Abstract

Cross-sectional estimates of immigrant wage growth have painted an optimistic picture of the ability of immigrants to adapt to the U.S. labor market: Studies using cross-sectional data have generally found the wage growth of immigrants to exceed that of the native born. This optimistic picture of immigrant economic assimilation was challenged by the important finding that compared to earlier immigrant cohorts, recent immigrants started at much lower wages. As such, the high wage growth of immigrants relative to the native born measured in cross-sectional data may simply be the spurious result of declining immigrant earnings ability. In this paper, we match Current Population Survey samples so that the wages of individual immigrant and native-born men can be followed for one year. We find that the wage growth of immigrants does exceed that of the native born. The general finding of faster immigrant wage growth also holds when imposing the foreign-born geographic distribution upon natives, but not when imposing the native-born geographic distribution on the foreign born—a result consistent with some theories of immigrant assimilation. In each comparison, however, the actual wage growth of immigrants relative to natives is similar to the predictions of cross-sectional regressions. This similarity suggests that either there is no cohort quality bias in the cross-sectional estimates of immigrant wage growth, or that there has been a coincidental increase in immigrant wage growth as the entry wages of immigrants have fallen.

This content is only available as a PDF.

References

Ahmed, B. and G. Robinson. 1994. “Estimates of Emigration of the Foreign-Born Population: 1980–1990.” Population Estimates and Projections Technical Working Paper Series, No. 9, U.S. Bureau of the Census.
Bailey, T.R. (
1987
).
Immigrant and Native Workers: Contrasts and Competition
.
Boulder and London
:
Westview Press
.
Baker, M. and D. Benjamin. 1994. “The Role of the Family in Immigrants’ Labor Market Activity: An Evaluation of Alternative Explanations.” Working Paper No. 9416, Dept. of Economics and Institute for Policy Analysis, University of Toronto, July 1994.
Beach, C.M., & Worswick, C. (
1993
).
Is There a Double-Negative Effect on the Earnings of Immigrant Women?
.
Canadian Public Policy
,
19
(
1
),
36
53
. 10.2307/3551789
Borjas, G. (
1982
).
The Earnings of Male Hispanic Immigrants in the United States
.
Industrial and Labor Relations Review
,
35
,
343
53
. 10.2307/2522814
Borjas, G. (
1985
).
Assimilation, Changes in Cohort Quality, and the Earnings of Immigrants
.
Journal of Labor Economics
,
3
,
463
89
. 10.1086/298065
Borjas, G. (
1987
).
Self Selection and Immigrants
.
American Economic Review
,
77
,
531
53
.
Borjas, G. (
1992
).
Immigration Research in the 1980s: A Turbulent Decade
. In Lewin, D., Mitchell, O.S., & Sherer, P. (Eds.),
Research Frontiers in Industrial Relations and Human Resources
(pp.
417
46
).
Ithaca, NY
:
Industrial Relations Research Association
.
Borjas, G. (
1992
).
National Origin and the Skills of Immigrants
. In Borjas, G.J., & Freeman, R.B. (Eds.),
Immigration and the Work Force
(pp.
17
49
).
Chicago
:
The University of Chicago Press for the National Bureau of Economic Research
.
Boyd, M. (
1988
).
Family and Personal Networks in International Migration
.
International Migration Review
,
23
(
88
),
638
70
.
Carliner, G. (
1980
).
Wages, Earnings and Hours of First, Second, and Third Generation American Males
.
Economic Inquiry
,
18
(
1
),
87
102
. 10.1111/j.1465-7295.1980.tb00561.x
Cattan, P. (
1993
).
The Diversity of Hispanics in the U.S. Work Force
.
Monthly Labor Review
,
116
(
8
),
3
15
.
Chiswick, B.R. (
1978
).
The Effect of Americanization on the Earnings of Foreign-Born Men
.
Journal of Political Economy
,
October
,
897
922
. 10.1086/260717
Chiswick, B.R. (
1979
).
