Abstract

New ways of understanding milk purity accompanied the introduction of veterinary antibiotics to the dairy farm. Antibiotics—once viewed as substances that could rid milk of bacterial hazards—became understood as food adulterants when residues of the drugs were detected in milk. Although consumers’ concerns about food purity became critical in the postwar era, only in the late 1950s and early 1960s did public health officials and consumers take interest in the potential human health effects of antibiotic residues. Veterinarians and milk processors, not consumers, led the effort to curb indiscriminate use of antibiotics in the 1940s and 1950s. Paying close attention to the context in which farmers chose to use antibiotics and monitored drug residues, this article seeks to explain why farm people adopted veterinary drugs and how they adapted to new regulatory structures and shifting ideas about milk purity.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

Notes

1 John Shover, First Majority—Last Minority: The Transforming of Rural Life in America (DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 1976)
Gilbert Fite, American Farmers: The New Minority (Bloomington: University of Indiana, 1981), 143–313
J. L. Anderson, Industrializing the Corn Belt: Agriculture, Technology, and the Environment (DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press, 2009)
Mary Douglas, Purity and Danger: An Analysis of the Concept of Pollution and Taboo (London: Routledge, 1966)
Mary Douglas and Aaron Wildavsky, Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technological and Environmental Dangers (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1982).
2 James Harvey Young, Pure Food: Securing the Federal Food and Drugs Act of 1906 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989), 265–67,292–93
Lorine Swainston Goodwin, The Pure Food, Drink, and Drug Crusaders, 1879–1914 (Jefferson, NC: McFarland and Company, 1999), 11.
3 Judith Walzer Leavitt, The Healthiest City: Milwaukee and the Politics of Health Reform (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1982), 156–89
Richard Meckel, Save the Babies: American Public Health Reform and the Prevention of Infant Mortality, 1850–1929 (Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press, 1990), 62–91
Jacqueline Wolf, Don’t Kill Your Baby: Public Health and the Decline of Breastfeeding in the 19th and 20th Centuries (Columbus: Ohio State University Press, 2001), 42–73
Barbara Gutman Rosenkrantz, "The Trouble with Bovine Tuberculosis," Bulletin of the History of Medicine 59 (Summer 1985): 155–75
Thomas Pegram, "Public Health and Progressive Dairying in Illinois," Agricultural History 65 (Winter 1991): 36–50.
4 Ralph Lutts, "Chemical Fallout: Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring, Radioactive Fallout, and the Environmental Movement," Environmental Review 9 (Autumn 1985): 210–25
Paul S. Boyer, By the Bomb’s Early Light: American Thought and Culture at the Dawn of the Atomic Age (New York: Pantheon, 1985), 89–92
Samuel P. Hays, Beauty, Health, and Permanence: Environmental Politics in the United States, 1955–1985 (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 172–73
Robert Gottlieb, Forcing the Spring: The Transformation of the American Environmental Movement (Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993), 81–93
Lawrence Buell, "Toxic Discourse," Critical Inquiry 24 (Spring 1998): 645–47
Christopher Sellers, "Body, Place, and the State: The Makings of an ’Environmentalist’ Imaginary in the Post–World War II US," Radical History Review 74 (Winter 1999): 38–40
Adam Rome, "’Give Earth a Chance’: The Environmental Movement and the Sixties," Journal of American History 90 (Sept. 2003): 526.
5 Rachel Carson, Silent Spring (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1962), 178–79.
Lewis Herber, "The Problems of Chemicals in Food," Contemporary Issues 3 (June/Aug. 1952): 206–41
Barry Commoner, Science and Survival (New York: Viking, 1963), 90–120.
Hays, Beauty, Health, and Permanence, 22–26
Adam Rome, The Bulldozer in the Countryside: Suburban Sprawl and the Rise of American Environmentalism (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2001)
Lizabeth Cohen, A Consumers’ Republic: The Politics of Mass Consumption in Postwar America (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2003).
6 John Duffy, The Sanitarians: A History of American Public Health (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1990), 239.
Joshua Blu Buhs, "Dead Cows on a Georgia Field: Mapping the Cultural Landscape of Post–World War II American Pesticide Controversies," Environmental History 7 (Jan. 2002): 99–121.
