This essay claims that antebellum theatrical star Edwin Forrest registered the era’s investment in oratorical eloquence and anxiety concerning the potentially incendiary nature of free expression in a democracy marked by economic and racial inequality. Forrest’s July 4, 1838, speech in New York’s Broadway Temple has often been cited as evidence of his Jacksonian commitments and, by extension, of the political conservatism of his most famous dramatic roles. Close analysis of the speech and its treatment in the press, however, suggests that Forrest delivered his vision of the peaceable transformation of society in order to recuperate the reputation of the radical Equal Rights Democrats, or “Locofocos,” after the 1837 New York Flour Riot. At the same time, however, Forrest’s performance was “ghosted” by the blood-stained rebels he had portrayed on stage, especially Spartacus of Robert Montgomery Bird’s The Gladiator (1831), and thus it contained an implicit threat of collective violence should working-class speech be curtailed. Moreover, Forrest’s close friendship with abolitionist William Leggett and quotation of Percy Bysshe Shelley’s Queen Mab and Revolt of Islam (among other literary works) indicate that Forrest’s oratorical and theatrical performances could not be wholly dissociated from antislavery discourse and working-class radicalism. This critical restaging of Forrest’s 1838 speech concludes with the suggestion that Forrest’s star power arose in part from the availability of his performances to several political causes.

This content is only available as a PDF.

References

References
Ackerman, Alan.
2003
. “
The Dysfunctional Families of Jacksonian Melodrama
.”
Arizona Quarterly
59
, no.
3
:
31
68
.
Bird, Robert Montgomery. (
1831
)
1997
.
The Gladiator
. In
Early American Drama
, ed. Richards, Jeffrey H.,
173
242
.
New York
:
Penguin
.
Bryant, William Cullen.
1837
. “
The Battlefield
.”
The United States Magazine and Democratic Review
1
, no.
1
:
15
.
———.
1839
. “
William Leggett
.”
United States Magazine and Democratic Review
6
, no.
23
:
430
.
Burrows, Edwin G.; Wallace, Mike.
1999
.
Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898
.
New York
:
Oxford Univ. Press
.
Byrdsall, Fitzwilliam.
1842
.
The History of the Loco-Foco, or Equal Rights Party, Its Movements, Conventions, and Proceedings
.
New York: Clement and Packard
.
Carlson, Marvin.
2001
.
The Haunted Stage: The Theatre as Memory Machine.
Ann Arbor
:
Univ. of Michigan Press
.
Chesebrough, David B.
2002
.
Charles G. Finney: Revivalistic Rhetoric
.
Westport, CT
:
Greenwood Press
.
Cleves, Rachel Hope.
2009
.
The Reign of Terror in America: Visions of Violence from Anti-Jacobinism to Antislavery
.
Cambridge, UK
:
Cambridge Univ. Press
.
Cliff, Nigel.
2007
.
The Shakespeare Riots: Revenge, Drama, and Death in Nineteenth-Century America
.
New York
:
Random House
.
Cmiel, Kenneth.
1990
.
Democratic Eloquence: The Fight over Popular Speech in Nineteenth-Century America
.
Berkeley and Los Angeles
:
Univ. of California Press
.
Cooper, Marilyn M.
2011
. “
Rhetorical Agency as Emergent and Enacted
.”
College Composition and Communication
62
, no.
3
:
420
49
.
Dawson, P. M. S.
1980
.
The Unacknowledged Legislator: Shelley and Politics
.
New York
:
Oxford Univ. Press
.
Earle, Jonathan Halperin.
2004
.
Jacksonian Antislavery and the Politics of Free Soil, 1824-1854
.
Chapel Hill
:
Univ. of North Carolina Press
.
Equal Rights Party
.
1837
.
Declaration of Rights, and Constitution and By-laws of the Equal Rights Party of the City and County of New-York, Adopted at the County Meeting, July, 1837
.
New York
.
Fliegelman, Jay.
