Abstract

In a recent article (Frisbie. Forbes. and Pullum 1996) we documented racial/ethnic differences in birth outcomes according to a more fine-grained classification than has typically been employed in the demographic literature. In his commentary, van der Veen focuses on the measurement of one of the dimensions of that classification, maturity of the infant. as proxied by the fetal growth ratio. The crux of the critique is easily seen in van der Veen's statement that “all of my disagreements with Frisbie et al. 's method arise from their particular use of a postnatal standard for the assessment of intrauterine growth.” Our critic misunderstands our objective: He fails to realize our interest in birth outcome, not pregnancy process, and does not perceive that our intent was to extend the research extant in both the demographic and public-health literatures in which patently postnatal (i.e., ex utero) measures are taken as outcomes interesting in their own right and/or as risk factors for infant mortality and infant and childhood morbidity. Specifically, he does recognize that we purposefully expanded our focus to include moderately compromised births to determine if they were at higher risk than the normal births with whom they are conventionally categorized. Our discussion draws on research cited in the original article, on studies cited by our critic, and on a few more recent investigations. Although we have never argued that ours is the only, or even the best, approach in all cases, we try to clarify the rationale for, and adduce additional empirical evidence of, the utility of the method we used.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

References

Alexander, G.R. (
1997
).
Annotation: The Accurate Measurement of Gestational Age—A Critical Step Toward Improving Fetal Death Reporting and Perinatal Health
.
American Journal of Public Health
,
87
,
1278
79
. 10.2105/AJPH.87.8.1278
Balcazar, H. (
1993
).
Mexican Americans' Intrauterine Growth Retardation and Maternal Risk Factors
.
Ethnicity and Disease
,
3
,
169
75
.
Balcazar, H. (
1994
).
The Prevalence of Intrauterine Growth Retardation in Mexican Americans
.
American Journal of Public Health
,
84
,
462
65
. 10.2105/AJPH.84.3.462
Balcazar, H., Keefer, L., & Chard, T. (
1994
).
Use of Anthropometric Indicators and Maternal Risk Factors to Evaluate Intrauterine Growth Retardation in Infants Weighing More Than 2,500 Grams at Birth
.
Early Human Development
,
36
,
147
55
. 10.1016/0378-3782(94)90001-9
Battaglia, F., Frazier, T., & Hellegers, A. (
1966
).
Birth Weight, Gestational Age, and Pregnancy Outcome, With Special Reference to High-Birth-Weight-Low-Gestational-Age Infants
.
Pediatrics
,
37
,
417
417
.
Battaglia, F.C., & Lubchenco, L.O. (
1967
).
A Practical Classification of Newborn Infants by Weight and Gestational Age
.
Journal of Pediatrics
,
71
,
159
63
. 10.1016/S0022-3476(67)80066-0
Brenner, W.E., Edelman, D.A., & Hendricks, C.H. (
1976
).
A Standard of Fetal Growth for the United States of America
.
American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
,
126
,
555
64
.
David, R. (
1990
).
Race, Birth Weight, and Mortality Rates
.
Journal of Pediatrics
,
116
,
101
102
. 10.1016/S0022-3476(05)81653-1
Frisbie, W.P., Forbes, D., & Pullum, S.G. (
1996
).
Compromised Birth Outcomes and Infant Mortality Among Racial and Ethnic Groups
.
Demography
,
33
,
469
81
. 10.2307/2061781
Goldenberg, R., Cutter, G., Hoffman, H., Foster, J., Nelson, K., & Hauth, J. (
1989
).
Intrauterine Growth Retardation: Standard for Diagnosis
.
American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
,
161
,
271
77
.
Gruenwald, P. (
1963
).
Chronic Fetal Distress and Placental Insufficiency
.
Biological Neonatology
,
5
,
215
215
. 10.1159/000239870
Hadlock, F., Harris, R., & Martinez-Poyer, J. (
1991
).