7 A. P. Brodeel and M. R. Cooper, "Milking Machines are War Tools," Hoard’s (Fort Atkinson, Wise.) Dairyman, Apr. 25,1944, 229.
Journal July 31, 1931–Apr. 1948, Item 5, Box 2, Elihu Gifford Papers, SC18734, New York State Archives and Special Collections, Albany, NY (hereafter Gifford Papers).
United States Census of Agriculture: 1950, General Report Farm Facilities, Roads, Trading Center, Equipment, Vol. II, Chpt. Ill (Washington, DC: GPO, 1952), 201.
United States Census of Agriculture, 1959, General Report. Volume II, Chapter III, Farm Facilities, Farm Equipment (Washington, DC: GPO, 1962), 205.
Ralph Little and Wayne Plastridge, eds., Bovine Mastitis: A Symposium (New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., 1946), 395
Daniel Noorlander, Milking Machines and Mastitis (Compton, Calif.: Compton Press, 1960).
8 Anon., "Herd Health: Mastitis," Hoard’s Dairyman, Feb. 25, 1945, 135
G S. Bryan, "Prevention and Control of Mastitis," Hoard’s Dairyman, Mar. 10, 1941,146
Plastridge and Little, Bovine Mastitis, 167
Virginia Hollerith to Bristow, Jan. 19, 1945
Hollerith Family Papers, MS Ih 7235b, Box 1, Hollerith Family Papers, 1904–1985, Virginia Historical Society, Richmond, Va.
9 Gertrude Mallary to A. L. Hamelin, Feb. 12, 1946, Doc. 496, Folder 37
General Correspondence, 1946
Mallary Farm Records, MS Accession Number 2002.11, Vermont Historical Society, Barre, Vt.; Frank Hill, interview with Lu Ann Jones, May 4, 1987, Folder 10, Box 18
An Oral History of Southern Agriculture, Archives Center, National Museum of American History, Washington, DC; "Herd Health," 135, 163
Bryan, "Prevention and Control of Mastitis," 177.
10 Plastridge and Little, Bovine Mastitis, 167.
Terry Summons, "Animal Feed Additives, 1940–1966," Agricultural History 42 (Oct. 1968): 305–13
Suzanne White, "The Chemogastric Revolution and the Regulation of Food Chemicals," in Chemical Sciences in the Modern World, ed. Seymour Masukopf (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1993), 322–55
William Boyd, "Making Meat: Science, Technology, and American Poultry Production," Technology and Culture 42 (Oct. 2001): 646–49
Mark Finlay, "Hogs, Antibiotics, and the Industrial Environments of Postwar Agriculture," in Industrializing Organisms: Introducing Evolutionary History, ed. Philip Scranton and Susan Schrepfer (New York: Routledge, 2004), 242–46
Roger Horowitz, Putting Meat on the American Table: Taste, Technology, Transformation (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006); Anderson, Industrializing the Corn Belt, 91–102.
L. C. Harold to Kneeland, Nov. 2,1960, Box 2822, General Subject Files, 1938–1974
Louis J. Boyd et al., "Effects of Feeding Aureomycin to Lactating Dairy Cows," Journal of Dairy Science 43 (May 1960): 668–73
Anon., "Feed Aureomycin to Your Dairy Cows?" Successful Farming 59 (May 1961): 81
Mike Bay, "What Can Additives do for Ruminants?" Successful Farming 59 (Dec. 1961): 50–51.
Hoard’s Dairyman, Apr. 10, 1952, 363.
Mar. 10, 1949 issue of Hoard’s Dairyman featured Squibb’s "instant-use" penicillin, Wyeth’s penstix, and American Cyanimid’s Veticillin Ointment.
Jan. 26, 1956, advertisments for liquid terramycin, Pen-FZ, New True antibiotic, and Dr. Legear "Hypozyme," whose ingredients included papain, penicillin, dihydrostreptomycin, sulfathiazole, sulfanilamide, and cobalt sulfate appeared. Hoard’s Dairyman, Mar. 10, 1949, 215, 237, 238
Hoard’s Dairyman, Jan. 25, 1956, 54, 61, 73, 83.
