Abstract

The transition to synthetic chemicals as a popular method of insect control in the United States was one of the most critical developments in the history of American agriculture. Historians of agriculture have effectively identified the rise and charted the dominance of early chemical insecticides as they came to define commercial agriculture between the emergence of Paris green in the 1870s and the popularity of DDT in the 1940s and beyond. Less understood, however, are the underlying mechanics of this transition. This article thus takes up the basic question of how farmers and entomologists who were once dedicated to an impressively wide range of insect control options ultimately settled on the promise of a chemically driven approach to managing destructive insects. Central to this investigation is an emphasis on the bureaucratic maneuverings of Leland O. Howard, who headed the Bureau of Entomology from 1894 to 1927. Like most entomologists of his era, Howard was theoretically interested in pursuing a wide variety of control methods--biological, chemical, and cultural included. In the end, however, he employed several tactics to streamline the government’s efforts to almost exclusively support arsenic and lead-based chemical insecticides as the most commercially viable form of insect control. While Howard in no way "caused" the national turn to chemicals, this article charts the pivotal role he played in fostering that outcome.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

Notes

1 The Practical Entomologist 1:4 (1865): 119
J. K. Hanzlik, "Health Hazards of Chemo-Enemies in Contaminated Food," Scientific Monthly 44 (May 1937): 439
USDA, Chronological History of the Development of Insecticides and Control Equipment from 1854 through 1954 (Washington, DC: USDA Agricultural Research Service, 1954)
Thomas R. Dunlap, DDT: Scientists, Citizens, and Public Policy (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1981), 39-55.
2 James Whorton, Before Silent Spring: Pesticides and Public Health in Pre-DDT America (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1974), xii
Richard C. Sawyer, To Make a Spotless Orange: Biological Control in California (Ames: Iowa State University Press, 1996), xix
V. G. Dethier, Man’s Plague?: Insects and Agriculture (Princeton: Darwin Press, 1976)
John Perkins, Insects, Experts, and the Insecticide Crisis: The Quest for New Pest Management Strategies (New York: Plenum Press, 1982)
Willis Conner Sorensen, Brethren of the Net: American Entomology, 1840-1880 (Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama Press, 1995)
Paolo Palladino, Entomology, Ecology, and Agriculture: The Making of Scientific Careers in North America, 1885-1985 (Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers, 1996)
Edmund Paul Russell, "War on Insects: Warfare, Insecticides, and Environmental Change in the United States, 1870-1945" (PhD diss., University of Michigan, 1993)
Hae-Gyung Geong, "Exerting Control: Biology and Bureaucracy in the Development of American Entomology, 1870-1930" (PhD diss., University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1999)
Steven Stoll, "Insects and Institutions: University Science and the Fruit Business in California," Agricultural History 69 (Spring 1995): 216-39.
3 Charles E. Rosenberg, "Science, Technology, and Economic Growth: The Case of the Agricultural Experiment Station Scientist, 1875-1914," in No Other Gods: On Science and American Social Thought (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University.Press, 1978), 153-72
Robert Kohler, "Warren Weaver and the Rockefeller Foundation Program in Molecular Biology: A Case Study in the Management of Science," in The Sciences in the American Context, ed. Nathan Reingold (Washington, DC: Smithsonian, 1979), 249-93
Alexandra Oleson and John Voss, eds., Organization of Knowledge in Modern America, 1860-1920 (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1979)
Geong, "Exerting Control," 50-60
Trudy H. Peterson, Farmers, Bureaucrats, and Middlemen: Historical Perspectives on American Agriculture (Washington, DC: Howard University Press, 1980)
Gerald Geison, "Scientific Change, Emerging Specialties, and Research Schools," History of Science 19 (Mar. 1981): 20-40.
4 Geong, "Exerting Control," 48
L. O. Howard, Fighting the Insects: The Story of an Entomologist (New York: MacMillan, 1933), 8
Arnold Mallis, American Entomologists (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1971), 79-92
Pamela Henson, "The Comstock Research School in Evolutionary Entomology," Osiris 8 (2nd Series, 1993): 158-77.
Palladino, Entomology, Ecology, and Agriculture, 26-27
Pamela Henson, "Evolution and Taxonomy: J. H. Comstock’s Research School in Evolutionary Entomology at Cornell University, 1874-1930" (PhD diss., University of Maryland, 1990), 405-406.
