Abstract

During the cattle boom of the late nineteenth century, homesteaders at either end of the Great Plains raised livestock in conjunction with the cultivation of crops. In order to support their small herds of cattle, these individuals relied on unfettered access to grass and especially water, a resource in short supply on the semi-arid prairies of Texas and Alberta. Larger ranchers and cattle syndicates resented the challenge posed by the settlers and feared the competition for water and grass. Supported by officials in Austin and Ottawa--who favored rapid industrial development on the Plains--cattlemen seized control of the range by fencing pastures and water holes and evicting squatters. When homesteaders resisted this exclusion, government authorities dispatched their rural constabularies--the Texas Rangers and the North-West Mounted Police--to protect a closed but embattled range.

The text of this article is only available as a PDF.

Notes

1
Macleod Gazette
,
Mar. 9
,
1886
.
2 David H. Breen ,
The Canadian Prairie West and the Ranching Frontier, 1874–1924
(Toronto: University of Toronto Press,
1983
)
3 Frederick Rathjen ,
The Texas Panhandle Frontier
(Austin: University of Texas Press,
1973
)
J. Evetts Haley ,
Charles Goodnight: Cowman & Plainsman
(Norman: University of Oklahoma Press,
1949
)
4 J. Evetts Haley , "And Then Came Barbed Wire to Change History’s Course," The CattlemenXIII (
Mar.
1927
):
80
.
5 Walter Prescott Webb, The Great Plains (1931; repr., Waltham, Mass.: Blaisdell, 1959), 270-318
Henry D. and Frances T. McCallum,
The Wire that Fenced the West
(Norman: University of Oklahoma Press,
1965
)
John M. Hendrix , "The Nester: He Originated in West Texas . . . And He’s an Honored Citizen,"
West Texas Today
,
Feb.
1934
, from PanhandlePlains Historical Museum, Canyon, Texas [hereafter PPHM]
6 William Curry Holden ,
The Spur Ranch: A Study of the Inclosed Ranch Phase of the Cattle Industry in Texas
(Boston: Christopher Publishing House,
1934
),
65
Thomas Lloyd Miller ,
The Public Lands of Texas, 1519–1970
(Norman: University of Oklahoma Press,
1972
)
Randolph B. Campbell ,
Grass-Roots Reconstruction in Texas, 1865–1880
(Baton Rouge: Louisiana State University Press,
1997
)
7 Miller, The Public Lands of Texas, 145-84
Andrew C. Isenberg , "
Environment and the Nineteenth-Century West; or, Process Encounters Place
," in
A Companion to the American West
, ed. William Deverell (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing,
2004
),
77
-92
"
Two Faces West: The Development Idea in Canada and the United States
," in
One West, Two Myths: A Comparative Reader
, ed. Carol Higham and Robert Thacker (Calgary: University of Calgary Press,
2004
),
23
-45
8
Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Texas, 1883
(Austin: State Printer, 1883),
21
-28
Paul F. Starrs ,
Let the Cowboy Ride: Cattle Ranching in the American West
(Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press,
1998
),
110
-24
Donald Abbe , "
Ranching and Speculation in Lynn County, Texas, 1876–1930
," in
Working the Range: Essays in the History of Western Land Management and the Environment
, ed. John Wunder (Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press,
1985
),
81
-97
9 Hugh A. Dempsey ,
The Golden Age of the Canadian Cowboy
(Saskatoon: Fifth House Publishers,
1995
),
7
Breen, The Canadian Prairie West, 9-10
Simon M. Evans ,
Prince Charming Goes West: The Story of the E. P. Ranch
(Calgary: University of Calgary Press,
1993
),
33
-61
10 Matthew H. Cochrane to John A. Macdonald, Dec. 17, 1880, File 13, Box 1, David Breen National Archives of Canada Ranching Collection [hereafter NACRC], Glenbow-Alberta Institute, Calgary, Alberta [hereafter GAI]
Breen, The Canadian Prairie West, 18-19
11 Cordia Sloan Duke and Joe B. Frantz,
6,000 Miles of Fence: Life on the XIT Ranch of Texas
(Austin: University of Texas Press,
1961
).
12 Breen, The Canadian Prairie West, 21,101.
13 Hugh G. J. Aitken ,
The State and Economic Growth
(New York: Social Science Research Council,
1959
),
79
-114
Henry Klassen ,
Eye on the Future: Business People in Calgary and the Bow Valley
(Calgary: University of Calgary Press,
2002
),
9
-37
14 his booksThe Fur Trade in Canada: An Introduction to Canadian Economic History (
1930
; repr., New Haven: Yale University Press, 1962)
The Cod Fisheries: The History of an International Economy
(New Haven: Yale University Press,
1940
)
15 Holden, The Spur Ranch, 65
R. D. Holt , "The Introduction of Barbed Wire into Texas and the Fence Cutting War," West Texas Historical Association Year BookVI (
June
1930
):
70
16 Holden, The Spur Ranch, 68-73.
17 Herbert O. Brayer, "The Influence of British Capital on the Western Range-Cattle Industry," Journal of Economic HistoryIX (1949):
96
.