Aureomycin advertisement, American (New York, NY) Druggist, Apr. 14, 1952, 64
Tribiotic Ointment Advertisement, American Druggist, Mar. 31, 1952, 42
"Many Brands of Mastitis Preps Displayed to Meet All Demands," American Druggist, June 2, 1958, 68.
11 Anderson, Industrializing the Corn Belt, 25
Chief of the Bureau of Dairy Industry, "Excerpts from the Annual Report of the Chief of the Bureau of Dairy Industry," Journal of Milk and Food Technology 11 (Mar./Apr. 1948): 110
J. L. Albright et al., "Antibiotics in Milk: A Review," Journal of Dairy Science 44 (May 1961): 787–88
Henry Welch et al., "Antibiotics in Fluid Market Milk: Third Nationwide Study," Antibiotics and Chemotherapy 6 (May 1956): 369–74
Henry Welch, "Control of Antibiotics in Food," Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law Journal 12 (Aug. 1957): 464
H. G Hodges, "Veterinary Antibiotic Use Increases," Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 138 (June 1961): 19.
12 Department of Health, Education, and Welfare Press Release, Sept. 2, 1960, Box 2822, FDA General Subject Files.
Marcella Palmer Blanchard to James S. Delaney, Mar. 27, 1961. Box 1, Series 1, James S. Delaney Papers, APAP-241, University at Albany Special Collections, Albany, NY (hereafter Delaney papers); Marcus, Cancer from Beef, 57.
13 Susan Jones, Valuing Animals: Veterinarians and Their Patients in Modern America (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2003), 63–73.
14 Plastridge and Little, Bovine Mastitis, 413
American Veterinary Medical Association, "Penicillin Has Limitation," Hoard’s Dairyman, July 10, 1947, 585
Daniel Noorlander et al., Mechanics and Production of Quality Milk (Madison: Democrat Printing Company, 1965), 280
American Foundation for Animal Health advertisement, Hoard’s Dairyman, June 25, 1947, 536.
15 Plastridge and Little, Bovine Mastitis, 365
American Veterinary Medical Association, "Penicillin Has Limitation"
Noorlander et al., Mechanics, 280.
16 Journal July 31, 1931–Apr. 1948, Item 5, Box 2, Gifford Papers
L. Dale and Veleanor Beall Farm Records, 1949, 1952, Apple River, Ill. (Farm record books in the possession of the author); Wyeth tribiotic advertisement, Hoard’s Dairyman, Apr. 10, 1952, 330.
17 John Collins, "The Food and Drug Administration and the Practicing Veterinarian," American Veterinary Medical Association Journal 127 (Sept. 1955): 204–206
Joe S. Taylor, "The Therapeutic Value of Antibiotics Used Promiscuously to Treat Bovine Mastitis," Thirty-First Annual Report of the New York State Association of Milk Sanitarians, 1957 (Albany: New York State Association of Milk Sanitarians, 1958), 89–97.
18 Alec Bradfield et al., "Presence of Aureomycin in Milk and its Effect on Cheese Production," Journal of Dairy Science 35 (Jan. 1952): 51, 56–57
H. Katznelson and E. G. Hood, "Influence of Penicillin and Other Antibiotics on Lactic Streptococci in Starter Cultures used in Cheddar Cheese-making," Journal of Dairy Science 32 (Nov. 1949): 961–68
C. S. Bryan, "Problems Created for the Dairy Industry by Antibiotic Mastitis Treatments," Journal of Milk and Food Technology 14 (Sept./Oct. 1951): 161–62
Bureau of Dairy Industry, 1944–1953, RG 152
A. E. Groth to Secretary of Agriculture, Aug. 24, 1960, Folder Insecticides Apr. 21–June 20, Box 3455, General Correspondence, 1906–1975, Records of the Secretary of Agriculture, RG 16, National Archives and Records Administration II
Theodore Marcus to USDA Dairy Division, Mar. 8, 1950
Herbert LaBrash to San Francisco District FDA office, Mar. 16,1959, Box 2650
19 W. H. Rotherty, "Milk Quality Control Program in the City of Auburn," TwentySecond Annual Report of the New York State Association of Milk Sanitarians, 1948 (Albany: New York State Association of Dairy and Milk Inspectors, 1948), 89
Anon., "Federal Inspection of Dairy Products," Hoard’s Dairyman, June 10, 1947, 475