The Economic Progress of Immigrants: Some Apparently Universal Patterns
. In Fellner, W. (Ed.),
Contemporary Economic Problems
(pp.
359
99
).
Washington, DC
:
American Enterprise Institute
.
Chiswick, B.R. (
1980
).
An Analysis of the Economic Progress and Impact of Immigrants
.
Washington, DC
:
National Technical Information Service
.
Economic Report of the President
. (
1996
).
Washington, DC
:
U.S. Government Printing Office
.
DeFreitas, G. 1981. “Occupational Mobility among Recent Black Immigrants.” Pp. 41–47 in Proceedings of the Thirty-Third Annual Winter Meetings, Industrial Relations Research Association.
Duleep, H.O. (
1988
).
The Economic Status of Americans of Asian Descent
.
Washington, DC
:
U.S. Government Printing Office
.
Duleep, H.O. (
1994
).
Social Security and the Emigration of Immigrants
.
Social Security Bulletin
,
57
,
37
52
.
Duleep, H.O. and M.C. Regets. 1992a. “The Elusive Concept of Immigrant Quality: The Borjas/Chiswick Debate Revisited.” Presented at the annual meetings of the North American Economics and Finance Association/Allied Social Science Association held in New Orleans, LA.
Duleep, H.O., & Regets, M.C. (
1992
).
Some Evidence on the Effect of Admission Criteria on Immigrant Assimilation
. In Chiswick, B.R. (Ed.),
Immigration, Language and Ethnic Issues: Canada and the United States
(pp.
410
39
).
Washington, DC
:
American Enterprise Institute
.
Duleep, H.O. and M.C. Regets. 1994a. “The Elusive Concept of Immigrant Quality.” Discussion Paper PRIP-UI-28, Program for Research on Immigration Policy, The Urban Institute.
Duleep, H.O. and M.C. Regets. 1994b. “Country of Origin and Immigrant Earnings.” Program for Research on Immigration Policy, Discussion Paper PRIP-UI-31, Program for Research on Immigration Policy, The Urban Institute.
Duleep, H.O. and M.C. Regets. 1996a. “The Elusive Concept of Immigrant Quality: Evidence from 1970–1990.” Discussion Paper PRIP-UI-41, Program for Research on Immigration Policy, The Urban Institute.
Duleep, H.O., Regets, M.C., & Wunnava, P.V. (
1996
).
Family Unification, Siblings, and Skills
. In Duleep, H. (Ed.),
Immigrants and Immigration Policy: Individual Skills, Family Ties, and Group Identities
(pp.
219
44
).
Greenwich, CT
:
JAI Press
.
Duleep, H.O., & Regets, M.C. (
1996
).
Admission Criteria and Immigrant Earnings Profiles
.
International Migration Review
,
30
(
2
),
571
90
. 10.2307/2547394
Duleep, H.O., & Regets, M.C. (
1997
).
The Decline in Immigrant Entry Earnings: Less Transferable Skills or Lower Ability?
.
Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance
,
37
,
189
208
. 10.1016/S1062-9769(97)90065-X
Duleep, H.O. and M.C. Regets. Forthcoming. “Immigrant Entry Earnings and Human Capital Growth: Evidence from the 1960–1990 Censuses.” Research in Labor Economics 16.
Duleep, H.O., M.C. Regets, and S. Sanders. Forthcoming. Skills, Investment, and Family Ties: A Study of Asian Immigrants, Kalamazoo, MI: Upjohn Institute of Employment Research.
Duleep, H.O., & Sanders, S. (
1993
).
The Decision to Work by Married Immigrant Women
.
Industrial and Labor Relations Review
,
46
,
677
90
. 10.2307/2524311
Duleep, H.O. and P.V. Wunnava. “Introduction and Summary.” Pp. 1–36 in Immigrants and Immigration Policy: Individual Skills, Family Ties, and Group Identities, edited by H. Duleep and P.V. Wunnava. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Enchautegui, M.E. 1996. “Immigration and Wage Changes of High School Dropouts.” Working paper, Immigrant Policy Program, The Urban Institute.