1993
.
Declaring Independence: Jefferson, Natural Language, and the Culture of Performance
.
Stanford, CA
:
Stanford Univ. Press
.
Foot, Paul.
1980
.
Red Shelley
.
London
:
Sidgwick and Jackson
.
Forrest, Edwin.
1838
.
Oration Delivered at the Democratic Republican Celebration of the Sixty-Second Anniversary of the Independence of the United States, In the City of New-York, Fourth July, 1838
.
New York
:
Jared W. Bell
.
Gilmore, Michael T.
2010
.
The War on Words: Slavery, Race, and Free Speech in American Literature
.
Chicago
:
Univ. of Chicago Press
.
Gustafson, Sandra M.
2011
.
Imagining Deliberative Democracy in the Early American Republic.
Chicago
:
Univ. of Chicago Press
.
Gustafson, Thomas.
1992
.
Representative Words: Politics, Literature, and the American Language, 1776-1865
.
Cambridge, UK
:
Cambridge Univ. Press
.
The History of Edwin Forrest, The Celebrated American Tragedian, from His Childhood to His Present Elevated Station as Performer.
1837
.
New York
.
Hofstadter, Richard.
1943
. “
William Leggett, Spokesman of Jacksonian Democracy
.”
Political Science Quarterly
58
, no.
4
:
581
94
.
Jefferson, Thomas. (
1787
)
1904-5
.
The Works of Thomas Jefferson, Volume 5: Correspondence 1786-89
, edited by Ford, Paul Leicester.
New York
:
Putnam
. oll.libertyfund.org/title/802/86685.
———. (
1787
)
1982
.
Notes on the State of Virginia
. Edited by Peden, William.
Published for the Institute of Early American History and Culture at Williamsburg, VA
.
Chapel Hill
:
Univ. of North Carolina Press
.
Jones, Sally Leilani.
1992
. “
The Original Characters of Edwin Forrest and His American Style
.”
PhD diss.
,
University of Toronto
.
Leggett, William.
1984
.
Democratick Editorials: Essays in Jacksonian Political Economy by William Leggett
, edited by White, Lawrence H..
Indianapolis, IN
:
Liberty Press
.
Levine, Lawrence W.
1988
.
Highbrow/Lowbrow: The Emergence of Cultural Hierarchy in America
.
Cambridge
:
Harvard Univ. Press
.
Mallett, Mark E.
1993
. “
‘The Game of Politics’: Edwin Forrest and the Jackson Democrats
.”
Journal of American Drama and Theatre
5
, no.
2
:
31
46
.
Martin, Scott C.
1999
. “
Interpreting Metamora: Nationalism, Theater, and Jacksonian Indian Policy
.”
Journal of the Early Republic
19
, no.
1
:
73
101
.
McConachie, Bruce A.
1992
.
Melodramatic Formations: American Theatre and Society, 1820-1870
.
Iowa City
:
Univ. of Iowa Press
.
Meyers, Norman J.
1989-90
. “
Edwin Forrest’s Coriolanus: The Democrat as Aristocrat
.”
Selected Papers from the West Virginia Shakespeare and Renaissance Association
14
:
29
41
.
Miller, Tice L.
2007
.
Entertaining the Nation: American Drama in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries
.
Carbondale
:
Southern Illinois Univ. Press
.
Moody, Richard.
1958
.
The Astor Place Riot
.
Bloomington
:
Indiana Univ. Press
.
———.
1960
.
Edwin Forrest: First Star of the American Stage
.
New York
:
Knopf
.
Moses, Montrose J.
1929
.
The Fabulous Forrest: The Record of an American Actor
.
Boston
:
Little, Brown
.
Mr. Forrest’s Oration
.”
1838
.
The United States Magazine and Democratic Review
3
, no.
9
:
51
57
.
Muller, Gilbert H.
2008
.
William Cullen Bryant: Author of America
.
Albany
:
State Univ. of New York Press
.
Nathans, Heather S.
