Abstract
In this essay. I suggest that the crisis in our understanding of fertility transitions is more apparent than real. Although most existing theories of fertility transition have been partially or wholly discredited, this reflects a tendency to assume that all fertility transitions share one or two causes, to ignore mortality decline as a precondition for fertility decline, to assume that pretransitional fertility is wholly governed by social constraints rather than by individual decision-making. and to test ideas on a decadal time scale. I end the essay by suggesting a perceptual. interactive approach to explaining fertility transitions that is closely allied to existing theories but focuses on conditions that lead couples to switch from postnatal to prenatal controls on family size.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Amin, S., Cleland, J., Phillips, J.P., & Kamal, G.M. (
1995
). Socioeconomic Change and the Demand for Children in Rural Bangladesh
. New York
: The Population Council
.Becker, G.S. (
1960
). An Economic Analysis of Fertility
Demographic and Economic Change in Developed Countries: A Conference of the Universities-National Bureau Committee for Economic Research
(pp. 209
–31
). Princeton
: Princeton University Press
.Blake, J. (
1985
). The Fertility Transition: Continuity or Discontinuity with the Past?
International Population Conference, Florence, 1985
(pp. 393
–405
). Liege, Belgium
: International Union for the Scientific Study of Population
.Bledsoe, C. (
1990
). The Politics of Children: Fosterage and the Social Management of Fertility Among the Mende of Sierra Leone
. In W.P. Handwerker (Ed.), Births and Power: Social Change and the Politics of Reproduction
(pp. 81
–100
). Boulder, CO
: Westview Press
.Bongaarts, J. (
1994
). The Impact of Population Policies: Comment
. Population and Development Review
, 20
(3
), 616
–20
. 10.2307/2137604Bongaarts, J., & Watkins, S.C. (
1996
). Social Interactions and Contemporary Fertility Transitions
. Population and Development Review
, 22
(4
), 639
–82
. 10.2307/2137804R.A. Bulatao, & R.D. Lee (
1983
). Determinants of Fertility in Developing Countries
. New York
: Academic Press
.Caldwell, J.C. (
1993
). The Asian Fertility Revolution: Its Implications for Transition Theory
. In R. Leete, & I. Alam (Eds.), The Revolution in Asian Fertility: Dimensions, Causes, and Implications
(pp. 299
–316
). Oxford
: Clarendon Press
.Caldwell, I.C., Orubuloye, I.O., & Caldwell, P. (
1992
). Fertility Decline in Africa: A New Type of Transition?
. Population and Development Review
, 18
(2
), 2 11
–42
. 10.2307/1973678Chesnais, J.-C. (
1992
). The Demographic Transition: Stages, Patterns, and Economic Implications. A Longitudinal Study of Sixty-Seven Countries Covering the Period 1720–1984
. Oxford, England
: Clarendon Press
.Cleland, I. (
1985
). Marital Fertility Decline in Developing Countries: Theories and the Evidence
. In J. Cleland, & J. Hobcraft (Eds.), Reproductive Change in Developing Countries: Insights from the World Fertility Survey
(pp. 223
–52
). Oxford, England
: Oxford University Press
.Cleland, I. (
1993
). Equity, Security and Fertility: A Reaction to Thomas
. Population Studies
, 47
(2
), 345
–52
. 10.1080/0032472031000147056Cleland, J., & Wilson, C. (
1987
). Demand Theories of the Fertility Transition: An Iconoclastic View
. Population Studies
, 41
(1
), 530
–530
. 10.1080/0032472031000142516Coale, A. J. (
1973
). The Demographic Transition Reconsidered
International Population Conference, Liege
(pp. 53
–72
). Liege, Belgium
: International Union for the Scientific Study of Population
.Coale, A. J. (
1986
). The Decline of Fertility in Europe Since the Eighteenth Century As a Chapter in Demographic History
. In A.J. Coale, & S.C. Watkins (Eds.), The Decline of Fertility in Europe
(pp. 1
–30
). Princeton, NI
: Princeton University Press
.A.I. Coale, & S.C. Watkins (
1986
). The Decline of Fertility in Europe
. Princeton, NI
: Princeton University Press
.Davis, K. (
1955
). Institutional Patterns Favoring High Fertility in Underdeveloped Areas
. Eugenics Quarterly
, 2
, 33
–39
.Davis, K. (
1963
). The Theory of Change and Response in Modern Demographic History
. Population Index
, 29
, 345
–66
. 10.2307/2732014Easterlin, R.A. (
1975
). An Economic Framework for Fertility Analysis
. Studies in Family Planning
, 6
, 54
–63
. 10.2307/1964934Easterlin, R.A. (
1978
). The Economics and Sociology of Fertility: A Synthesis
. In C. Tilly (Ed.), Historical Studies of Changing Fertility
(pp. 57
–133
). Princeton, NI
: Princeton University Press
.Easterlin, R.A., & Crimmins, E.N. (
1985
). The Fertility Revolution: A Demand-Supply Analysis
. Chicago, IL
: University of Chicago Press
.Feeney, G. (
1994
). Fertility Decline in East Asia
. Science
, 266
(2
), 1518
–23
. 10.1126/science.7985021Flandrin, I.-L. (
1976
). Families in Former Times: Kinship, Household and Sexuality
. Cambridge, MA
: Cambridge University Press
.Freedman, R. (
1979
). Overview
. In L.-I. Cho, & K. Kobayashi (Eds.), Fertility Transition in the East Asian Populations
(pp. 286
–98
). Honolulu, HI
: University Press of Hawaii
.Freedman, R. (
1979
). Theories of Fertility Decline: A Reappraisal
. Social Forces
, 58
(1
), 1
–17
. 10.2307/2577781Freedman, R. (
1997
). Do Family Planning Programs Affect Fertility Preferences? A Literature Review
. Studies in Family Planning
, 28
(1
), 1
–13
. 10.2307/2137966Friedl, E. (
1975
). Women and Men: An Anthropologist’s View
. New York
: Holt, Rinehart and Winston
.Geertz, H. (
1961
). The Javanese Family: A Study of Kinship and Socialization
. Prospect Heights, IL
: Waveland Press
.Goody, J. (
1996
). Comparing Family Systems in Europe and Asia: Are There Different Sets of Rules?
. Population and Development Review
, 22
(1
), 1
–20
. 10.2307/2137684Greenhalgh, S. (
1990
). Toward a Political Economy of Fertility: Anthropological Contributions
. Population and Development Review
, 16
(1
), 85
–106
. 10.2307/1972530Greenhalgh, S. (
1992
). State-Society Links: Political Dimensions of Population Policies and Programmes, with Special Reference to China
. In I.F. Phillips, & I.A. Ross (Eds.), Family Planning Programmes and Fertility
(pp. 276
–98
). Oxford, England
: Clarendon Press
.Hajnal, I. (
1965
). European Marriage Patterns in Perspective
. In D.V. Glass (Ed.), Population in History:’ Essays in Historical Demography
(pp. 101
–43
). London, England
: Edward Arnold
.Hammel, E.A. (
1990
). A Theory of Culture for Demography
. Population and Development Review
, 16
(3
), 455
–85
. 10.2307/1972832Hanley, S. B. (
1979
). The Iapanese Fertility Decline in Historical Perspective
. In L.-I. Cho, & K. Kobayashi (Eds.), Fertility Transition of the East Asian Populations
(pp. 24
–48
). Honolulu, HI
: University of Hawaii Press
.Harkavy, O. (
1995
). Curbing Population Growth: An Insider’s Perspective on the Population Movement
. New York
: Plenum Press
.Henry, L. (
1961
). Some Data on Natural Fertility
. Eugenics Quarterly
, 8
, 81
–91
.Hirschman, C. (
1994
). Why Fertility Changes
. Annual Review of Sociology
, 20
, 203
–33
. 10.1146/annurev.so.20.080194.001223Johansson, S.R. (
1991
). ‘Implicit’ Policy and Fertility During Development
. Population and Development Review
, 17
(3
), 377
–414
. 10.2307/1971947Knodel, I. (
1983
). Natural Fertility: Age Patterns, Levels, and Trends
. In R.A. Bulatao, & R.D. Lee (Eds.), Determinants of Fertility in Developing Countries
(pp. 61
–102
). New York
: Academic Press
.Knodel, I., & van de Walle, E. (
1979
). Lessons from the Past: Policy Implications of Historical Fertility Studies
. Population and Development Review
, 5
, 217
–45
. 10.2307/1971824Knowles, I.C., Akin, I.S., & Guilkey, D.K. (
1994
). The Impact of Population Policies: Comment
. Population and Development Review
, 29
(3
), 611
–15
. 10.2307/2137603Langer, W.L. (
1972
). Checks on Population Growth: 1750–1850
. Scientific American
, 226
(2
), 92
–99
. 10.1038/scientificamerican0272-92Lee, I., Wang, E., & Campbell, C. (
