Massey, D.S. (
1997
). Undocumented Migration and the Quantity and Quality of Social Capital.
. Soziale Welt
, 12
, 141
–62
.Fry, R., Lowell, B.L., & Haghighat, E. (
1995
). The Impact of Employer Sanctions on Metropolitan Wage Rates.
. Industrial Relations
, 34
, 464
–84
.Greenwell, L., Valdez, R.B., & DaVanzo, J. (
1997
). Social Ties, Wages, and Gender in a Study of Salvadorean and Pilipino Immigrants in Los Angeles.
. Social Science Quarterly
, 78
, 559
–77
.Hagan, J.M. (
1994
). Deciding to Be Legal: A Maya Community in Houston
. Philadelphia
: Temple University Press
.Heckman, J.J. (
1979
). Sample Selection Bias as a Specification Error.
. Econometrica
, 47
, 153
–62
. 10.2307/1912352Heer, D.M. and D. Falasco. 1983. “Determinants of Earnings Among Three Groups of Mexican Americans: Undocumented Immigrants, Legal Immigrants, and the Native Bom.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Population Association of America, Minneapolis.
Koussoudji, S.A. and S.I. Ranney. 1984. “Wage Rates of Temporary Mexican Migrants to the U.S.: The Role of Legal Status.” Paper presented at the meeting of the Econometrica Society, Dallas, TX.
Lindstrom, D.P., & Massey, D.S. (
1994
). Selective Emigration, Cohort Quality, and Models of Immigrant Assimilation.
. Social Science Research
, 23
, 315
–49
. 10.1006/ssre.1994.1013Loury, G.C. (
1977
). A Dynamic Theory of Racial Income Differences.
. In P.A. Wallace, & A.M. LaMond (Eds.), Women, Minorities and Employment Discrimination
(pp. 153
–62
). Lexington, MA
: D.C. Heath and Company
.Lowell, B.L., & Jing, Z. (
1994
). Unauthorized Workers and Immigration Reform: What Can We Ascertain From Employers?
. International Migration Review
, 28
, 427
–48
. 10.2307/2546815Lowell, B.L., Teachman, J., & Jing , Z. (
1995
). Unintended Consequences of Immigration Reform: Discrimination and Hispanic Employment.
. Demography
, 32
, 617
–28
. 10.2307/2061678Martin, P.L. (
1996
). Promises to Keep: Collective Bargaining in California Agriculture
. Ames, IA
: Iowa State University Press
.Martin, P.L., Taylor, J.E., & Fix, M. (
1991
). Immigration Reform and Farm Labor Contracting in California.
The Paper Curtain: Employer Sanctions ’ Implementation, Impact, and Reform
(pp. 239
–61
). Washington, DC
: The Urban Institute Press
.Martin, P.L., Taylor, J.E., & Hardiman, P. (
1988
). California Farmworkers and the SAW Legalization Program.
. California Agriculture
, 42
, 4
–6
.Massey, D.S. (
1986
). The Settlement Process Among Mexican Mi-grants to the United States.
. American Sociological Review
, 51
, 670
–85
. 10.2307/2095492Massey, D.S. (
1987
). Do Undocumented Migrants Earn Lower Wages?
. International Migration Review
, 21
, 236
–74
. 10.2307/2546315Massey, D.S., Alarcon, R., Durand, J., & Gonzalez, H. (
1987
). Return to Aztlan: The Social Process of International Migration From Western Mexico.
. London
: University of California Press
.Massey, D.S., Donato, K.M., & Liang, Z. (
1990
). Effects of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986: Preliminary Data From Mexico.
. In F.D. Bean, B. Edmonston, & J.S. Passel (Eds.), Undocumented Migration to the United States: IRCA and the Experience of the 1980s
(pp. 182
–210
). Washington, DC
: The Urban Institute.
.Massey, D.S., & Espinosa, K.E. (
1997
). What’s Driving Mexico-U.S. Migration? A Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Analysis.
. American Journal of Sociology
, 102
, 939
–99
. 10.1086/231037Massey, D.S., Goldring, L.P., & Durand, J. (
1994
). Continuities in Transnational Migration: An Analysis of 19 Communities.