In Utero Analysis of Fetal Growth: A Sonographic Weight Standard
.
Radiology
,
181
,
129
33
.
Hadlock, F., Harris, R., Shah, Y., Sharman, R., & Park, S. (
1990
).
Sonographic Fetal Growth Standards: Are Current Data Applicable to a Racially Mixed Population?
.
Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine
,
9
,
157
60
.
Hummer, R., M. Biegler, P. DeTurk, D. Forbes, W.P. Frisbie, Y. Hong, and S.G. Pullum. Forthcoming. “Race/Ethnicity, Nativity, and Infant Mortality in the United States.” Social Forces.
Hummer, R.A., Schmertmann, C.P., Eberstein, I.W., & Kelly, S. (
1995
).
Retrospective Reports of Pregnancy Wantedness and Birth Outcomes in the United States
.
Social Science Quarterly
,
76
,
402
18
.
Preventing Low Birthweight
. (
1985
).
Washington, DC
:
National Academy Press
.
Kallan, J.E. (
1993
).
Race, Intervening Variables, and Two Components of Low Birth Weight
.
Demography
,
30
,
489
506
. 10.2307/2061653
Kiely, J.L., & Susser, M. (
1992
).
Preterm Birth, Intrauterine Growth Retardation, and Perinatal Mortality
.
American Journal of Public Health
,
82
,
343
45
. 10.2105/AJPH.82.3.343
Kline, J., Stein, Z., & Susser, M. (
1989
).
Conception to Birth: Epidemiology of Prenatal Development
.
New York
:
Oxford University Press
.
Kramer, M.S., McLean, F.H., Olivier, M., Willis, D.M., & Usher, R.H. (
1989
).
Body Proportionality and Head and Length ‘Sparing’ in Growth-Retarded Neonates: A Critical Reappraisal
.
Pediatrics
,
84
,
717
23
.
Lubchenco, L.O., & Koops, B.L. (
1987
).
Assessment of Weight and Gestational Age
. In G.B. Avery (Ed.),
Neonatology: Pathophysiology and Management of the Newborn
(pp.
235
57
). 3rd edition
Philadelphia
:
Lippincott
.
McCarton, C., Wallace, I., Divon, M., & Vaughan, H. (
1996
).
Cognitive and Neurologic Development of the Premature, Small for Gestational Age Infant Through Age 6: Comparison by Birth Weight and Gestational Age
.
Pediatrics
,
98
,
1167
78
.
Myers, S., & Ferguson, R. (
1989
).
A Population Study of the Relationship Between Fetal Death and Altered Fetal Growth
.
Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
,
74
,
325
31
.
Linked Birth/Infant Death Data Set: 1991 Birth Cohort
Public Use Data File Documentation
. (
1995
).
Hyattsville, MD
:
National Center for Health Statistics
.
van der Veen, W.I. (
1998
).
Comment on 'Compromised Birth Outcomes and Infant Mortality Among Racial and Ethnic Groups.
.
Demography
,
35
,
509
517
. 10.2307/3004019
Wilcox, A.I. (
1981
).
Birth Weight, Gestation, and the Fetal Growth Curve
.
American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology
,
139
,
863
67
.
Wilcox, A.I., & Russell, I. (
1986
).
Birthweight and Perinatal Mortality: III. Towards a New Method of Analysis
.
International Journal of Epidemiology
,
15
,
188
98
. 10.1093/ije/15.2.188
Wilcox, A.I., & Russell, I. (
1990
).
Why Small Black Infants Have a Lower Mortality Rate Than Small White Infants: The Case for Population-Specific Standards for Birth Weight
.
The Journal of Pediatrics
,
116
,
7
10
. 10.1016/S0022-3476(05)81638-5
Wise, P.H. (
1993
).
Confronting Racial Disparities in Infant Mortality: Reconciling Science and Politics
.
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
,
9
,
7
16
.
Yerushalmy, I. (
1967
).
The Classification of Newborn Infants by Birth Weight and Gestational Age
.
Journal of Pediatrics
,
71
,
164
72
. 10.1016/S0022-3476(67)80067-2
Yudkin, P., Aboualfa, M., Eyre, I., Redman, C., & Wilkinson, A. (
1987
).
New Birthweight and Head Circumference Centiles for Gestational Ages 24 to 42 Weeks
.
Early Human Development
,
15
,
45
52
. 10.1016/0378-3782(87)90099-5
Yudkin, P., Aboualfa, M., Eyre, I., Redman, C., & Wilkinson, A. (
1987
).
Influence of Elective Preterm Delivery on Birthweight and Head Circumference Standards
.
Archives of Disease in Childhood
,
62
,
24
29
. 10.1136/adc.62.1.24