D. N. McDowell, "The Milk House Requirement," Milk Dealer 42 (Nov. 1952): 104–106.
20 W. A. Krienke, "ADSA Antibiotic Control Program," Milk Dealer 41 (Oct. 1951): 104–105
Wisconsin Cheese Makers’ Association, Resolution Number Seven, Proceedings of the Wisconsin Cheese Makers’ Association Sixtieth Annual Meeting, October 24–25, 1951 (Madison: Cantwell Print Company, 1951), 43–44
Administrative Procedure Act, Title 21, § 3.25, Federal Register, 16 (Aug. 21, 1951): 8270.
21 Wisconsin Cheese Makers’ Association, Proceedings of the Wisconsin Cheese Makers’ Association, 44.
22 F. V. Kosikowski, "The Antibiotic Adulteration of Milk," Thirty-First Annual Report, 81–87
Gordon Thompson to Chief of Minneapolis District office, Feb. 15, 1960, Box 2817
Jan. 27, 1960 meeting, Box 2820, FDA General Subject Files.
23 "Annual Report of the Food and Drug Administration," Annual Report of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, 1953 (Washington, DC: GPO, 1953), 112
Welch, "Control of Antibiotics," 465–68; Henry Welch, "Problems of Antibiotics in Food as the Food and Drug Administration Sees Them," American Journal of Public Health 47 (June 1957): 705
Welch et al., "Antibiotics in Fluid Market Milk," 571–73
Wallace Janssen, "Antibiotic Contamination a Threat to Milk," Milk Plant Monthly (July 1956): 24
F. V. Kosikowski et al., "Incidence of Antibiotics, Sulfa Drugs, and Quarternary Ammonium Compounds in the Fluid Milk Supply of New York State," Journal of Dairy Science 6 (June 1952): 533–39
F. A. Siino et al., "Incidence of Penicillin in the Market Milk Supply of a Local New England Area," Journal of Milk and Food Technology 21 (Oct. 1958): 211–13.
24 Welch, "Control of Antibiotics," 466–68
H. R. Vickers et al., "Dermatitis Caused by Penicillin in Milk," Lancet 1 (Feb. 1958): 377
H. D. Kautz, "Penicillin and Other Antibiotics in Milk," JAMA 171 (Sept. 5,1959): 135–37
Welch, "Problems of Antibiotics in Food," 704
Krienke to Dunbar, Feb. 24, 1950
Lehman to Dunbar, Mar. 2, 1950
Dunbar to Krienke, Mar. 16, 1950, Box 1959, FDA General Subject Files
FDA, Annual Report, 1957 (Washington, DC: GPO, 1958), 208–209
FDA, Bureau of Program Planning and Appraisal, "Investigational Program, Antibiotics and Pesticide Residues in Fluid Market Milk," Aug. 1, 1958, Box 2650, FDA General Subject Files. An Oxford unit is equivalent to 0.6 micrograms
M. R. Stephens, "Policies and Programs Concerning Antibiotic and Pesticide Residues in Milk," Journal of Dairy Science 43 (Apr. 1960): 581.
25 Anon., "Science Notes: Ways to Preserve Living Eye Tissue—Penicillin in Milk," New York Times, Dec. 16, 1956, E9
J. I. Rodale, "Is there Penicillin in Your Milk?" Prevention 1 (July 1955): 99
J. I. Rodale, "Don’t Drink Milk," and "What They Have Done to the Cow," Prevention 8 (Feb. 1956): 12–13, 20, 67–70
Anon., "Dangerous Drugs?" Newsweek, Jan. 12, 1953, 74
W. L. Laurence, "Lifesaving Drugs Can Harm You," Ladies’ Home Journal 70 (Jan. 1953): 43
S. S. Schneierson, "Hazards of Antibiotics," Consumer Reports 18 (Apr. 1953): 162–64
Anon., "Antibiotics in the Food Supply" 18 (Aug. 1953): 347.
26 John Harvey, "What can Industry Do to Help Solve Problems of Antibiotics and Insecticides?" Food Law and Cosmetic Law Journal 15 (Apr. 1960): 256–62
Roger Wilkowske to Sam Fine, Dec. 7, 1959, Box 2650, FDA General Subject Files.
27 Shelbey Gray to Chiefs of Districts, Sept. 28, 1959
C. W. Burch to John Harvey, Oct. 28, 1959, Box 2650, FDA General Subject Files.
28 Ray Clark to George Clarke, Feb. 16, 1960, Box 2818; Kraft Foods pamphlet, Box 2821
Clyde Russell, Group Discussion Held at Michigan State University, Dec. 22, 1959
Nevis Cook, Boston District FDA Report, Dec. 11, 1959
Nevis Cook to FDA Administration, Dec. 11, 1959, Box 2650
A. M. Meekman to County Agricultural Agents, Dec. 28, 1959, Box 2818, FDA General Subject Files.
29 Cliff Shane to Kansas City District, Jan. 7, 1959, Box 2650
Jerome Trichter to George Larrick, Mar. 16, 1960, Box 2821, FDA General Subject Files.
30 Green Bay MS 104, Folder 14, Box 3, Consolidated Badger Dairy Cooperative Records, 1931–1981
31 Wesley Sawyer to Oren Harris, Mar. 22, 1960
K. M. Autrey to George P. Larrick, May 31, 1960
32 Marcus, Cancer from Beef 4–7, 55–57
Thomas Dunlap, DDT: Scientists, Citizens, and Public Policy (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1981)
Christopher J. Bosso, Pesticides and Politics: The Life Cycle of a Policy Issue (Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1987), 66–67
Linda Lear, "Bombshell in Beltsville:The USDA and the Challenge of ’Silent Spring,’" Agricultural History 66 (Spring 1992): 151–70
Pete Daniel, Toxic Drift: Pesticides and Health in the Post-World War II South (Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press, 2005), 71–83, 101–29.
33 Kurt Weckel, "Aspects of Pesticides and Antibiotics as They Relate to the Dairy Industry," Journal of Milk and Food Technology 23 (Sept. 1960): 277.
34 Taylor, "The Therapeutic Value of Antibiotics," 96 (emphasis mine)
Harold Irvin, "Survey of Nebraska Veterinarians on Mastitis and the Antibiotic Problem," Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 138 (Jan. 1961): 17–19.
35 Cohen, Consumers’ Republic, 345–47, 357–63
Marcus, Cancer from Beef, 62–63
Robert Bud, "Antibiotics, Big Business, and Consumers: The Context of Government Investigations of the Postwar American Drug Industry," Technology and Culture 46 (Apr. 2005): 329–49.
Drug Control Bill, HR 1235, 87th Cong., 2nd. Sess., Congressional Record 108 (Sept. 27, 1962), H21058–21083.
Fritz Blumenthal to Delaney, Oct. 22, 1969
Elise Jerard to Delaney, Dec. 15, 1969
Raymond Overland to Delaney, July 31, 1971
"Antibiotics in animal feed, Department of Health Education and Welfare," Apr. 19, 1973
36 W. D. Schultze, "Antibiotics in Treatment of Mastitis," in Agricultural Uses of Antibiotics, ed. William A. Moats (Washington, DC: American Chemical Society, 1986), 24–25, 28–29
H. Williams Smith, "The Effects of the Use of Antibiotics on the Emergence of Antibiotic-Resistant Disease-Producing Organisms in Animals," in Antibiotics in Agriculture: Proceedings of the University of Nottingham Ninth Easter School in Agricultural Science, 1962, ed. Malcolm Woodbine (London: Butterworths, 1962), 374–75
Robert Courter and Mildred Galton, "Animal Staphylococcal Infections and their Public Health Significance," American Journal of Public Health 52 (Nov. 1962): 1822.
Great Britain’s Joint Committee on Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Medicine urged restrictions on veterinary drugs also used to treat human diseases in 1969.
"The Swann Report," Journal of the American Veterinary Medicine Association 157 (July 1,1970): 13–15.
37 Jones, Valuing Animals, 91–114
Weckel, "Aspects of Pesticides and Antibiotics," 277–80.
38 Douglas, Purity and Danger, 44–45.