Book Chapter
BONAFIDE 'til I Can't No More: “Old Town Road” as the Endpoint of a Century of Genre and Chart Evolution
-
Published:October 2023
This content is made freely available by the publisher. It may not be redistributed or altered. All rights reserved.
The book's introduction places “Old Town Road” in context as a singular chart phenomenon and considers its value as both a piece of music and a pop artifact. An opening anecdote from a grade-school gymnasium reveals the depth of popularity of Lil Nas X's song with audiences of all ages. The song's run at No. 1 on the Hot 100 was longer than the biggest hits by many pop titans, raising the question of whether “Old Town Road” was a fluke. The introduction makes the case that the song is part of a long lineage of metatextual, self-referential pop hits that reset the idea of “cool” for a new generation. The song's great contribution was revealing what we value as a culture.
This content is only available as PDF.
Bibliography
Ahlgrim
, Callie
. “Billy Ray Cyrus Says Lil Nas X Only Knew He Made Country Music because of ‘Hannah Montana.’
” Business Insider
, January
31
, 2020
.Aku
, Timmhotep
. “Brooklyn Rapper Bobby Shmurda Goes from Vine Star to Major-Label Player
.” Billboard
, August
26
, 2014
.Asker
, Jim
. “Chart Rewind: In 1962, Ray Charles’ ‘Stop’ Started Its No. 1 Hot 100 Run
.” Billboard
, June
2
, 2022
.Atwood
, Brett
. “The History of the Music Industry's First-Ever Digital Single for Sale, 20 Years after Its Release
.” Billboard
, September
13
, 2017
.Bastone
, Nick
. “TikTok Was the Most-Downloaded App in the US in September
.” Business Insider
, November
2
, 2018
.Battan
, Carrie
. “‘Old Town Road’ and the Overdue Death of Genre
.” New Yorker
, April
8
, 2019
.Burns
, Ken
. Country Music
(miniseries). pbs, 2019
.Carmichael
, Rodney
. “Wrangler on His Booty: Lil Nas X on the Making and the Magic of ‘Old Town Road.’
” npr Music
, April
10
, 2019
.Chow
, Andrew R.
“Lil Nas X Talks ‘Old Town Road’ and the Billboard Controversy
.” Time
, April
5
, 2019
.Chow
, Andrew R.
“Inside Lil Nas X's Record-Breaking, Culture-Changing Summer
.” Time
, August
15
, 2019
.Coroneos
, Kyle
(“Trigger”). “Billboard Must Remove Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ from Country Chart
.” Saving Country Music
(blog), March
23
, 2019
.Coscarelli
, Joe
. “‘Old Town Road’: See How Memes and Controversy Took Lil Nas X to the Top of the Charts
.” New York Times
, May
10
, 2019
.Cuby
, Michael
. “Lil Nas X Praised Frank Ocean and Tyler, the Creator for Making It Easier for Queer Artists
.” Them
, December
5
, 2020
.DeVille
, Chris
. “Justin Bieber Hops on Billie Eilish's ‘Bad Guy.’
” Stereogum
, July
11
, 2019
.Düren
, Breanne
. “Interview with Steve Bursky, Manager at Foundations for Owl City
.” Hit Quarters
, July
11
, 2011
.Feldman
, Brian
, Dee
Lockett
, et al “The 23 Most Important Vines of All Time
.” Vulture
, October
28
, 2016
.Frank
, Allegra
. “Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ Is a Banger. But Is It Country? Depends on Whom You Ask
.” Vox
, April
5
, 2019
.Frank
, Allegra
. “Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ Music Video Is a Time-Traveling Western
.” Vox
, May
17
, 2019
.Ghosh
, Devarati
. “The Meaningless Florida-Georgia Line Billboard Country Songs Record: Who Really Has the Biggest Country Hit?
” MJ's Big Blog
, August
2
, 2013
.Gracie
, Bianca
. “tlc's ‘FanMail’ Turns 20: A Track-by-Track Retrospective with the Girl Group and Behind-the-Scenes Collaborators
.” Billboard
, February
22
, 2019
.Hong
, Euny
. The Birth of Korean Cool: How One Nation Is Conquering the World through Pop Culture
. New York
: Picador
, 2014
.Hughes
, Charles
. Country Soul: Making Music and Making Race in the American South
. Chapel Hill
: University of North Carolina Press
, 2015
.Hughes
, Jazmine
. “The Subversive Joy of Lil Nas X's Gay Pop Stardom
.” New York Times Magazine
, July
7
, 2021
.Jacobs
, Julia
. “Lil Nas X Comes Out on Last Day of Pride Month
.” New York Times
, July
1
, 2019
.Jones
, Jonathan
. “Red Dead Redemption 2 Critiques White History for an Audience Susceptible to Alt-Right Ideology
.” Slate
, February
4
, 2019
.Kim
, Michelle Hyun
. “How Solange and Mitski Reconsider Who Can Be the Cowboy
.” Pitchfork
, March
21
, 2019
.King
, Gayle
. “Lil Nas X Opens Up about the Difficulties of Coming Out: ‘We Still Have a Long Way to Go.’