Rosenberg, No Other Gods, 153-60
Samuel H. Adams, "Leland Ossian Howard," American Magazine 72 (1911): 721-23
F. C. Bishopp, "Leland Ossian Howard Centennial, 1857-1957," Bulletin of Entomological Society of America 3 (1957): 1-3.
5 Charles E. Rosenberg, "Rationalization and Reality in the Shaping of American Agricultural Research, 1875-1914," Social Studies of Science 1 (Nov. 1977): 401
Richard Hofstadter, The Age of Reform: From Bryan to FDR (New York: Vintage Books, 1955), 148-64
Charles V. Riley, "Recent Advances in Economic Entomology," Proceedings of the Philosophical Society of Washington, Feb. 2, 1884, 10
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 3, 8-9.
F. H. Fowler, Insecticides and their Application (Boston: Wright and Potter, Apr. 1891)
James E. McWilliams, American Pests: Our Losing War on Insects from Colonial Times to DDT (New York: Columbia University Press, 2008), 113.
Leland O. Howard, Fighting the Insects, 3, 214
T. W. Harris, A Report of the Insects of Massachusetts Injurious to Vegetation (Cambridge, Mass.: Folson, Wells, and Thurston, 1841), v.
Howard, A History of Applied Entomology (Somewhat Anecdotal) (Washington, DC: Smithsonian, 1930), 536.
6 Rosenberg, "Rationalization and Reality," 401
Hofstadter, The Age of Reform, 148-64
Riley, "Recent Advances in Economic Entomology," 10
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 3.
Fowler, Insecticides and their Application, 3.
I. Bernard Cohen, Revolution in Science (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1985), 325-27.
Hae-Gyung Geong, "Carving a Niche for Medical Entomology: A Quest for Professional Identity in American Entomology," American Entomologist 47 (Winter 2001): 23643
Geong, "Exerting Control," 199
Howard, A History of Applied Entomology, 536.
7 "Agricultural Experiment Stations," Western Stock Journal and Farmer 6 (1877): 246.
Hofstadter’s Age of Reform and Elizabeth Sanders, Roots of Reform: Farmers, Workers, and the American State, 1877-1917 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999)
Rosenberg, No Other Gods, 153-72
Robert Weibe, The Search for Order, 1877-1920 (1967; repr., New York: Hill and Wang, 1992), 1-25.
8 S. A. Forbes, "Synopsis of Recent Work with Arsenical Insecticides," Transactions of the Illinois Horticultural Society 23 (1890): 319
E. V. Wilcox, "Some Results of Experiment Station Work with Insecticides," Annual Report of the Office of Experiment Stations for the Year Ended June 30, 1905 (Washington, DC: GPO, 1906), 250
Insect Life 4 (Nov. 1891): 154
John B. Smith, "Insecticide Experiments for 1904," New Jersey Agriculture Experiment Stations, Bulletin No. 178 (1904): 3-5
F. W. Malley, "The Boll Worm of Cotton," USD A, Division of Entomology, Bulletin No. 24 (1891): 41-43
"Reports of Observations and Experiments in the Practical Work of the Division," USDA, Division of Entomology, Bulletin No. 3 (1883): 20-23
"Dosing Trees with Sulphur and Other Substances," Insect Life 1 (Jan. 1889): 223
"Alum as a Current Worm Remedy," Insect Life 1 (Jan. 1889): 229-30
J. K. Haywood, "Insects and Fungicides," USDA, Farmers’ Bulletin No. 146 (1902): 12.
Palladino, Entomology, Ecology, and Agriculture, 29-31.
9 F. M. Webster, "Reports of Experiments with Various Insecticide Substances," USDA, Division of Entomology, Bulletin No. 11 (1886): 9-22
C. H. Fernald, "The Association of Economic Entomologists—Address by the President..." Science 94 (Oct. 16, 1896): 544
Rosenberg, No Other Gods, 153-72.
10 A. S. Packard Jr., "The Mode of Extrication of Silk-Worm Moths from their Cocoons," American Naturalist 12 (June 1878): 379
L. Trouvelot, "The American Silk Worm (Concluded)," American Naturalist 1 (May 1867): 145-49
"A Dangerous Insect Pest in Medford, Mass.," Science 14 (Dec. 6, 1889): 381-82
Howard, "Danger of Importing Insect Pests," USDA Yearbook (Washington, DC: GPO, 1897), 529-52
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 95.
11 H. Kirkland to General Appleton, Jan. 15, 1906, Folder 118
H. M. Aiken to "the editor," Feb. 9, 1906, Folder 112, Box 10
C. S. Sargeant to General Appleton, Apr. 12, 1905, Folder 112, Box 15, MS N517, Massachusetts Historical Society, Boston, Mass.
