Abstract

Agricultural societies have precursor societies that can be misrepresented in the process of writing agricultural history. Also, the interest in environmental history on labor and nature is rarely applied to Indigenous workers. This article addresses these two issues in the context of Aboriginal people of the Murray River in the region of the Victorian Mallee in southeastern Australia, now premier wheat country. It argues through a close examination of work within a “geography of labor” along the river, that Indigenous people at European contact in the 1840s and long before, labored in afar more successful and sustainable manner than humans did for most of the farm history of this region.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

Notes

1. Richard White,
“‘Are You an Environmentalist or Do You Work for Living?’ Work and Nature,”
in
Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature
, ed. William Cronon (
New York
:
W. W. Norton & Company
,
1996
),
171
72
,
185
.
2. William Dampier,
A New Voyage Round the World
, Vol.
1
, 3rd ed. (
London
:
1698
), quoted in
Sources of Australian History
, ed. Manning Clark (
London
:
Oxford University Press
,
1957
),
25
,
27
.
3. H. R. Allen,
“The Bagundji of the Darling Basin: Cereal Gatherers in an Uncertain Environment,”
World Archaeology
5
:
3
(
1974
):
309
22
;
“Expedition Sent to Explore the Course of the River Darling, in 1835,”
in Major T. L. Mitchell,
Three Expeditions into the Interior of Eastern Australia … in Two Volumes
, Vol.
2
, Chpt. 5; see Norman Tindale’s map in John Mulvaney and Johan Kamminga,
Prehistory of Australia
(
Sydney
:
Allen & Unwin
,
1999
),
86
; R. G. Kimber,
“Beginnings of Farming,”
Mankind
10
:
3
(
1976
):
142
50
.
4. Josephine Flood,
Archaeology of the Dreamtime
(
Sydney
:
Collins
,
1983
),
219
35
; Rupert Gerritsen,
Australia and the Origins of Agriculture
(
London
:
BAR International Series, Archaeopress
,
2008
); Bill Gammage,
The Biggest Estate on Earth: How Aborigines Made Australia
(
Sydney
:
Allen & Unwin
,
2011
),
304
. For a popular account of this theme, see Bruce Pascoe,
Dark Emu, Black Seeds: Agriculture or Accident
(
Broome
:
Magabala Books
,
2014
).
5. Gunther Peck,
“The Nature of Labor: Fault Lines and Common Ground in Environmental and Labor History,”
Environmental History
11
(Apr.
2006
):
214
; Ian Clark and Edward Ryan,
“Ladjiladji Language Area: A Reconstruction,”
Australian Aboriginal Studies
, no.
1
(
2009
):
77
88
.
6. Robert H. Stainthorpe and William Candy,
Reminiscences of the Mallee and Wimmera
(first published in the Warracknabeal Herald,
1925
and
1927
; reprint,
Donvale
:
Lowden Publishing Co.
,
2009
),
17
; James Kirby,
Old Times in the Bush of Australia: Trials and Experiences of Early Bush Life in Victoria during the Forties
(
Melbourne
:
Geo. Robertson and Co.
,
Melbourne
, n.d.),
36
.
7. Gerard Krefft,
“On the Manners and Customs of the Aborigines of the Lower Darling and Murray,”
Transactions of the Philosophical Society of New South Wales, 1862–1865
(
Sydney
:
Reading and Wellbank
),
357
74
,
359
.
8. E. P. Thompson,
“Time, Work-Discipline, and Industrial Capitalism,”
Past and Present
38
(Dec.
1967
):
56
97
; Richard Broome,
“Aboriginal Workers on South-eastern Frontiers,”
Australian Historical Studies
26
(Oct.
1994
),
202
20
;
“Stereotypes & Prejudice of ‘Aboriginal Australia,’”
https://www.creativespirits.info/aboriginalculture/people/stereotypes-prejudice-of-aboriginal-australia (Accessed Sept. 21,
2016
).
9. Roy Rappaport,
“Nature, Culture, and Ecological Anthropology,”
in
Man, Culture, and Society
, ed. Harry L. Shapiro (
London
:
Oxford University Press
,
1971
),
246
.
10. Matt D. White,
“The Mallee Vegetation of North Western Victoria,”
Proceedings of the Royal Society of Victoria
,
118
:
2
(
2006
),
231
.
11. Charles Fenner,
“The Murray River Basin,”
Geographical Review
24
(Jan.
1934
),
79
91
; Charles Sturt,
Two Expeditions into the Interior of Southern Australia during the Years 1828, 1829, 1830 and 1831: With Observations on the Soil, Climate and General Resources of the Colony of New South Wales in Two Volumes
(
London
:
Smith and Elder
,
1933
; reprint,
Sydney
:
Doubleday Australia
,
1982
), Vol.
2
, Chpt. 5.
12.
“Discover Murray Australia’s Greatest River,”
http://www.murrayriver.com.au/about-the-murray/locks-weirs-dams-barrages/; Australian Disaster Resiliance Knowledge Hub https://www.emknowledge.org.au/resource/158/1913/environmental—drought-1913. (Accessed Sept. 21,
2016
).
13. Sturt,
Two Expeditions into the Interior of Southern Australia
,
86
87
,
88
,
86
87
,
91
92
. See also Norman Mackay and David Eastburn, eds.,
The Murray
(
Canberra
:
Murray-Darling Basin Commission
,
1990
).
14. J. M. Bowler, A. Kotsonis, C. R. Lawrence,
“Environmental Evolution of the Mallee Region, Western Murray Basin,”
Proceedings of the Royal Society of Victoria
118
:
2
(
2006
). Meander distance calculated from paddling distances on the Murray over 400 kilometers upstream of Swan Hill. See http://www.massivemurraypaddle.org.au/ (Accessed Feb. 24,
2017
).
Sturt,
Two Expeditions into the Interior of Southern Australia
