Abstract
There is no single calculable welfare effect of an additional person. Rather, there are many different judgments, which may be negative or positive. The welfare effect depends upon the particular economic situation the child will be born into, which point in his life-cycle one refers to, whether he is expected to have a positive effect upon his particular sort of economy and society during and after his lifetime, and most of all, on the kind of welfare criterion used. Furthermore, no matter which welfare criterion is used, the welfare effect of an added individual summarized over time is especially sensitive to the particular assumptions made.
The text of this article is only available as a PDF.
References
Arrow, Kenneth Joseph (
1970
). Social Choice and Individual Values
. 2nd ed.New Haven
: Yale University Press
.Barnett, Harold J., & Chandler, Morse (
1963
). Scarcity and Growth: The Economics of Natural Resource Availability
. Baltimore
: Johns Hopkins Press
.Berry, R Albert, & Ronald, Soligo (
1969
). Some Welfare Aspects of International Migration
. Journal of Political Economy
, 77
, 778
–794
. 10.1086/259562Blandy, Richard (
1974
). The Welfare Analysis of Fertility Reduction
. Economic Journal
, 84
, 109
–129
. 10.2307/2230486Boserup, Ester (
1965
). The Conditions of Agricultural Growth: The Economics of Agrarian Change under Population Pressure
. Chicago
: Aldine Publishing Co
.Brandt, R B. (
1972
). The Morality of Abortion
. The Monist
, 56
, 503
–526
.Carr-Saunders, A. M. (
1922
). The Population Problem: A Study in Human Evolution
. Oxford
: The Clarendon Press
.Coase, R H. (
1960
). The Problem of Social Cost
. Journal of Law and Economics
, 3
, 1
–44
. 10.1086/466560Dasgupta, P. S. (
1969
). On the Concept of Optimum Population
. Review of Economic Studies
, 36
, 295
–318
. 10.2307/2296429Enke, Stephen (
1966
). The Economic Aspects of Slowing Population Growth
. Economic Journal
, 76
, 44
–56
. 10.2307/2229036Friedman, David (
1972
). Laissez-Faire in Populations: The Least Bad Solution. Occasional Paper
. New York
: The Population Council
.Friedman, Milton, & Savage, L. J. (
1952
). The Expected-Utility Hypothesis and the Measurability of Utility
. Journal of Political Economy
, 60
, 463
–474
. 10.1086/257308Gottlieb, Manuel (
1945
). The Theory of Optimum Population for a Closed Economy
. Journal of Political Economy
, 53
, 289
–316
. 10.1086/256283Heer, David M., & Smith, Dean O. (
1968
). Mortality Level, Desired Family Size, and Population Increase
. Demography
, 5
, 104
–121
. 10.2307/2060199Jevons, W. Stanley (
1906
). Flux, A. W.The Coal Question: An Inquiry Concerning the Progress of the Nation and the Probable Exhaustion of Our Coal-Mines
. 3rd edLondon
: Macmillan and Co. Limited
.Krzywicki, Ludwik (
1934
). Primitive Society and Its Vital Statistics
. London
: MacMillan
.Kuznets, Simon (
1960
). Population Change and Aggregate Output. 1960
Universities-National Bureau of Economic Research, Demographic and Economic Change in Developed Countries
(pp. 324
–340
). Princeton
: Princeton University Press
.May, David A., & Heer, David M. (
1968
). Son Survivorship Motivation and Family Size in India: A Computer Simulation
. Population Studies
, 22
, 199
–210
. 10.2307/2173019Meade, James Edward (
1955
). The Theory of International Economic Policy
. New York
: Oxford University Press
.Mirrlees, James A. (
1972
). Population Policy and the Taxation of Family Size
. Journal of Public Economics
, 1
, 169
–198
. 10.1016/0047-2727(72)90001-1Narveson, Jan (
1967
). Utilitarianism and the New Generations
. Mind
, 76
, 62
–72
. 10.1093/mind/LXXVI.301.62Narveson, Jan (
1973
). Moral Problems of Population
. The Monist
, 57
, 62
–86
.Phelps, Edmund S. (
1968
). Population Increase
. Canadian Journal of Economics
, 1
, 497
–518
. 10.2307/133749Sen, Amartya Kumar (
1961
). On Optimising the Rate of Saving
. Economic Journal
, 71
, 479
–496
. 10.2307/2228914Simon, Julian (
1974
). The Effects of Income upon Fertility
. Chapel Hill
: Carolina Population Center
.Simon, Julian (
1975
). The Economics of Population Growth
. Princeton
: Princeton University Press. Forthcoming
.Stearns, J. Brenton (
1972
). Ecology and the Indefinite Unborn
. The Monist
, 56
, 612
–625
.Votey, Harold L. (
1969
). The Optimum Population and Growth: A New Look. A Modification to Include a Preference for Children in the Welfare Function
. Journal of Economic Theory
, 1
, 273
–290
. 10.1016/0022-0531(69)90034-9Weckstein, Richard S. (
1962
). Welfare Criteria and Changing Tastes
. American Economic Review
, 52
, 133
–153
.© Population Association of America 1975
1975
Issue Section:
Articles
