This essay provides a new interpretation of the major methodological movements in literary scholarship since World War II, especially in the United States. The overarching claim is that these movements comprise displaced repetitions of moments in the early modern mourning for lost absolutes (the “death of God”), a mourning that, as the recent “return of religion” reveals, is far from complete. In the history of the secularization of reason in the West, the rationalist and empiricist traditions constitute the two main (and opposing) forms in which reason attempts to mourn for God, and to replace him. The essay argues that rationalism involves a melancholic gesture, whose structural representative in Freudian terms is obsessive-compulsive discourse. Empiricism, in turn, arises as a manic phase of attempted (and failed) mourning, stabilized in what will come to be known as hysteria. Contemporary theory has taken shape in and around these two modes of response to the disappearance of the absolute addressee. The four movements considered are New Criticism, structuralism (and post-structuralism), New Historicism (and Cultural Studies), and what I call the “New Vitalism” (represented here by Giorgio Agamben and Slavoj Žižek). The essay initially understands New Criticism as focused on formal traits, (post)structuralism as concerned mainly with epistemology, New Historicism/Cultural Studies as privileging history, and the New Vitalism as seeking the realization of the subject. Going beyond this initial, standard determination, the essay characterizes each movement in terms of the concepts provided by all of them, on the assumption that the “totality” of these movements cannot be exceeded at this time, but that it can be displaced by being relativized through such a description. As a result, New Criticism appears as ironic in its privileged representational mode, criticist (in the Kantian sense) in its epistemology and aesthetics, aestheticist in literary-historical or history of ideas terms, and phobic in psychoanalytic terms. The (post)structuralist moment appears formally as allegorical, philosophically as rationalist, historically as akin to Enlightenment, and psychoanalytically as obsessional. New Historicism and Cultural Studies embrace (despite appearances) a symbolist mode of presentation and an empiricist epistemology, recapitulate the literary-historical tendencies of realism, and take, in psychoanalytic terms, a hysterical stance. The New Vitalism, finally, has faith in polemic as its privileged mode of presentation, takes a neo-idealist position philosophically, echoes neo-Romantic vitalisms of the late nineteenth century, and positions itself as perverse in psychoanalytic terms. Where critical theory goes from here remains an open question. Completion of mourning for the socially sanctioned delusion we still evidently have difficulty doing without remains a methodological desideratum.

This content is only available as a PDF.

Works Cited

Works Cited
Abraham, Karl.
“A Short Study of the Development of the Libido, Viewed in the Light of Mental Disorders,” Part 1, section 1, “Melancholia and Obsessional Neurosis.”
Selected Papers of Karl Abraham
. Trans. Bryan, Douglas; Strachey, Alix. Intro. Jones, Ernest.
London
:
Hogarth Press
,
1948
.
422
33
.
Print
.
Abrams, M.H.
“Coleridge, Baudelaire, and Modernist Poetics.”
Immanente Ästhetik, Ästhetische Reflexion: Lyrik als Paradigma der Moderne
. Ed. Iser. Poetik, W.; Hermeneutik, ,
Arbeitsergebnisse einer Forschungsgruppe II
.
Munich
:
Wilhelm Fink
,
1966
.
113
38
.
Print
.
Agamben, Giorgio.
Homo Sacer: Sovereign Power and Bare Life
. Trans. Heller-Roazen, Daniel.
Stanford
:
Stanford UP
,
1998
.
Print
.
Apollon, Willy; Bergeron, Danielle; Cantin, Lucie.
After Lacan: Clinical Practice and the Subject of the Unconscious
. Ed. Hughes, Robert; Malone, Kareen Ror.
Albany
:
SUNY Press
,
2002
.
Print
.
Arac, Jonathan.
“Rereading ‘Literary History and Literary Modernity’: Paul de Man's Ambivalence.”
Time and the Literary: Essays from the English Institute
. Ed. Newman, Karen; Clayton, Jay; Hirsch, Marianne.
New York
:
Routledge
,
2002
.
121
44
.
Print
.
Badiou, Alain.
“The Adventure of French Philosophy.”
New Left Review
35
(
Sept.–Oct.
2005
):
67
77
.
Print
.
———.
Metapolitics
.
London
:
Verso
,
2005
.
Print
.
———.
Saint Paul: or the Foundations of Universalism
.
Stanford
:
Stanford UP
,
2003
.
Print
.
Barthes, Roland.
“From ‘Work’ to ‘Text.’”
Image Music Text
. Ed. and trans. Heath, Stephen.
New York
:
Hill and Wang
,
1977
.
155
64
.
Print
.
Benjamin, Walter.
“Über einige Motive bei Baudelaire.”
Illuminationen
.
Frankfurt am Main
:
Suhrkamp
,
1961
.
201
45
.
Print
.
Berlant, Lauren.
“Slow Death (Sovereignty, Obesity, Lateral Agency).”