18 J. M. Neeson ,
Commoners: Common Right, Enclosure, and Social Change in England, 1700–1820
(New York: Cam¬ bridge University Press,
1993
)
Keith Wrightson ,
Earthly Necessities: Economic Lives in Early Modern Britain
(New Haven: Yale University Press,
2000
)
Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Texas, 1883, 27–28
19 Wayne Gard , "The Fence Cutters," Southwestern Historical Quarterly60 (July1947):
1
-15.
20 Holt, "The Introduction of Barbed Wire," 76
R. D. Holt , "The Saga of Barbed Wire in the Tom Green Country," West Texas Historical Association Year Book4 (June1928):
39
21 Robert M. Utley ,
Lone Star Justice: The First Century of the Texas Rangers
(New York: Oxford University Press,
2002
),
234
Holt, "The Introduction of Barbed Wire," 74
22
Message of Governor John Ireland to the Eighteenth Legislature, Convened in Special Session, at the City of Austin, January 8,1884
(Austin: State Printer, 1884)
H. P. N. Gammel , ed.,
The Laws of Texas, 1882–1897
(Austin: Gammel Book Company,
1898
), Vol.
IX
,
Part II
,
566
23 Breen, The Canadian Prairie West, 20.
24
Macleod Gazette
,
Aug. 24
, Sept. 23,
1882
John O’Beirne Ranelagh, A Short History of Ireland (1983; repr., New York: Cambridge University Press, 1994), 129-51
25
Macleod Gazette
,
Mar. 24
,
1883
.
26 Edward Brado ,
Cattle Kingdom: Early Ranching in Alberta
(Vancouver: Douglas & Mclntyre,
1984
),
182
Evans, Prince Charming Goes West, 47-48
27 Breen, The Canadian Prairie West, 57.
28 Canada, Department of the Interior ,
Annual Report
,
1885
,
19
-20.
29 William Pearce to H. Stanley Pinhorne, Sept. 27,1886, File 24, Box 1 (enclosed in letter from William Pearce to minister of the interior, Nov. 11,1886), NACRC, GAI
D. H. Breen, "The Canadian Prairie West and the ’Harmonious’ Settlement Interpre¬ tation," Agricultural HistoryAl (Winter1973):
70
Donald Worster ,
Rivers of Empire: Water, Aridity, and the Growth of the American West
(New York: Oxford University Press,
1985
)
30 William Pearce, unaddressed, May 7,1889, File 33, Box 2
S. B. Steele to NWMP Commissioner, Oct. 17,1891, File 53, Box 2, NACRC, GAI
31 Andrew R. Graybill, "Instruments of Incorporation: Rangers, Mounties, and the North American Frontier, 1875–1910" (PhD diss., Princeton University, 2003), 41–54,118–27
32 Terry G. Jordan ,
North American Cattle Ranching Frontiers: Origins, Diffusion, and Differentiation
(Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press,
1993
)
Robert R. Dykstra ,
The Cattle Towns
(New York: Knopf,
1968
)
Leora Bruch ,
Banister Was There
(Fort Worth: Branch-Smith,
1968
),
1
-12
33 G. B. Greer to L. P. Sieker, Aug. 26,1884, Folder 9, Box 401–405
L. P. Sieker to W. H. King, Aug. 8,1884, Folder 8, Box 401-405, General Correspondence [here¬ after GC], Adjutant General Records [hereafter AGR], Texas State Library and Archives, Austin, Texas [hereafter TSLA]
34
Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Texas, December 1884
(Austin: State Printer, 1884),
28
D. D. Sanderson to John Ireland, Jan. 10,1885, Folder 1, Box 401–406, GC, AGR, TSLA
35 T. R. Havins ,
Something About Brown: A History of Brown County, Texas
(Brownwood, Tex.: Banner Printing,
1958
),
33
^0
Harold Preece ,
Lone Star Man: Ira Aten, Last of the Old Texas Rangers
(New York: Hastings House,
1960
)
36 L. P. Sieker, June 11,1887, Vol. XI, Box 2R289, Walter Prescott Webb Papers [hereafter WPWP], Center for American History, University of Texas at Austin [hereafter CAH]
Havins, Something About Brown, 39
37 Ira Aten ,
Six and One-Half Years in the Ranger Service: The Memoirs of Ira Aten, Sergeant Company D, Texas Rangers
(Bandera, Tex.: Frontier Times,
1945
),
20
-22 (In his memoirs, Aten incorrectly remembers the year as 1887)