2009
.
Slavery and Sentiment on the American Stage, 1787-1861: Lifting the Veil of Black
.
Cambridge, UK
:
Cambridge Univ. Press
.
Parker, Edward G.
1857
.
The Golden Age of American Oratory.
Boston
:
Whittemore, Niles, and Hall
.
Rebhorn, Matthew.
2012
.
Pioneer Performances: Staging the Frontier.
New York
:
Oxford Univ. Press
.
Reed, Peter P.
2009
.
Rogue Performances: Staging the Underclasses in Early American Theatre Culture.
New York
:
Palgrave
.
Richards, Jeffrey H., ed.
1997
. “
Introduction to The Gladiator
.” In
Early American Drama
,
166
70
.
New York
:
Penguin
.
Roach, Joseph.
2007
.
It.
Ann Arbor
:
Univ. of Michigan Press
.
Roberts, Stephen.
2003
.
The People’s Charter: Democratic Agitation in Early Victorian Britain
.
London
:
Merlin Press
.
Sabin, Joseph.
1863
.
Catalogue of the Library of Edwin Forest
.
Philadelphia
:
privately printed
.
Sayre, Gordon M.
2005
.
The Indian Chief as Tragic Hero: Native Resistance and the Literatures of America, from Moctezuma to Tecumseh.
Chapel Hill
:
Univ. of North Carolina Press
.
Scrivener, Michael Henry.
1982
.
Radical Shelley: The Philosophical Anarchism and Utopian Thought of Percy Bysshe Shelley
.
Princeton, NJ
:
Princeton Univ. Press
.
Shaaban, Bouthaina.
1996
. “
Shelley and the Chartists
.” In
Shelley: Poet and Legislator of the World
, edited by Bennett, Betty T.; Curran, Stuart,
114
25
.
Baltimore
:
Johns Hopkins Univ. Press
.
Shakespeare, William.
1997
.
The First Part of King Henry the Fourth
. Edited by Hodgdon, Barbara.
Boston
:
Bedford
.
Shelley, Percy Bysshe. (
1821
)
1954
. “
A Defence of Poetry
.” In
Shelley’s Prose, or The Trumpet of a Prophecy
, edited by Clark, David Lee.
Albuquerque
:
Univ. of New Mexico Press
.
Sklansky, Jeffrey.
2012
. “
William Leggett and the Melodrama of the Market
.” In
Capitalism Takes Command: The Social Transformation of Nineteenth-Century America
, edited by Zakim, Michael; Kornblith, Gary J.,
199
221
.
Univ. of Chicago Press
.
Smith, Craig R.
2005
.
Daniel Webster and the Oratory of Civil Religion
.
Columbia
:
Univ. of Missouri Press
.
Smith, Ted A.
2007
.
The New Measures: A Theological History of Democratic Practice
.
New York
:
Cambridge Univ. Press
.
Tetreault, Ronald.
1990
. “
Shelley among the Chartists
.”
English Studies in Canada
16
:
279
95
.
Weinbaum, Paul.
1977
.
Mobs and Demagogues: The New York Response to Collective Violence in the Early Nineteenth Century
.
Ann Arbor
:
Univ. of Michigan Research Press
.
Whitman, Walt. (
1846
)
2010
. “
The Gladiator—Mr. Forrest—Acting
.”
Brooklyn Eagle
,
26
December
. In
The American Stage: Writing on Theater from Washington Irving to Tony Kushner
, edited by Senelick, Laurence,
44
47
.
New York
:
Library of America
.
Wilentz, Sean.
1997
. “
Jacksonian Abolitionist: The Conversion of William Leggett
.” In
The Liberal Persuasion: Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., and the Challenge of the American Past
.
Princeton, NJ
:
Princeton Univ. Press
.
———.
2004
.
Chants Democratic: New York City and the Rise of the American Working Class, 1788-1850
. 20th anniversary edition.
New York
:
Oxford Univ. Press
.