W. G. Sebald is one of the most original and significant authors of the twentieth century, but these credentials only make The Rings of Saturn that much more disappointing. In his other novels, Sebald’s drift between landscapes and encyclopedic fragments emerged out of a deep necessity and constituted an ingenious literary innovation. But here this style exists in a void. When an author becomes enslaved to his own style, when form is empty of content, the result is not merely boring. In his previous books, Sebald was a great writer of the German trauma, but in The Rings of Saturn he makes that national trauma banal.
Sebald or Gevalt?
Nissim Calderon is Professor Emeritus in the Department of Hebrew Literature at Ben-Gurion University, Be’er Sheva, Israel. He has published extensively on contemporary Hebrew literature, poetry, and music, and the relationship between them.Shir Alon is assistant professor of Middle Eastern studies at the University of Minnesota. She has published scholarly articles in Arab Studies Journal, Comparative Literature, Jewish Social Studies, and boundary 2. Her book manuscript explores the challenges of writing the present in modern Arabic and Hebrew literatures.
Nissim Calderon, Shir Alon; Sebald or Gevalt?. boundary 2 1 August 2020; 47 (3): 165–168. doi: https://doi.org/10.1215/01903659-8524467
Download citation file: