Abstract

During the 1960’s and continuing into the 1970’s, the charge that birth control and abortion are integral elements of a white genocidal conspiracy directed against Afro-Americans has been heard with increasing frequency and stridency in black communities. The genocide theory finds greatest acceptance among spokesmen for black nationalist and black revolutionary groups, but suspicion of family planning programs is not limited to them. An analysis of black leadership opinion on birth control is provided in this paper. The black debate over the desirability of population limitation is traced back approximately fifty years. It began with a dispute between those blacks who believed that in sheer numbers there was strength and those blacks, such as W. E. B. DuBois, who argued that among human races, as among vegetables, quality and not quantity counted. An appreciation of the sexual exploitation of the chattel slave in the ante-bellum period, which did not end with emancipation, is also essential to an understanding of the roots and rationale of the genocide notion which are the foci of this paper.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

References

Abubakari, Dara (
1972
).
The Black Woman Is Liberated In Her Own Mind
. In Gerda Lerner (Ed.),
Black Women in White America—A Documentary History
(pp.
585
587
).
New York
:
Pantheon Books
.
Anonymous, and Thomas H. Jones. 1871. The Experience of Thomas H. Jones Who Was A Slave for Forty-Three Years. New Bedford: E. Anthony and Sons.
Attah, Ernest B. 1972. Racial Aspects of Zero Population Growth: Some Perspectives With Demographic Models. A paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Population Association of America, Toronto, April, 1972.
Bancroft, Frederick (
1931
).
Slave-Trading in the Old South
.
Baltimore
:
J. H. Furst Co
.
Ben-Gurion, David (
1971
).
Israel—A Personal History
.
New York
:
Funk and Wagnalls, Inc.
.
Bibb, Henry (
1850
).
Narrative of the Life and Times of Henry Bibb, An American Slave
.
New York
:
Published by the Author
.
Black Man, The. November 1934.
Black Panther, The. 4 January 1969; 4 July 1970; 10 April 1971; 8 May 1971.
(
1970
).
Statement on Birth Control
. In Robin Morgan (Ed.),
Sisterhood is Powerful
(pp.
360
361
).
New York
:
Vintage Books
.
Blake, Margaret Jane (
1897
).
Memoirs of Margaret Jane Blake of Baltimore, Maryland
.
Philadelphia
:
Press of Innes and Son
.
Bogue, Donald J. (
1970
).
Family Planning in the Negro Ghettos of Chicago
.
Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly
,
48
,
283
299
. 10.2307/3349123
Brown, H. Rap (
1969
).
Die Nigger Die
.
New York
:
The Dial Press
.
Carter, Elmer A. (
1932
).
Eugenics for the Negro
.
Birth Control Review
,
16
,
169
170
.
Chisholm, Shirley (
1971
).
Unbought and Unbossed
.
New York
:
Avon Books
.
Cobb, W. Montague (
1939
).
The Negro as a Biological Element in the American Population
.
Journal of Negro Education
,
8
,
336
348
. 10.2307/2292634
Cowles, Wylda B. 1962. Memo to Dr. Alan F. Guttmacher concerning the Interview with Malcolm X, May 29, 1962.
Cowles, Wylda B..1966. Memo to Dr. Alan F. Guttmacher concerning meeting with E.R.O.S. in Berkeley, California on February 23, 1966.
Crisis, (
1970
).
Planned Parenthood
.
Crisis
,
77
,
78
79
.
Curtin, Philip D. (
1969
).
The Atlantic Slave Trade—A Census
.
Madison
:
University of Wisconsin Press
.
Darity, William A., Castellano B. Turner, and Jean H. Thiebaux. 1971. An Exploratory Study on Barriers to Family Planning: Race Consciousness and Fears of Black Genocide as a Basis. A paper presented at the Ninth Annual Meeting of the American Association of Planned Parenthood Physicians, Kansas City, Missouri, April, 1971.
Dubois, W. E. B. (
1922
).
Birth
.
Crisis
,
24
,
248
250
.
Dubois, W. E. B. (
1932
).
Black Folk and Birth Control
.
Birth Control Review
,
16
,
166
167
.
Ehrlich, Paul R. (
1971
).
The Population Bomb
.
New York
:
Ballantine Books
.
Essence. 1971. Conversation: Jesse Jackson and Marcia Gillespie. Essence (July 25).
Farrakhan, Minister Louis. 1972. The Black Woman. Essence (January).
Frazier, E. Franklin (
1945
).
Birth Control for More Negro Babies
.
Negro Digest
,
3
,
41
44
.
Garvey, Marcus (
1967
).
Philosophy and Opinions of Marcus Garvey
.
London
:
Frank Cass and Company
.
Goodell, William (
1969
).
The American Slave Code in Theory and Practice
.
New York
:
The New American Library
.
Goodman Benjamin (
1971
).
Malcolm X, the End of White World Supremacy—Four Speeches
.
New York
:
Merlin House, Inc.
.
Gregory, Dick (
1971
).
My Answer to Genocide