1994
). Infant and Child Mortality Among the Qing Nobility: Implications for Two Types of Positive Check
. Population Studies
, 48
(3
), 395
–411
. 10.1080/0032472031000147936Leibenstein, H.M. (
1957
). Economic Backwardness and Economic Growth
. New York
: Iohn Wiley and Sons
.Lesthaeghe, R. (
1980
). On the Social Control of Human Reproduction
. Population and Development Review
, 6
(4
), 527
–48
. 10.2307/1972925Lesthaeghe, R. (
1983
). A Century of Demographic and Cultural Change in Western Europe: An Exploration of Underlying Dimensions
. Population and Development Review
, 9
(3
), 411
–35
. 10.2307/1973316Lesthaeghe, R. (
1995
). The Second Demographic Transition in Western Countries: An Interpretation
. In K.O. Mason, & A.-M. Iensen (Eds.), Gender and Family Change in Industrialized Countries
(pp. 17
–62
). Oxford, England
: Clarendon Press
.Lesthaeghe, R., Ohadike, P.O., Kocher, I., & Page, H.I. (
1981
). Child-Spacing and Fertility in Sub-Saharan Africa: An Over view of Issues
. In H. Page, & R. Lesthaeghe (Eds.), Child-Spacing in Tropical Africa: Traditions and Change
(pp. 3
–23
). London, England
: Academic Press
.Lesthaeghe, R., & Surkyn, J. (
1988
). Cultural Dynamics and Economic Theories of Fertility Change
. Population and Development Review
, 14
(1
), 1
–45
. 10.2307/1972499Lesthaeghe, R., & Wilson, C. (
1986
). Modes of Production, Secularization, and the Pace of the Fertility Decline in Western Europe, 1870–1930
. In A.l. Coale, & S.C. Watkins (Eds.), The Decline of Fertility in Europe
(pp. 261
–92
). Princeton, Nl
: Princeton University Press
.Levine, D. (
1977
). Family Formation in an Age of Nascent Capitalism
. New York
: Academic Press
.Lloyd, C.B., & Ivanov, S. (
1988
). The Effects of lmproved Child Survival on Family Planning Practice and Fertility
. Studies in Family Planning
, 19
(3
), 141
–61
. 10.2307/1966750Mason, K.O. (
1992
). Culture and the Fertility Transition: Thoughts on Theories of Fertility Decline
. Genus
, 48
, 114
–114
.Mason, K.O., & Taj, A.M. (
1987
). Differences Between Women’s and Men’s Reproductive Goals in Developing Countries
. Population and Development Review
, 13
(4
), 611
–38
. 10.2307/1973025McDonald, P. (
1993
). Fertility Transition Hypotheses
. In R. Leete, & I. Alam (Eds.), The Revolution in Asian Fertility: Dimensions, Causes, and Implications
(pp. 3
–14
). Oxford, England
: Clarendon Press
.Menken, I. (
1979
). Introduction
. In H. Leridon, & I. Menken (Eds.), Natural Fertility: Patterns and Determinants of Natural Fertility, Proceedings of a Seminar on Natural Fertility
(pp. 1
–13
). Liege, Belgium
: Ordina Editions
.Minturn, L., & Hitchcock, I.T. (
1966
). The Rajputs of Khalapur, India
. New York
: John Wiley and Sons
.Montgomery, M.R. (
1996
). Learning and Lags in Mortality Perceptions
. New York
: Research Division, The Population Council
.Morgan, S.P. (
1991
). Late Nineteenth- and Early Twentieth- Century Childlessness
. American Journal of Sociology
, 97
(3
), 779
–807
. 10.1086/229820Notestein, F. (
1953
). Economic Problems of Population Change
Proceedings of the Eight International Conference of Agricultural Economics
(pp. 13
–31
). London, England
: Oxford University Press
.Phillips, J.F., & Ross, I.A. (
1992
). itFamily Planning Programmes and Fertility
. Oxford, England
: Clarendon Press
.Pritchett, L.H. (
1994
). Desired Fertility and the Impact of Population Policies
. Population and Development Review
, 20
(1
), 1
–55
. 10.2307/2137629Robinson, W.C. (
1997
). The Economic Theory of Fertility Over Three Decades
. Population Studies
, 51
(1
), 63
–74
. 10.1080/0032472031000149736Robinson, W.C., & Cleland, I. (
1992
). The Influence of Contraceptive Costs on the Demand for Children
. In I.F. Phillips, & I.A. Ross (Eds.), Family Planning Programmes and Fertility
(pp. 106
–22
). Oxford, England
: Clarendon Press
.Schultz, T.W., ed. 1973. “New Economic Approaches to Fertility: Proceedings of a Conference, June 8–9, 1972.” Journal of Political Economy 81(2, Part II).