Russell, "War on Insects," 42.
L. O. Howard and W. F. Fiske, "The Importation into the United States of the Parasites of the Gypsy Moth and the Brown Tail Moth," USDA, Bureau of Entomology, Bulletin No. 91 (1911): 305
Sawyer, To Make a Spotless Orange, 62-63
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 91.
12 Russell, "War on Insects," 42-47
W. D. Hunter, "The Boll Weevil Problem," USDA, Farmers’ Bulletin No. 344 (1909): 46
Richard C. Sawyer, "Monopolizing the Insect Trade: Biological Control in the USDA, 1888-1951," Agricultural History 64 (Apr. 1990): 276
Frederick W. Malley, "The Mexican Cotton Boll Weevil," USDA, Farmers’ Bulletin No. 130 (1901): 23
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 156.
13 Thomas R. Dunlap, "The Triumph of Chemical Pesticides in Insect Control," Environmental Review 1:5 (1978): 42-45.
14 C. H. T. Townsend, "Letters and Reports received from C. H. T. Townsend," in Records of the Division of the Southern Crop Insect Investigations, National Archives
Russell, "War on Insects," 42-47
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 156
Mallis, American Entomologists, 391
Malley, "The Mexican Cotton Boll Weevil," 23
Hunter, "The Boll Weevil Problem," 46
Sawyer, "Monopolizing the Insect Trade," 276
L. O. Howard, "The Mexican Cotton-Boll Weevil," USDA, Division of Entomology, Circular No. 6 (1895): 1-5
L. O. Howard, "The Mexican Boll Weevil," USDA, Division of Entomology, Circular No. 14 (1896): 1-8
Dunlap, DDT, 31
Howard, A History of Applied Entomology, 128.
15 Howard, History of Applied Entomology, 129-31
B. R. Coad, "Killing Boll Weevils with Poison Dust," USDA Yearbook (Washington, DC: GPO, 1920), 241-52
B. R. Coad, "Recent Studies of the Mexican Cotton Boll-Weevil," USDA, Farmers’ Bulletin No. 231 (1915): 1-34
Dunlap, "The Triumph of Chemical Pesticides," 39-42.
16 L. O. Howard, "Insect Enemies of Shade Trees," USDA, Farmers’ Bulletin No. 99 (1899): 10-25.
Howard, "A Study in Insect Parasitism," USDA, Division of Entomology, Technical Series No. 5 (1897): 6
Howard, "Danger of Importing Insect Pests," Yearbook of the United States Department of Agriculture, 1897 (Washington, DC: GPO, 1898).
Edmund Russell, War and Nature: Fighting Humans and Insects with Chemicals from World War I to Silent Spring (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001), 64-66.
17 L. O. Howard, "Progress in Economic Entomology in the United States," Yearbook of Department of Agriculture (Washington, DC: GPO, 1899): 135-56.
18 Mallis, American Entomologists, 78-86
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 116-38
Robert Matheson, A Handbook of Mosquitoes of North America (Springfield, Ill.: C. C. Thomas, 1929), 66-71
L. O. Howard, Mosquitoes: How they Live; How They Carry Disease; How they are Classified; How they May Be Destroyed (New York: McClure, Phillips, 1901), 167-73
E. O. Essig, A History of Entomology (New York: Macmillan Co., 1931), 909
Gordon Harrison, Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Man: A History of the Hostilities Since 1880 (New York: Dutton, 1978), 167-68.
19 L. O. Howard, "An Experiment against Mosquitoes," Insect Life 5 (1892-93): 12-14
L. O. Howard, "Another Mosquito Experiment," Insect Life 6 (1893-94): 92-93
Howard, Mosquitoes, 172-73.
20 Andrew Spielman and Michael D’Antonio, Mosquito: A Natural History of Our Most Persistent and Deadly Foe (New York: Hyperion, 2001), 86-92
Harrison, Mosquitoes, Malaria, and Man, 72-80.
www.cdc.gov/malaria/history/ross.htm (page last modified Dec. 6, 2004).
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 53, 116
Mallis, American Entomologists, 81.
Yearbook of the United States Department of Agriculture, 1897
Howard, "An Experiment Against Mosquitoes," 12-14
L. O. Howard, "Mosquitoes as Transmitters of Disease," Review of Reviews 24 (1901): 192-95
L. O. Howard, "How to Distinguish the Different Mosquitoes of North America," USDA, Division of Entomology, Circular No. 40 (1900): 1-7.