Ira Aten to L. P. Sieker, Aug. 31,1888, Folder 19, Box 401–412, GC, AGR, TSLA
41 Ira Aten to L. P. Sieker, Oct. 8,1888, Folder 6, Box 401–413, GC, AGR, TSLA
Aten, Six and One-Half Years, 22
42 Breen, "The ’Harmonious’ Settlement Interpretation," 72.
43 David H. Breen , "
The Mounted Police and the Ranching Frontier
," in
Men in Scarlet
, ed. Hugh A. Dempsey (Calgary: McClelland & Stewart,
1974
),
117
Sheilagh Jameson ,
Ranches, Cowboys, and Characters: Birth of Alberta’s Western Heritage
(Calgary: GlenbowAlberta Institute,
1987
),
7
,16
44 Breen, "The Mounted Police," 118.
45 Warren M. Elofson ,
Cowboys, Gentlemen & Cattle Thieves: Ranching on the Western Frontier
(Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press,
2000
),
99
-133
Fred White to unknown correspondent, Jan. 4,1889, File 43, Vol. 26, Series A-l, RG 18, National Archives of Canada, Ottawa [hereafter cited as NAC]
"Annual Report of the Minister of the Interior for the Year Ended 30th June, 1881: Part II, North-West Mounted Police Force,"
Sessional Papers
,
1882
, XV, Vol.
8
, No.
18
, Canada Parliament, p.
24
Louis S. Warren ,
The Hunter’s Game: Poachers and Preservationists in Twentieth-Century America
(New Haven: Yale University Press,
1997
),
126
-51
46 Maple Creek, May 5,1894
N.W. Territories, Nov. 30, 1895, File 184, Vol. 105, Series A-l, RG 18, NAC
Maple Creek, Sept. and Oct. 1897, File 9, Vol. 127, Series A-l, RG 18, NAC
David Spector ,
Agriculture on the Prairies, 1870–1940
(Ottawa: Parks Canada,
1983
),
27
^2
File 27, Vol. 38, Series A-l, RG 18, NAC
47 William Pearce to secretary of the Department of the Interior, Oct. 23, 1894, File 141376, Part II, Vol. 1204
A. M. Burgess to T. Mayne Daly, Apr. 30, 1894, File 352945, Vol. 1241, RG 15, NAC
48 Fred White to deputy minister of the interior, June 12,1894, File 72, Vol. 116, Series A-1, RG 18
George B. Jonas to the minister of the interior, June 19, 1894, File 352945, Vol. 1241, RG 15
John Hall, undated, File 352945, Vol. 1241, RG 15, NAC
File 23, Vol. 101, Series A-1, RG 18, NAC
William Pearce to John Herron, Nov. 4,1895, File 141376, Part II, Vol. 1204, RG 15, NAC
49 Preece, Lone Star Man, 228-35
50 Lynwode Pereira to Fred White, Sept. 19, 1895, File 72, Vol. 116
Sam Steele, Nov. 1895, File 46, Vol. 102, Series A-1, RG 18, NAC
51 Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Texas, 1888, 48–49
52 James A. Smart to Frank Oliver, June 17,1897, File 141376, Part III, Vol. 1204, RG 15
A. Power to deputy minister of the interior, Nov. 21,1896, File 72, Vol. 116, Series A-1, RG 18, NAC
53 Donna A. Barnes ,
Farmers in Rebellion: The Rise and Fall of the Southern Farmers Alliance and People’s Party in Texas
(Austin: Univer¬ sity of Texas Press,
1984
)
Laurence Goodwyn ,
Democratic Promise: The Populist Moment in America
(New York: Oxford University Press,
1976
)
54 J. Arthur Lower ,
Western Canada: An Outline History
(Vancouver: Douglas & Mclntrye,
1983
),
316
Havins, Something About Brown, 37
55 Ira Aten to L. P. Sieker, Sept. 17, 1888, Folder 4, Box 401–413, GC, AGR,TSLA
56 Duke and Frantz, 6,000 Miles of Fence, 107.
57 Simon Evans , "The End of the Open Range Era in Western Canada,"
Prairie Forum
8
(Spring1983):
71
-87
David C. Jones, Empire of Dust: Settling and Abandoning the Prairie Dry Belt (1987; repr., Calgary: University of Calgary Press, 2002)
Donald Worster ,
Dust Bowl: The Southern Plains in the 1930s
(New York: Oxford University Press,
1979
)