. American Journal of Sociology
, 99
, 1492
–532
. 10.1086/230452Massey, D.S., & Parrado, E.A. (
1994
). Migradollars: The Remittances and Savings of Mexican Migrants to the United States.
. Population Research and Policy Review
, 13
, 3
–30
. 10.1007/BF01074319Massey, D.S., & Singer, A. (
1995
). New Estimates of Undocumented Mexican Migration and the Probability of Apprehension.
. Demography
, 32
, 203
–11
. 10.2307/2061740Perotti, R. (
1992
). IRCA’s Antidiscrimination Provisions: What Went Wrong?
. International Migration Review
, 26
, 732
–53
. 10.2307/2546963Portes, A., & Sensenbrenner, J. (
1993
). Embeddedness and Immigration: Notes on the Social Determinants of Economic Action.
. American Journal of Sociology
, 98
, 1320
–51
. 10.1086/230191Singer, A., & Massey, D.S. (
1998
). The Social Process of Undocumented Border Crossing.
. International Migration Review
, 32
, 561
–92
. 10.2307/2547764Sorensen, E., & Bean, F.D. (
994
). The Immigration Reform and Control Act and the Wages of Mexican Origin Workers: Evidence From Current Population Surveys.
. Social Science Quarterly
, 75
, 1
–17
.Sudman, S. (
1983
). Applied Sampling.
. In P.H. Rossi, J.D. Wright, & A.B. Anderson (Eds.), Handbook of Survey Research
(pp. 145
–94
). Orlando, FL
: Academic Press
.Taylor, J.E. (
1996
). IRCA’s Effects in California Agriculture.
. In PL. Martin, W. Huffman, R. Emerson, & J.E. Taylor (Eds.), Immigration Reform and U.S. Agriculture
(pp. 181
–206
). Oakland
: California Division of Agriculture and Natural Resources
.Taylor, J.E., Martin, P.L, & Fix, M. (
1997
). Poverty Amid Prosperity: Immigration and the Changing Face of Rural California
. Washington, DC
: The Urban Institute Press
.Taylor, J.E., & Thilmany, D. (
1993
). Worker Turnover, Farm Labor Contractors, and IRCA’s Impact on the California Farm Labor Market.
. American Journal of Agricultural Economics
, 75
, 350
–60
. 10.2307/1242919Taylor, J.E., & Wyatt, T.J. (
1996
). The Shadow Value of Migrant Remittances, Income, and Inequality in a Household-Farm Economy.
. Journal of Development Studies
, 32
, 819
–912
. 10.1080/00220389608422445Teitelbaum, M.S. (
1986
). Intersections: Immigration and Demographic Change and Their Impact on the United States.
. In J.A. Menken (Ed.), World Population and U.S. Policy: The Choices Ahead
(pp. 133
–74
). New York
: W.W. Norton.
.Tilly, C., & Brown, CH. (
1967
). On Uprooting, Kinship, and the Auspices of Migration.
. International Journal of Comparative Sociology
, 8
, 139
–64
. 10.1177/002071526700800201U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Various Years. Employment and Unemployment in States and Local Areas 1974, 1976–1995 (MRDF). Distributed by the U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Washington, DC.
Employer Sanctions and U.S. Labor Markets: First Report
. (1991
). Washington, DC
: U.S. Government Printing Office
.Immigration Reform: Employer Sanctions and the Question of Discrimination
. (1990
). Washington, DC
: U.S. Government Printing Office.
.U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service. Various Years. Immigrants Admitted to the United States, 1972-1993 (MRDF). Distributed by Inter-Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR), Ann Arbor, MI.
Statistical Yearbook of the Immigration and Naturalization Service 1990
. (1991
). Washington, DC
: U.S. Government Printing Office
.Statistical Yearbook of the Immigration and Naturalization Service 1991.
. (1992
). Washington, DC
: U.S. Government Printing Office
.Statistical Yearbook of the Immigration and Naturalization Service 1994
. (1995
). Washington, DC
: U.S. Government Printing Office.
.White, M.J., Bean, F.D., & Espenshade, T.J. (
1990
). The U.S. 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act and Undocumented Migration to the United States.
. Population Research and Policy Review
, 9
, 93
–116
. 10.1007/BF02343244© Population Association of America 1999
1999
Issue Section:
Consequences of Policy Shifts and Political Change