,
138
.
15. Sturt,
Two Expeditions into the Interior of Southern Australia
,
99
,
126
,
124
; Clark and Ryan,
“Ladjiladji Language Area,”
80
82
.
16. Noel Butlin,
Our Original Aggression: Aboriginal Populations of Southeastern Australia 1788–1850
(
London
:
Allen & Unwin
,
1983
); Kirby,
Old Times in the Bush of Australia
,
28
,
78
; Peter Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina as seen by Peter Beveridge
(
1889
; reprinted,
Donvale
:
Lowden Publishing
,
1908
),
16
; Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
368
69
. For a description of these five biotas, see Jan Penney,
“The Death of Queen Aggie: Culture Contact in the Mid-Murray Region,”
(BA Honors Thesis,
La Trobe University
,
1979
),
10
27
.
17. Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
96
,
98
,
102
; Marshall Sahlins,
Stone Age Economics
, 2nd ed. (
London
:
Routledge
,
2004
),
14
20
.
18. Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
140
41
; Stephen Webb,
“Intensification, Population and Social Change in South-eastern Australia: The Skeletal Evidence,”
Aboriginal History
8
:
2
(
1984
):
170
; Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
360
; Richard Broome,
Aboriginal Victorians. A History since 1800
(
Sydney
:
Allen & Unwin
,
2005
),
147
.
19. Kirby,
Old Times in the Bush of Australia
,
46
; Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
76
.
20. Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
371
.
21. Beth Gott and John Conran,
Victorian Koorie Plants
, 2nd ed. (
Hamilton
:
Yangennanock Women’s Group
,
1998
),
54
57
; Nelly Zola and Beth Gott,
Koorie Plants, Koorie People: Traditional Aboriginal Food, Fibre and Healing Plants of Victoria
(
Melbourne
:
Koorie Heritage Trust
,
1996
),
57
64
; Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
77
; Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
361
.
22. Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
78
; Kirby,
Old Times in the Bush of Australia
,
34
.
23. Harry Allen, ed.,
Australia: William Blandowski’s Illustrated Encyclopedia of Aboriginal Australia
(
Canberra
:
Aboriginal Studies Press
,
2010
),
58
59
,
91
.
24. Sturt,
Two Expeditions into the Interior of Southern Australia
,
114
.
25. Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
80
88
.
26. Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
367
; Allen, ed.,
Australia
,
83
.
27. Marcel Mauss,
The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies
(
London
:
Routledge Classics
,
2002
).
See Marshall Sahlins’s helpful discussion of Mauss’s ideas in his chapter “The Spirit of the Gift,”
Stone Age Economics
(
London
:
Routledge
,
2004
),
186
.
28. Donald Thomson,
Economic Structure and the Ceremonial Exchange Cycle in Arnhem Land
(
Melbourne
:
Macmillan and Co.
,
1949
),
28
,
26
,
33
,
34
; Allen, ed.,
Australia.
29. John Mulvaney,
“‘The Chain of Connection’: The Material Evidence,”
in
Tribes and Boundaries in Australia
, ed. Nicolas Peterson (
Canberra
:
AIAS
,
1976
),
72
94
; Isabel McBryde,
“Exchange in South-Eastern Australia: An Ethnohistorical Perspective,”
Aboriginal History
8
:
2
(
1984
),
132
54
, especially
150
; Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
366
; Isabel McBryde,
“Wil-im-ee Moor-ring: Or, Where Do Axes Come From?”
Mankind
11
:
3
(
1978
):
354
82
.
30. Edward John Eyre,
Journals of Expeditions of Discovery into Central Australia and Overland from Adelaide to King George’s Sound
,
2
Vols. (
London
:
T & W Boone
,
1845
), Vol.
1
,
vi
.
31. Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
142
; W. Wooster,
“How the Lerp Crystal Palace is Built,”
Microscopical Society of Victoria
,
1880
, quoted in Tim Low,
“Exuding Abundance,”
in
Birdlife Australia
(Dec.
2012
); David C. Paton,
“The Importance of Manna, Honeydew and Lerp in the Diets of Honeyeaters,”
in
Emu-Austral Ornithology
80
:
4
(
1980
):
213
26
.
32. Low,
“Exuding Abundance”
; Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
143
.
33. Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
142
,
145
.
34. John Burch,
“The Wirrengren-Kulkyne Pathway: Locating a Cultural Icon,”
Victorian Historical Journal
87
:
2
(
2016
):
261
78
; Eyre,
Journals of Expeditions of Discovery.
35. Eyre,
Journals of Expeditions of Discovery
, Vol.
1
,
350
.
36.
“From Kulnine to Kulkyne — Reminiscences of “Charley” Thompson of Kulkyne, 1850s to 1920s,”
Nangiloc, Colignan & District, http://nangiloc.vic.au/history/reminiscences-charley-thompson-kulkyne-1850s-1920s/ (Accessed Sept. 21,
2016
).
37. Eyre,
Journals of Expeditions of Discovery
, Vol.
1
,
371
.
38. Wikipedia, s.v.
“Murray River,”
last modified Feb. 21,
2017
, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_River (Accessed Feb. 24,
2017
); Beveridge,
The Aborigines of Victoria and Riverina
,
96
; Kirby,
Old Times in the Bush of Australia
,
76
; Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
360
.
39. Kirby,
Old Times in the Bush of Australia
,
28
; Krefft,
“On the Manners,”
359
; Kerin O’Dea,
“Introduction,”
in
Zola and Gott
,
Koorie Plants, Koorie People
,
ix
; Sahlins,
Stone Age Economics
,
32
39
.
40. Sahlins,
Stone Age Economics
,
38
.