Schroeder’s essay works to draw critical attention to the aesthetic history of local color, and, more broadly, to the underrecognized relation between local color and realism. In returning local color to its long aesthetic history within painting, Schroeder argues that its primary purpose within realism was not the delineation of regions, but rather the production of an affective and aesthetic engagement with the cosmopolitan project of self-cultivation. The local-color detail was generally not used as a representative detail of a place, but rather, by the late-nineteenth century, as an indexical trace of the invisible truths of an object, and particularly the invisible processes that made human populations distinctive. By bringing this attention to local color’s color, Schroeder aims to move critical debates away from considerations of place-based content of local-color stories and toward a recognition of how local color constituted an aesthetic that could be configured in radically antithetical ways by an archrealist like Mary Murfree and an impressionist like Hamlin Garland. Ultimately, local color helps us see realism not as an indiscriminate, antiliterary, transparent representation of the world, but rather as a highly discriminating, distinctive style that was consistently engaged with the twin principles of human self-cultivation and the neoclassical economy of representation. The example of Garland’s Crumbling Idols has proven so illuminating for this essay precisely because of how it reacts against this formation, as well as how it suggests an alternative, unconscious receptivity to the detail that foreshadows American modernism and regionalism.

References

References
Alden
Henry Mills
Howells
William Dean
, eds.
1906-1907
.
Harper’s Novelettes
.
8 vols
.
London
:
Harper and Brothers
.
Allen
James Lane
.
1886
. “
Local Color
.”
Critic
,
January
9
.
Baldwin
Charles Sears
.
1904
.
American Short Stories
.
New York
:
Longmans, Green
.
Barrish
Phillip
.
2011
.
The Cambridge Introduction to American Literary Realism
.
Cambridge, UK
:
Cambridge Univ. Press
.
Bentley
Nancy
.
2009
.
Frantic Panoramas: American Literature and Mass Culture, 1870-1920
.
Philadelphia
:
Univ. of Pennsylvania Press
.
Berthoff
Warner
.
1959
. “
The Art of Jewett’s Pointed Firs
.”
New England Quarterly
32
, no.
1
:
31
53
.
Botkin
B. A.
1929
. “
The Folk in Literature: An Introduction to the New Regionalism
.”
Folk-Say: A Regional Miscellany
1
, no.
1
:
9
20
.
Bramen
Carrie Tirado
.
2000
.
The Uses of Variety: Modern Americanism and the Quest for National Distinctiveness
.
Cambridge
:
Harvard Univ. Press
.
Brodhead
Richard
.
1993
.
Cultures of Letters: Scenes of Reading and Writing in Nineteenth-Century America
.
Chicago
:
Univ. of Chicago Press
.
Brown
Bill
.
2004
.
The Sense of Things: The Object Matter of American Literature
.
Chicago
:
Univ. of Chicago Press
.
Canby
Henry Seidel
.
1913
. “
The Local Colorists
.” In
A Study of the Short Story
,
56
59
.
New York
:
Henry Holt
.
Carman
Bliss
.
1894
. “
The Verses of Miss Gertrude Hall
.”
Chap-Book
1
, no.
8
:
185
96
.
Charles Egbert Craddock
.”
1885
.
Critic
,
March
14
.
Cross
Anson Kent
.
1895
.
Color Study: A Manual for Teachers and Students
.
Boston
:
Ginn
.
De Piles
Roger
. (
1673
)
1699
.
Dialogue sur Coloris
.
Paris
:
Nicolas Langlois
.
———.
1708
.
Cours de Peinture par Principes
.
Paris
:
Jacques Estienne
.
———.
1743
.
The Principles of Painting
.
London
:
J. Osborn
.
Donovan
Josephine
.
2010
.
European Local-Color Literature: National Tales, Dorfgeschichten, Romans Champêtres
.
New York
:
Continuum
.
Dorman
Robert L.
1993
.
Revolt of the Provinces: The Regionalist Movement in America, 1920-1945
.
Chapel Hill
:
Univ. of North Carolina Press
.
Elliott
Eugene Clinton
.
1958
. “
On the Understanding of Color in Painting
.”
Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism
16
, no.
4
:
453
70
.
Evans
Brad
.
2005
.
Before Cultures: The Ethnographic Imagination in American Literature, 1865-1920
.
Chicago
:
Univ. of Chicago Press
.
Fetterley
Judith
Pryse
Marjorie
.
2003
.
Writing Out of Place: Regionalism, Women, and American Literary Culture
.
Urbana
:
Univ. of Illinois Press
.