Skinner, G.W. (
1997
). Family Systems and Demographic Processes
. In D.I. Kertzer, & T.E. Fricke (Eds.), Anthropological Demography: Toward a New Synthesis
(pp. 53
–95
). Chicago, IL
: University of Chicago Press
.Szretzer, S. (
1993
). The Idea of Demographic Transition and the Study of Fertility Change: A Critical Intellectual History
. Population and Development Review
, 19
(4
), 659
–701
. 10.2307/2938410Teitelbaum, M.S. (
1975
). Relevance of Demographic Transition Theory for Developing Countries
. Science
, 188
(2
), 420
–25
. 10.1126/science.1124392Thornton, A., & Fricke, T.E. (
1987
). Social Change and the Family: Comparative Perspectives from the West, China, and South Asia
. In I.M. Stycos (Ed.), Demography as an Interdiscipline
(pp. 128
–61
). New Brunswick, NJ and Oxford, England
: Transaction Publishers
.van de Kaa, D.J. (
1996
). Anchored Narratives: The Story and Findings of a Half a Century of Research into the Determinants of Fertility
. Population Studies
, 50
(3
), 389
–432
. 10.1080/0032472031000149546van de Walle, F. (
1986
). Infant Mortality and the European Demographic Transition
. In A.J. Coale, & S.C. Watkins (Eds.), The Decline of Fertility in Europe
(pp. 201
–33
). Princeton, NJ
: Princeton University Press
.Wang, F., Lee, J., & Campbell, C. (
1995
). Marital Fertility Control among the Qing Nobility: Implications for Two Types of Preventive Check
. Population Studies
, 49
(3
), 383
–400
. 10.1080/0032472031000148736Ware, H. (
1983
). Female and Male Life-Cycles
. In C. Oppong (Ed.), Female and Male in West Africa
(pp. 6
–31
). London, England
: George Allen & Unwin
.Wilson, C. and P. Airey. 1997. “What Can Transition Theory Learn from the Diversity of Low-Growth Demographic Regimes?” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Population Association of America, Washington, D.C.
Wolf, A. (
1978
). Gods, Ghosts, and Ancestors
. In A. Wolf (Ed.), Studies in Chinese Society
(pp. 131
–82
). Stanford, CA
: Stanford University Press
.Wolf, M. (
1972
). Women and the Family in Rural Taiwan
. Stanford, CA
: Stanford University Press
.Wrigley, E.A. (
1969
). Family Limitation in Pre-Industrial England
. In M. Drake (Ed.), Population in Industrialization
(pp. 157
–94
). London, England
: Methuen
.Wrigley, E.A. (
1978
). Fertility Strategy for the Individual and the Group
. In C. Tilly (Ed.), Historical Studies of Changing Fertility
(pp. 135
–54
). Princeton, NJ
: Princeton University Press
.Wrong, D.H. (
1961
). The Oversocialized Conception of Man in Modern Sociology
. American Sociological Review
, 26
(2
), 183
–93
. 10.2307/2089854Zavala de Cosio, M.E., & Rodriguez, G. (
1996
). The Demographic Transition in Latin America and Europe
. In J. M. Guzman, S. Singh, & E.A. Pantelides (Eds.), The Fertility Transition in Latin America
(pp. 95
–109
). Oxford, England
: Clarendon Press
.© Population Association of America 1997
1997
Issue Section:
Presidential Address