” cbs News, September
30
, 2019
.King
, Gayle
. “Lil Nas X Takes Gayle King inside the Studio Where He Recorded ‘Old Town Road.’
” cbs News, September
30
, 2019
.Lamarre
, Carl
. “‘Old Town Road’ Producer YoungKio on How Lil Nas X's Song Came to Life
.” Billboard
, March
28
, 2019
.Lawrence
, Keith
. “Arnold Shultz: The Greatest (?) Guitar Picker's Life Ended before Promise Realized
.” ibma Foundation website, October
22
, 2020
.Leight
, Elias
. “Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ Was a Country Hit. Then Country Changed Its Mind
.” Rolling Stone
, March
26
, 2019
.Leight
, Elias
. “Fueled by Controversy, Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ Is on a Record-Breaking Run
.” Rolling Stone
, April
17
, 2019
.Lewis
, Randy
. “Record Producer Was Godfather of r&b
.” Los Angeles Times
, August
16
, 2008
.Lewry
, Fraser
. “The Day Aerosmith Changed the Internet as We Know It
.” Classic Rock
, June
27
, 2022
.Lockett
, Dee
. “Everything You Need to Know about the ‘Shmoney Dance.’
” Slate
, July
15
, 2014
.Martin
, Rachel
. “Lil Nas X, Country Music's Unlikely Son, Sparks Conversation on Genre and Race
.” kcur-npr Kansas City, May
23
, 2019
.McGraw
, Tim
, and Jon
Meacham
. “Country Music Should Be Political. After All, It Always Has Been
.” Time
, August
15
, 2019
.McKinley
, James C.
, Jr. “Billboard's Changes to Charts Draw Fire
.” New York Times
, October
26
, 2012
.McKinney
, Kelsey
. “A Hit Song Is Usually 3 to 5 Minutes Long. Here's Why
.” Vox
, January
30
, 2015
.Nodjimbadem
, Katie
. “The Lesser-Known History of African-American Cowboys
.” Smithsonian
, February
13
, 2017
.Pearce
, Sheldon
. “How Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ Became a Lightning Rod for Race, the Charts, and Country Music
.” Pitchfork
, April
1
, 2019
.Pecknold
, Diane
. Hidden in the Mix: The African American Presence in Country Music
. Durham, NC
: Duke University Press
, 2013
.Petrusich
, Amanda
. “Lil Nas X Is the Sound of the Internet, Somehow
.” New Yorker
, June
24
, 2019
.Petrusich
, Amanda
. “Genre Is Disappearing. What Comes Next?
” New Yorker
, March
8
, 2021
.Reese
, Ashley
. “What Everyone Is Getting Wrong about the ‘Yee Haw Agenda,’ according to Bri Malandro, the Woman Who Coined the Term
.” Jezebel
, March
27
, 2019
.Royster
, Francesca T.
Black Country Music: Listening for Revolutions
. Austin
: University of Texas Press
, 2022
.Scott
, Jason
. “Billboard, Stop the Use of Multi-format Airplay in Determining ‘Hit’ Country, r&b, Rock Songs
.” Change.org, October
12
, 2012
.Sisario
, Ben
. “Lil Nas X Added Billy Ray Cyrus to ‘Old Town Road.’ Is It Country Enough for Billboard Now?
” New York Times
, April
5
, 2019
.Strauss
, Neil
. “Hit Makers Warily Explore the Computer Frontier
.” New York Times
, July
6
, 1994
.Tingen
, Paul
. “Inside Track: Lil Nas X ft Billy Ray Cyrus ‘Old Town Road.’
” Sound on Sound
, August
2019
.Trust
, Gary
. “Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ Leaps to No. 1 on Billboard Hot 100
.” Billboard
, April
8
, 2019
.Trust
, Gary
. “Lil Nas X's ‘Old Town Road’ Debuts on Country Airplay, Driven by Morning Show Spins
.” Billboard
, April
9
, 2019
.Weisbard
, Eric
. To p 40 Democracy: The Rival Mainstreams of American Music
. Chicago
: University of Chicago Press
, 2014
.Whitburn
, Joel
. Top Country Singles 1944–2017
. Menomenee Falls, WI
: Record Research
, 2018
.Whitburn
, Joel
. Top Pop Singles 1955–2018
. Menomenee Falls, WI
: Record Research
, 2019
.Whitburn
, Joel
. Top r&b Singles 1942–2016
. Menomenee Falls, WI
: Record Research
, 2017
.Witt
, Stephen
. How Music Got Free: A Story of Obsession and Invention
. New York
: Penguin
, 2016
.Zellner
, Xander
. “Spurred by a TikTok Meme, Lil Nas X Scores First Hot 100 Hit with ‘Old Town Road.’
” Billboard
, March
13
, 2019
.Zoladz
, Lindsay
. “ ‘Old Town Road’ Isn't Country or Rap or Even Internet—It's Pure Bliss
.” The Ringer
, April
8
, 2019
.