Critical Inquiry
33
.
4
(
2007
):
754
80
.
Print
.
Birnbaum, Antonia.
Le vertige d'une pensée: Descartes corps et âme
.
Lyon
:
Horslieu éditions
,
2003
.
Print
.
Blumenberg, Hans.
The Legitimacy of the Modern Age
. Trans. Wallace, Robert M..
Cambridge
:
MIT Press
,
1983
.
Print
.
Bowman, Paul; Stamp, Richard, eds.
The Truth of Žižek
.
London
:
Continuum
,
2007
.
Print
.
Brooks, Cleanth.
“Irony as a Principle of Structure.”
Critical Theory Since Plato
. Ed. Adams, Hazard.
New York
:
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
,
1971
.
1041
48
.
Print
.
———.
The Well-Wrought Urn: Studies in the Structure of Poetry
.
New York
:
Harcourt, Brace
,
1947
.
Print
.
Culler, Jonathan.
Flaubert: The Uses of Uncertainty
.
London
:
Elek
,
1974
.
Print
.
———.
Structuralist Poetics: Structuralism, Linguistics, and the Study of Literature
.
Ithaca
:
Cornell UP
,
1975
.
Print
.
Dean, Jodi.
Žižek's Politics
.
New York
:
Routledge
,
2006
.
Print
.
De Man, Paul.
Allegories of Reading: Figural Language in Rousseau, Nietzsche, Rilke, and Proust
.
New Haven
:
Yale UP
,
1979
.
Print
.
———.
Blindness and Insight: Essays in the Rhetoric of Contemporary Criticism
. 2nd ed.
Minneapolis
:
U of Minnesota P
,
1983
.
Print
.
———.
The Resistance to Theory
.
Minneapolis
:
U of Minnesota P
,
1986
.
Print
.
———.
The Rhetoric of Romanticism
.
New York
:
Columbia UP
,
1984
.
Print
.
Descartes, René.
Discourse on Method and Meditations on First Philosophy
. Trans. Cress, Donald A.. 4th ed.
Indianapolis
:
Hackett Publishing
,
1998
.
Print
.
Dor, Joël.
The Clinical Lacan
.
New York
:
Other Press
,
1999
.
Print
.
Eagleton, Terry.
Literary Theory: An Introduction
.
Minneapolis
:
U of Minnesota P
,
1983
.
Print
.
Eliot, T.S.
Selected Essays
.
New York
:
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
,
1978
.
Print
.
Fletcher, Angus.
Allegory: The Theory of a Symbolic Mode
.
Ithaca
:
Cornell UP
,
1964
.
Print
.
Flowers, Ronald B.
“Everson at 6o.”
Church and State
60
.
1
(
Jan.
2007
). Web. <http://www.au.org/media/church-and-state/archives/2007/01/emeversonem.html>.
Freud, Sigmund.
Studienausgabe
.
12 Vols
. Ed. Mitscherlich, Alexander et al.
Frankfurt am Main
:
Fischer Taschenbuch Verlag
,
1982
.
Print
.
Gleckner, Robert F.; Enscoe, Gerald E., eds.
Romanticism: Points of View
.
Detroit
:
Wayne State UP
,
1975
.
Print
.
Grossberg, Lawrence; Nelson, Cary; Treichler, Paul A., eds.
Cultural Studies
.
New York
:
Routledge
,
1992
.
Print
.
Hamburger, Philip.
Separation of Church and State
.
Cambridge
:
Harvard UP
,
2002
.
Print
.
Hartman, Geoffrey.
“Structuralism: The Anglo-American Adventure.”
Beyond Formalism: Literary Essays 1958–1970
.
New Haven
:
Yale UP
,
1970
.
3
24
.
Print
.
Hertz, Neil.
“Lurid Figures.”
Reading De Man Reading
. Ed. Waters, Lindsay; Godzich, Wlad.
Minneapolis
:
U of Minnesota P
,
1981
.
82
104
.
Print
.
Jameson, Fredric.
The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially Symbolic Act
.
Ithaca
:
Cornell UP
,
1981
.
Print
.
Jancovich, Mark.
The Cultural Politics of the New Criticism
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge UP
,
1993
.
Print
.
Johnston, Adrian.
“From the Spectacular Act to the Vanishing Act: Badiou, Žižek, and the Politics of Lacanian Theory.”
International Journal of Žižek Studies
1
(
2007
):
1
40
.
Print
.
Johnston, Kenneth R. et al, eds.
Romantic Revolutions: Criticism and Theory
.
Bloomington
:
Indiana UP
,
1990
.
Print
.
Juergensmeyer, Mark.
Terror in the Mind of God: The Global Rise of Religious Violence
.
Berkeley
:
U of California P
,
2000
.
Print
.
Kant, Immanuel.
Critique of Pure Reason
. Trans. Smith, Norman Kemp.
New York
:
St. Martin's Press
,
1965
.