Fawcett, J.T., B.V. Carino, I. Han Park, and R.W. Gardner. 1990. “Selectivity and Diversity: The Effects of U.S. Immigration Policy on Immigrant Characteristics.” Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Population Association of America, held in Toronto, Canada.
Fix, M., & Passel, J.S. (
1994
).
Immigration and Immigrants: Setting the Record Straight
.
Washington, DC
:
The Urban Institute
.
Funkhouser, E., & Trejo, S.J. (
1995
).
The Labor Market Skills of Recent Male Immigrants: Evidence from the Current Population Survey
.
Industrial and Labor Relations Review
,
48
(
4
),
792
811
. 10.2307/2524357
Gallo, C., & Bailey, T.R. (
1996
).
Social Networks and Skills-Based Immigration Policy
. In Duleep, H., & Wunnava, P.V. (Eds.),
Immigrants and Immigration Policy: Individual Skills, Family Ties, and Group Identities
(pp.
203
18
).
Greenwich, CT
:
JAI Press
.
Hill, K. (
1985
).
Indirect Approaches to Assessing Stocks and Flows of Migrants
. In Levine, D.B., Hill, K., & Warren, R. (Eds.),
Immigration Statistics: A Story of Neglect
(pp.
205
224
).
Washington, DC
:
National Academy Press
.
Jasso, G., & Rosenzweig, M.R. (
1982
).
Estimating the Emigration Rates of Legal Immigrants Using Administrative and Survey Data: The 1971 Cohort of Immigrants to the United States
.
Demography
,
19
,
279
90
. 10.2307/2060971
Jasso, G., & Rosenzweig, M.R. (
1989
).
Sponsors, Sponsorship Rates, and the Immigration Multiplier
.
International Migration Review
,
23
(
4
),
856
88
. 10.2307/2546465
Jasso, G., & Rosenzweig, M.R. (
1990
).
The New Chosen People: Immigrants in the United States
.
New York
:
Russell Sage Foundation
.
Jasso, G., & Rosenzweig, M.R. (
1995
).
Do Immigrants Screened for Skills Do Better than Family-Reunification Immigrants?
.
International Migration Review
,
29
(
Spring
),
85
111
. 10.2307/2546998
Katz, A., Teuter, K., & Sidel, P. (
1984
).
Comparison of Alternative Ways of Deriving Panel Data from the Annual Demographic Files of the Current Population Survey
.
Review of Public Data Use
,
12
,
35
4
.
Keely, C.B., & Kraly, E.P. (
1978
).
Recent Net Alien Immigration to the United States: Its Impact on Population Growth and Native Fertility
.
Demography
,
15
,
267
83
. 10.2307/2060650
Kim, K.C., & Hurh, W.M. (
1996
).
Ethnic Resources Utilization of Korean Immigrant Entrepreneurs in the Chicago Minority Area
. In Duleep, H., & Wunnava, P.V. (Eds.),
Immigrants and Immigration Policy: Individual Skills, Family Ties, and Group Identities
(pp.
149
74
).
Greenwich, CT
:
JAI Press
.
Lalonde, R.J., & Topel, R.H. (
1991
).
Immigrants in the American Labor Market: Quality, Assimilation, and Distributional Effects
.
The American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings
,
81
,
297
302
.
Long, J. (
1980
).
The Effect of Americanization on Earnings: Some Evidence for Women
.
Journal of Political Economy
,
88
(
3
),
620
29
. 10.1086/260892
Lowell, B.L. (
1996
).
Skilled and Family-Based Immigration: Principles and Labor Markets
. In Duleep, H., & Wunnava, P.V. (Eds.),
Immigrants and Immigration Policy: Individual Skills, Family Ties, and Group Identities
(pp.
353
72
).
Greenwich, CT
:
JAI Press
.
Meisenheimer, J.R. (
1992
).