.
Ebony
,
26
(
12
),
66
72
.
Himes, Norman E. (
1936
).
Medical History of Contraceptions
.
Baltimore
:
The Williams and Wilkins Co.
.
Hughes, Langston. 1965. Population Explosion. New York Post, December 10, 1965.
Jones, Carolyn (
1970
).
Abortion and Black Women
.
Black America
,
1
,
48
49
.
Jordan, Winthrop D. (
1968
).
White Over Black—American Attitudes toward the Negro 1550–1812
.
Chapel Hill
:
University of North Carolina Press.
.
Kahlil, Brother. 1971. Eugenics, Birth Control and the Black Man. Black News (January 14): 20–21.
King, Martin Luther, Jr. n.d. Family Planning —A Special Urgent Concern. New York: Planned Parenthood-World Population.
Kiser, Clyde V. (
1935
).
Fertility of Harlem Negroes
.
Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly
,
13
,
273
285
. 10.2307/3347964
Lester, Julius (
1969
).
Birth Control and Blacks
Revolutionary Notes
(pp.
140
143
).
New York
:
Richard W. Baron
.
Lewis, Julian (
1945
).
Can the Negro Afford Birth Control
.
Negro Digest
,
3
,
19
22
.
Lewis, Julian. 1954. Is Birth Control A Menace To Negroes? Jet (August 19):52–55.
Lincoln, Richard (
1970
).
July 1970 Senate Bill 2108
.
Capitol Hill Debates the Future of Population and Family Planning
,
2
(
1
),
6
12
.
Lipson, Gerald, & Wolman, Dianne (
1972
).
Polling Americans on Birth Control and Population
.
Family Planning Perspectives
,
4
,
39
42
. 10.2307/2133674
Moore, Emily C. n.d. Native American Indian Values: Their Relation to Suggested Population Policy Proposals. Unpublished report to the Commission on Population Growth and the American Future. U. S. Commission on Population Growth and the American Future.
Morsell, John. 1972. Private communication with the Author, April 24, 1972.
Muhammad, Elijah. 1965. Message to the Blackman in America. Chicago: Muhammad Mosque of Islam No.2.
Muhammad Speaks. 11 October 1968; 29 August 1969; 31 May 1969; 23 May 1969; 24 January 1969; 20 November 1970; and 3 January 1971.
New York Post. 7 October 1968.
New York Times. 23 May 1971; 26, 27, 28 July 1972; 8, 9 August 1972.
Noonan, John T. (
1967
).
Contraception—A History of Its Treatment by the Catholic Theologians and Canonists
.
New York
:
Mentor-Omega
.
William L. Patterson (
1970
).
We Charge Genocide—The Historic Petition To The United Nations for Relief From a Crime of the United States Government Against the Negro People
.
New York
:
International Publishers
.
Paul, Julius (
1968
).
The Return of Punitive Sterilization Programs—Current Attacks on Illegitimacy and the AFDC Program
.
Law and Society Review
,
111
(
1
),
90
90
.
Pearl, Raymond (
1936
).
Fertility and Contraception in Urban Whites and Negroes
.
Science
,
83
,
503
506
. 10.1126/science.83.2160.503
Pittsburgh Courier. 14 April 1947; 29 March 1947; 24 August 1968.
Pittsburgh Press. 21 August 1968; 15 August 1968.
Puckett, Niles N. (
1968
).
Folk Beliefs of the Southern Negro
.
New York
:
Negro Universities Press
.
Rice, Thurman B. (
1929
).
Racial Hygiene—A Practical Discussion of Eugenics and Race Culture
.
New York
:
Macmillan Company
.
Sanders, Thomas G. 1970. Opposition to Family Planning in Latin America: The Non-Marxist Left. American Universities Field Staff Reports. West Coast South America Series XVII, No.5.
Sanger, Margaret (
1938
).
Margaret Sanger: An Autobiography
.
New York
:
W. W. Norton and Company Publishers
.
Schuyler, George S. (
1932
).
Quantity or Quality
.
Birth Control Review
,
16
,
165
166
.
Seibels, Robert E. (
1941
).
A Rural Project in Negro Maternal Health
.
Human Fertility
,
6
,
42
44
.
Smith, Mary (
1968
).
Birth Control and the Negro Woman
.
Ebony
,
23
(
5
),
29
37
.
Tannenbaum, Frank (
1946
).
Slave and Citizen: The Negro in the Americas
.
New York
:
Vintage Press
.
Warwick, Donald P., and Nancy Williamson. 1971. Population Policy and Spanish Speaking Americans. Unpublished report to the Commission on Population Growth and the American Future. U. S. Commission on Population Growth and the American Future.
Watts, Daniel H. 1969. Birth Control. Liberator (May, 1969).
Westoff, Charles F. (
1972
).
The Modernization of U. S. Contraceptive Practice
.
Family Planning Perspectives
,
4
,
9
12
. 10.2307/2133932
Williams, Maxine, & Newman, Pamela (
1971
).
Black Women’s Liberation, Second Ed
.
New York
:
Pathfinder Press, Inc.
.
Woodside, Moya (
1950
).
Sterilization in North Carolina: A Sociological and Psychological Study
.
Chapel Hill
:
University of North Carolina Press
.
Yette, Samuel F. (
1971
).
The Choice: The Issue of Black Survival in America
.
New York
:
G. P. Putnam’s Sons
.