Fisher
Philip
.
2000
.
Still the New World: American Literature in a Culture of Creative Destruction
.
Cambridge
:
Harvard Univ. Press
.
Flatley
Jonathan
.
2008
.
Affective Mapping: Melancholia and the Politics of Modernism
.
Cambridge
:
Harvard Univ. Press
.
Foote
Stephanie
.
2001
.
Regional Fictions: Culture and Identity in Nineteenth-Century American Literature
.
Madison
:
Univ. of Wisconsin Press
.
Freeman
Mary Wilkins
.
1892
.
A New England Nun and Other Tales
.
New York
:
Harper and Brothers
.
French
John
.
1922
.
Review of Short Stories of America
by
Ramsay
Robert L.
.
Modern Language Notes
37
, no.
8
:
502
3
.
Fried
Michael
.
1981
.
Absorption and Theatricality
.
Berkeley and Los Angeles
:
Univ. of California Press
.
Garland
Hamlin
.
1894
.
Crumbling Idols: Twelve Essays on Art, Dealing Chiefly with Literature, Painting and the Drama
.
Chicago
:
Stone and Kimball
.
Gaskill
Nicholas
.
2010
. “
Vibrant Environments: The Feel of Color from the White Whale to the Red Wheelbarrow
.”
PhD diss.
,
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
.
Gilder
Richard
.
January
1878
. “
Recent Literature
.”
Scribner’s Monthly
15
, no.
3
:
427
30
.
Hazlitt
William
et al. 
.
1836
. “
On the Fine Arts
.” In
Literary Remains of the Late William Hazlitt
,
193
220
.
New York
:
Saunders and Otley
.
Helmholtz
Hermann von
.
1872
. “
Professor Helmholtz’s Lectures-Painting Optically Considered
.”
Photographic World
2
, no.
15
:
66
70
.
Hetherington
H. J. W.
Muirhead
J. H.
.
1918
.
Social Purpose: A Contribution to the Philosophy of Civic Society
.
London
:
George Allen and Unwin
.
Howells
William Dean
.
1921
. “
A Reminiscent Introduction
.” In
The Great American Stories: An Anthology
,
vii
xiv
.
New York
:
Boni and Liveright
.
Hsu
Hsuan
.
2005
. “
Literature and Regional Production
.”
American Literary History
17
, no.
1
:
36
69
.
James
Henry
.
1875
.
A Passionate Pilgrim and Other Tales
.
Boston
:
James Osgood
.
———.
1886
.
The Bostonians
.
New York
:
Macmillan
.
James
W. P.
1897
. “
On the Theory and Practice of Local Color
.”
Macmillan’s Magazine
76
:
16
23
.
Jewett
Sarah Orne
. (
1877
)
1893
. “
Preface
.” In
Deephaven
,
1
7
.
Boston
:
Houghton Mifflin
.
Jessup
Alexander
, ed.
1923
. “
Preface
.” In
Representative American Short Stories
.
Norwood, MA
:
Allyn and Bacon
.
Johnson
Rossiter
, ed.
1897
.
A History of the World’s Columbian Exposition Held in Chicago in 1893
.
4 vols
.
New York
:
D. Appleton
.
Joseph
Philip
.
2007
.
American Literary Regionalism in a Global Age
.
Baton Rouge
:
Louisiana State Univ. Press
.
Kaplan
Amy
.
1991
. “
Nation, Region, Empire
.” In
The Columbia History of the American Novel
.
New York
:
Columbia Univ. Press
.
Kapor
Vladimir
.
2009
.
Local Colour: A Travelling Concept
.
New York
:
Peter Lang
.
Koselleck
Reinhart
.
2004
. “
Begriffsgeschichte and Social History
.” In
Futures Past: On the Semantics of Historical Time
, translated by
Tribe
Keith
,
75
92
.
New York
:
Columbia Univ. Press
.
Lathrop
G. P.
1884
. “
An American Story Writer
.”
Atlantic Monthly
54
, no.
321
:
131
33
.
Lears
T. J. Jackson
.
1995
.
Fables of Abundance: A Cultural History of Advertising in America
.
New York
:
Basic Books
.
Levine
George
.
1981
.
The Realistic Imagination: English Fiction from Frankenstein to Lady Chatterly
.
Chicago
:
Univ. of Chicago Press
.
Lieberman
Elias
.
1912
.
The American Short Story: A Study of Locality in Its Development
.
Ridgewood, NJ
:
The Editor
.
Lutz
Tom
.
2004
.
Cosmopolitan Vistas: American Regionalism and Literary Value
.