How Do Immigrants Fare in the U.S. Labor Market?
.
Monthly Labor Review
,
115
(
12
),
3
19
.
Mincer, J., & Ofek, H. (
1982
).
Interrupted Work Careers: Depreciation and Restoration of Human Capital
.
Journal of Human Resources
,
17
,
1
23
. 10.2307/145520
Mincer, J., & Polachek, S.W. (
1978
).
Women’s Earnings Re-examined
.
Journal of Human Resources
,
13
,
118
34
. 10.2307/145305
Morrissey, M., Mitchell, C., & Rutherford, A. (
1991
).
The Family in the Settlement Process
.
Canberra
:
Australian Government Publishing Service
.
Ngo, H.-Y. (
1994
).
The Economic Role of Immigrant Wives in Hong Kong
.
International Migration
,
32
(
3
),
403
23
. 10.1111/j.1468-2435.1994.tb00162.x
O’Neill, J.A. 1970. The Effect of Income and Education on InterRegional Migration.” Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Department of Economics, Columbia University.
Peracchi, F., & Welch, F. (
1994
).
Trends in Labor Force Transitions of Older Men and Women
.
Journal of Labor Economics
,
12
(
2
),
210
42
. 10.1086/298356
Polachek, S., & Horvath, F. (
1977
).
A Life-Cycle Approach to Migration: Analysis of the Perspicacious Peregrinator
. In Ehrenberg, R. (Ed.),
Research in Labor Economics
(pp.
103
149
).
Greenwich, CT
:
JAI Press
.
Portes, A., & Bach, R.L. (
1985
).
Latin Journey: Cuban and Mexican Immigrants in the United States
.
Berkeley
:
University of California Press
.
Schulte, M.M. and D.A. Wolf. 1994. “Family Networks of the Foreign-Born Population.” Discussion Paper PRIP-UI-35, Program for Research on Immigration Policy, The Urban Institute.
Schultz, TP. 1995. “Immigrant Quality and Assimilation.” Research paper, U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform.
Schultz, T.W. (
1975
).
The Value of the Ability to Deal with Disequilibria
.
Journal of Economic Literature
,
13
(
3
),
827
46
.
Schwartz, A. (
1976
).
Migration, Age and Education
.
Journal of Political Economy
,
84
(
4
),
701
19
. 10.1086/260472
Sehgal, E. (
1985
).
Foreign Born in the U.S. Labor Market: The Results of a Special Survey
.
Monthly Labor Review
,
108
(
7
),
18
24
.
Simon, J.L. and A. Akbari. 1995. “Educational Trends of Immigrants into the United States.” Paper presented at the annual meetings of the Population Association of America, held in San Francisco, CA.
Sjaastad, L.A. (
1962
).
The Costs and Returns of Human Migration
.
The Journal of Political Economy
,
70
,
80
93
. 10.1086/258726
Waldinger, R. (
1986
).
Through the Eye of the Needle: Immigrant Enterprise in New York’s Garment Trades
.
New York
:
New York University Press
.
Warren, R. and E.P Kraly. 1985. “The Elusive Exodus: Emigration from the United States.” Occasional Paper No. 8, Population Reference Bureau.
Warren, R. and J.S. Passel. “A Count of the Uncountable: Estimates of Undocumented Aliens Counted in the 1980 United States Census.“ Demography 24:375–93.
Warren, R., & Peck, J.M. (
1980
).
Foreign-Born Emigration from the United States, 1960–1970
.
Demography
,
17
,
71
84
. 10.2307/2060964
Woodrow-Lafield, K..A. 1994. “Immediate Relatives of Natives and Immigrants to the United States.” Unpublished manuscript. Center for Social and Demographic Analysis, State University of New York at Albany.
Yezer, A.M.J., & Thurston, L. (
1976
).
Migration Patterns and Income Change: Implications for the Human Capital Approach to Migration
.
Southern Economic Journal
,
42
,
693
702
. 10.2307/1056262