21 Howard, Mosquitoes, 167-219.
22 C. E. Wilson, "The Anopheles Mosquito in Relation to Malaria and Agriculture," Florida Buggist 1 (Sept. 21, 1917): 18-19, 22-23
Geong, "Exerting Control," 269-71
Howard, A History of Applied Entomology, 465-76.
23 Robert Matheson, A Handbook of the Mosquitoes of North America (Baltimore: Charles C. Thomas, 1929), 59-75
L. L. Williams and S. S. Cook, "Paris Green Applied by Airplane in the Control of Anopheles Production," Office of Public Health, Public Health Report Reprint No. 1140 (1927): 459.
24 Joseph M. Ginsburg, "Airplane Oiling to Control Mosquitoes," Science 75 (May 20, 1932): 542
Joseph M. Ginsburg, "Studies of Pyrethrum as a Mosquito Larvicide," Proceedings of the lTh Annual Meeting of the New Jersey Mosquito Extermination Association (np: np, 1930), 57
Williams and Cook, "Paris Green Applied by Airplane," 459
Edgar E. Foster, "Mosquito Control on Hydroelectric Projects," Scientific Monthly 37 (Dec. 1933): 529.
Thomas J. Headlee, The Mosquitoes of New Jersey and Their Control (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 1945), 289-300
Paul F. Russell, "Automatic Distribution of Paris Green for Malaria Control," Journal of Parasitology 919 (Mar. 1933): 215-24
no author, "Rockefeller Foundation Leads World Fight on Disease," Science News-Letter 8 (Jan. 1926): 3.
25 L. O. Howard, "Entomology and the War," Scientific Monthly 8 (Feb. 1919): 109-17
Howard, Fighting the Insects, 138-39
J. S. Ames, "The Trained Man of Science in the War," Science 48 (Oct. 25, 1918): 403
A. Hunter Dupree, Science in the Federal Government: A History of Policies and Activities to 1940 (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1957), 324
Russell, War and Nature, 20, 75-78
Avner Offer, The First World War: An Agrarian Interpretation (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1989)
Howard, "’On Some Presidential Addresses’: The War Against the Insects," Science 54 (Dec. 30, 1921): 641-51
L. O. Howard, "US Wages Insect War," Science News-Letter 10 (Nov. 20, 1926): 127
R. H. Hutchinson, "A Maggot Trap in Practical Use: An Experiment in House Fly Control," USDA, Bulletin No. 200 (1915): 1-15.
26 Howard, "Entomology and the War," 109-111.
27 Ibid.
28 Ibid., 114
Maurice C. Hall, "Parasites in War Time," Scientific Monthly (Feb. 1918): 112
F. C. Cooke, R. H. Hutchison, and F. M. Scales, "Further Experiments in the Destruction of Fly Larvae in Horse Manure," USDA, Bulletin No. 245 (1915).
29 W. Moore, "Fumigation of Animals to Destroy their External Parasites," Journal of Economic Entomology 9 (1916): 71-78.
30 Howard, "Entomology and the War," 113
Hall, "Parasites in War Time," 112
"Microbe and Bug Killers," New York Times, Dec. 13, 1917, 17
"Board Announces Enlarged Embargo," New York Times, Oct. 22, 1917, 6
"Makers of Disinfectants are Told to Excel if They are Not To Fall Behind Foreigners," New York Times, Dec. 12, 1916, 15
R. F. Bacon, "The Industrial Fellowships of the Mellon Institute," Science 45 (Apr. 27, 1917): 402
E. Dwight Sanderson, Insect Pests of Farm, Garden, and Orchard (New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1921), 670.
31 Howard, "Entomology and the War," 116.
32 Hall, "Parasites in War Time," 107
Dunlap, DDT, 36-37
A. L. Melander, "Fighting Insects with Powder and Lead," Scientific Monthly 36 (Feb. 1933): 168.
Dethier, Man’s Plague? 146.
33 Russell, War and Nature, 21.
34 E. B. Blakeslee, "Use of Toxic Gases as a Possible Means of Control of the Peach Tree Borer," USDA, Division of Entomology, Bulletin No. 796 (1919): 1-7
Russell, War and Nature, 30-35
Charles H. Herty, "The Expanding Relations of Chemistry in America," Science 44 (Oct. 6, 1916): 481-83.
35 USDA, Chronological History.
Elton W. Downs and George F. Lemmer, "Origins of Aerial Crop Dusting," Agricultural History 39 (Summer 1965): 130-32.