Ithaca, NY
:
Cornell Univ. Press
.
Matthews
Brander
.
1900
.
The Philosophy of the Short Story
.
New York
:
Longmans, Green
.
McLaughlin
M. Louise
.
1888
.
Painting in Oil: A Manual for the Use of Students
.
Cincinnati
:
Robert Clarke
.
McWilliams
Carey
.
1930
.
The New Regionalism in American Literature
.
Seattle
:
Univ. of Washington Book Store
.
Miss Howe’s Atalanta in the South
.”
1886
.
Critic
,
March
20
.
Murfree
Mary
.
1884
. “
Over on T’other Mounting
.” In
In the Tennessee Mountains
,
247
82
.
Boston
:
Houghton Mifflin
.
Nicholson
Francis
.
1823
. “
Of the Local Colour
.” In
The Practice of Drawing and Painting Landscape from Nature, in Water Colours
,
13
15
.
London
:
John Murray
.
Pattee
Fred Lewis
.
1917
.
A History of American Literature since 1870
.
New York
:
Century
.
———.
1923
.
The Development of the American Short Story
.
New York
:
Harpers
.
Puttfarken
Thomas
.
1985
.
Roger de Piles’s Theory of Art
.
New Haven
:
Yale Univ. Press
.
Ramsay
Robert
, ed.
1921
.
The Short-Stories of America
.
Boston
:
Houghton Mifflin
.
Raymond
George Lansing
.
1899
.
Proportion and Harmony of Line and Color in Painting, Sculpture, and Architecture: An Essay in Comparative Aesthetics
.
New York
:
G. P. Putnam
.
Recent Literature
.”
1884
.
Manhattan Illustrated Monthly Magazine
4
, no.
1
:
113
22
.
Recent Novels
.”
1884
.
Nation
,
May
22
.
Rees
Abraham
, ed.
1819
.
The Cyclopaedia; or, Universal Dictionary of Arts, Sciences, and Literature
. Vol.
21
.
London
:
Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown
.
Ruskin
John
.
1843
.
Modern Painters
. Vol.
1
.
London
:
John Wiley
.
Sandoz
Mari
.
1932
. “
Midwestern Writers: FOLK-SAY, A Regional Miscellany
.”
Prairie Schooner
6
, no.
1
:
65
67
.
Satterwhite
Emily
.
2006
. “
Reading Craddock, Reading Murfree: Local Color, Authenticity, and Geographies of Reception
.”
American Literature
78
, no.
1
:
59
88
.
Schor
Naomi
. (
1987
)
2007
.
Reading in Detail: Aesthetics and the Feminine
.
New York
:
Routledge
.
Simpson
Claude M.
, ed.
1960
.
The Local-Colorists: American Short Stories, 1857-1900
.
New York
:
Harpers
.
Smith
Charles Alphonso
.
1912
.
The American Short Story
.
Boston
:
Ginn
.
Smith
Frank H.
, ed.
1893
.
. . . Art, History, Midway Plaisance and . . . World’s Columbian Exposition
.
Chicago
:
Foster Press
.
Smith
Henry Nash
.
1942
.
Review of American Local-Color Stories
, edited by
Warfel
Harry R.
Orians
G. Harrison
; and
Prose and Poetry of Today: Regional America
, edited by
Lucas
Harriet Marcelia
.
American Literature
14
, no.
1
:
101
3
.
Stetson
Elizabeth Mills
.
1907
. “
The Management of Details
.”
Editor
25
, no.
1
:
16
20
.
Stewart
George
.
1948
. “
The Regional Approach to Literature
.”
College English
9
, no.
7
:
370
75
.
Thompson
Maurice
.
1892
. “
Richter, a Painter of Picturesque Portraits
.”
Chautauquan
14
, no.
4
:
453
61
.
Van Brunt
Henry
.
1893
. “
The Columbian Exposition and American Civilization
.”
Atlantic Monthly
71
, no.
427
:
577
88
.
Ware
Sedley Lynch
.
1922a
. “
France and Reconstruction
.”
Sewanee Review
30
, no.
3
:
307
23
.
———.
1922b
. “
Some Effects of the Great War upon France
.”
Sewanee Review
30
, no.
2
:
179
91
.
Warfel
Harry W.
Orians
George Harrison
, eds.
1941
.
American Local-Color Stories
.
New York
:
American Book
.
Warner
Charles Dudley
.
1892
. “
Editor’s Study
.”
Harper’s New Monthly Magazine
85
, no.
505
:
152
56
.
This content is only available as a PDF.