Print
.
Kosellek, Reinhart.
Kritik und Krise: eine Studie zur Pathogenese der bürgerlichen Welt
.
Frankfurt
:
Suhrkamp
,
1973
.
Print
.
Lacan, Jacques.
The Seminar of Jacques Lacan. Book 2. The Ego in Freud's Theory and in the Technique of Psychoanalysis, 1954–1955
. Ed. Miller, Jacques-Alain. Trans. Tomaselli, Sylvana. Notes Forrester, John.
New York
:
W.W. Norton
,
1988
.
Print
.
Laclau, Ernesto.
Emancipation(s)
.
New York
:
Verso
,
1996
.
Print
.
Lentricchia, Frank.
After the New Criticism
.
Chicago
:
U of Chicago P
,
1980
.
Print
.
LeSage, Laurent.
The French New Criticism: An Introduction and a Sampler
.
University Park
:
Pennsylvania State UP
,
1967
.
Print
.
Librett, Jeffrey S.
“From the Sacrifice of the Letter to the Voice of Testimony: Giorgio Agamben's Fulfillment of Metaphysics.”
Taking Exception to the Exception
. Ed. Frank, Jason; McNulty, Tracy.
Spec. issue of Diacritics
37
.
2–3
(
2007
):
11
33
.
Print
.
———.
“Introduction — Reason Split into Rationalism and Empiricism: Divergent Traditions on the Borderline.”
Borderlines in Psychoanalysis, Borderlines of Psychoanalysis
.
Spec. issue of Konturen
3
(
2010
):
162
85
. Web. <http.//Konturen.uoregon.edu>.
MacCannell, Juliet Flower.
The Hysteric's Guide to the Future Female Subject
.
Minneapolis
:
U of Minnesota P
,
2000
.
Print
.
Maclear, J.F.
Church and State in the Modern Age: A Documentary History
.
New York
:
Oxford UP
,
1995
.
Print
.
McGann, Jerome.
The Romantic Ideology: A Critical Investigation
.
Chicago
:
U of Chicago P
,
1983
.
Print
.
Moore-Gilbert, Bart.
Postcolonial Theory: Contexts, Practices, Politics
.
London
:
Verso
,
1997
.
Print
.
Nietzsche, Friedrich.
Thus Spake Zarathustra
. Trans. Common, Thomas. Revised with introduction and notes, James Birx, H..
Amherst
:
Prometheus
,
1993
.
Print
.
Oaks, Dallin H., ed.
The Wall Between Church and State
.
Chicago
:
U of Chicago P
,
1963
.
Print
.
Piaget, Jean.
Structuralism
. Trans. Maschler, Chaninah.
New York
:
Basic Books
,
1970
.
Print
.
Said, Edward.
The Edward Said Reader
. Ed. Bayoumi, Moustafa; Rubin, Andrew.
New York
:
Vintage
,
2000
.
Print
.
Siebers, Tobin.
Cold War Criticism and the Politics of Skepticism
.
Oxford
:
Oxford UP
,
1993
.
Print
.
Sorauf, Frank J.
The Wall of Separation: the Constitutional Politics of Church and State
.
Princeton
:
Princeton UP
,
1976
.
Print
.
Sørensen, Bengt Algot.
Allegorie und Symbol: Texte zur Theorie des dichterischen Bildes im 18. und frühen 19. Jahrhundert
.
Frankfurt am Main
:
Athenäum
,
1972
.
Print
.
Stevens, Jason W.
God-Fearing and Free: A Spiritual History of America's Cold War
.
Cambridge
:
Harvard UP
,
2010
.
Print
.
Veeser, H. Aram, ed.
The New Historicism
.
New York
:
Routledge
,
1989
.
Print
.
Vogt, Eric.
“Exception in Žižek's Thought.”
Taking Exception to the Exception
. Ed. Frank, Jason; McNulty, Tracy.
Spec. issue of Diacritics
37
.
2–3
(
2007
):
61
77
.
Print
.
———.
“Schmittian Traces in Žižek's Political Theology (and Some Derridian Specters).”
Diacritics
36
.
1
(
2006
):
14
29
.
Print
.
Žižek, Slavoj.
On Belief
.
London
:
Routledge
,
2001
.
Print
.
———.
The Puppet and the Dwarf: The Perverse Core of Christianity
.
Cambridge
:
MIT Press
,
2003
.
Print
.
———.
Tarrying with the Negative: Kant, Hegel, and the Critique of Ideology
.
Durham
:
Duke UP
,
1993
.
Print
.
———.
The Ticklish Subject: The Absent Centre of Political Ontology
.
London
:
Verso
,
1999
.
Print
.
Zorach, Rebecca.
“Love, Truth, Orthodoxy, Reticence: or, What Edgar Wind Didn't See in Botticelli's Primavera.”
Critical Inquiry
34
.
1
(
2007
):
190
224
.
Print
.